Which of these MLB players do you think will get into the Hall

[frogsrangers]

Ichrio
Griffey Jr
Halladay
Pudge
Mariano Rivera

[lakerboy]

Mariano
Griffey
Ichiro

[DOM_Toretto]

Mariano
Griffey
Ichiro

Yup

[goduke]

Everyone but halladay I think. Pudge was easily the first or 2nd best catcher during his time.

[frogsrangers]

Everyone but halladay I think. Pudge was easily the first or 2nd best catcher during his time.

Do you think his connection to those 90s Rangers teams that were all roided up could keep him out?

[DOM_Toretto]

Pudge was the saving grace of the all-time worst Tigers

[BuckyOne]

I like all of their chances. There are HOF'rs and then super - mega - HOF'rs. Hope we don't have to have a Superstar HOF!

[RonPaul2008]

Griffey Jr., imo, was the best non-roid player in at least 3 decades.

[upscope]

Pudge in

[seaborneq]

All of them will get in. Sandman, Griffey and Ichiro will be first ballot hall of famers. The other will eventually get in. Pudge will get in and Halladay. Halladay is the most underrated of all of these players. Curt Shilling/Nolan Ryan rolled up into one.

[JAKEPEAVY21]

all are locks but Halladay..he is borderline

[goduke]

Do you think his connection to those 90s Rangers teams that were all roided up could keep him out?

No i dont think so because he wasnt really ever mentioned when the whole scandal broke out. Plus he was quite a talent right when he came in at 19.

[rm18]

Ichiro and Halladay are close others are locks. Pudge and Mariano are first ballot locks

[ttwarrior1]

u people joking? do u all watch baseball

[44 Mag]

Mariano
Griffey
Ichiro

Agreed !!!

[Chi_archie]

of course Pudge gets in, guy was an all-time great catcher. forget about just against his contemporaries

Catcher JAWS Leaders

Glossary · SHARE · Embed · CSV · Export · PRE · LINK · ?

1	Johnny Bench HOF	75.0	47.1	61.0	17	1967	1983	14	2158	8674	7658	1091	2048	381	24	389	1376	68	43	891	1278	.267	.342	.476	.817	126	*25379/8
2	Gary Carter HOF	69.9	48.2	59.1	19	1974	1992	11	2296	9019	7971	1025	2092	371	31	324	1225	39	42	848	997	.262	.335	.439	.773	115	*293/75
3	Ivan Rodriguez	68.4	39.7	54.0	21	1991	2011	14	2543	10270	9592	1354	2844	572	51	311	1332	127	64	513	1474	.296	.334	.464	.798	106	*2D/34
4	Carlton Fisk HOF	68.3	37.5	52.9	24	1969	1993	11	2499	9853	8756	1276	2356	421	47	376	1330	128	58	849	1386	.269	.341	.457	.797	117	*2D7/35
5	Mike Piazza	59.4	43.1	51.2	16	1992	2007	12	1912	7745	6911	1048	2127	344	8	427	1335	17	20	759	1113	.308	.377	.545	.922	142	*2D3
6	Yogi Berra HOF	59.5	37.0	48.2	19	1946	1965	18	2120	8359	7555	1175	2150	321	49	358	1430	30	26	704	414	.285	.348	.482	.830	125	*279/35
7	Bill Dickey HOF	55.8	34.2	45.0	17	1928	1946	11	1789	7065	6300	930	1969	343	72	202	1209	36	32	678	289	.313	.382	.486	.868	127	*2
8	Mickey Cochrane HOF	52.1	36.9	44.5	13	1925	1937	2	1482	6207	5169	1041	1652	333	64	119	830	64	45	857	217	.320	.419	.478	.897	129	*2/O
	Avg of 13 HOFers at this position

[jjgold]

Hall of Fame seems to not mean as much anymore

People do not care

Its all about he present in sports