greatest player ever all time in all 4 major sports

[THam12]

Maradona naw.

[spider]

only one GREAT one in any sport.smashed all records and made all his teammates allstars. WAYNE GRETZKY.

[MickeyMan]

Listen.


Gretzky was awesome. He had nowhere near as much talent as Mario. Mario was dominant. If Mario played in Waynes early years with the players wayne played with he might have gotten 240 points.

If talent is your argument then what about bobby orr?

[MickeyMan]

Baseball- Bonds
Football- Elway
Hockey- Roy
Basketball- Barkley
Soccer- Solo
Tennis- Williams
Golf- Woods

Just because hope solo's clit is almost as long as your cokk, it does not make her the best soccer player ever bear.

[BEANTOWNJIM]

Gretzky couldn't play in today's game i think he weighed 170 pounds in today's game he wouldn't last a week without getting killed

[broadway6]

Baseball- Bonds
Football- Elway
Hockey- Roy
Basketball- Barkley
Soccer- Solo
Tennis- Williams
Golf- Woods

You can't honestly believe this list is correct? 0-7

[broadway6]

Gretzky couldn't play in today's game i think he weighed 170 pounds in today's game he wouldn't last a week without getting killed

Jemmmmmmy!!!! Where you been?

[BEANTOWNJIM]

Did all the hockey guys forget about a man named bobby orr

[Petey Wheatstraw]

Jim Thorpe

[spider]

Gretzky couldn't play in today's game i think he weighed 170 pounds in today's game he wouldn't last a week without getting killed

Gretzky had all the goons after him, in every shift he played, but they couldn't catch him. he ran circles around
them, embarrassing them, which resulted in penalties that turned into more goals.
and there was no overtime, if there was he'd have a riot playing 4 on 4.

[ByeShea]

Baseball - Ruth (pitching is the clincher)
Football - Brady
Hockey - Orr
Basketball- bird

[TheLock]

Baseball- gehrig

LOL.

Great guy but, LOL.


Ted Williams, boys.

[Spedizzo]

Baseball: Babe Ruth
Football: Tom Brady
Basketball: Michael Jordan
Hockey: Wayne Gretzky
Rugby: Leigh Halfpenny

[allang198]

I thought you said American sports are for assholes and we are all pussies. Who cares about your opinion JERK OFF! Unless you are jealous and BRADY is not even in the conversation stupid fuk.

Ur the stupid fuk!

Ur mom droped u on ur head and done some permanent damage!

[Auto Donk]

Andre the Giant

greatest athlete overall: has to be that woman that won the decathalon..... no, not Babe Didrikson, but tather "Belinda" Jenner f/k/a "Bruce"

greatest nfl player double murderer: Orenthal James Simpson

greatest mlb punching bag: Robin Ventura

[lakerboy]

LOL.

Great guy but, LOL.


Ted Williams, boys.

lock you have a hangover pal?

lol at lou gehrig? you okay?

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/r/ruthba01.shtml

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/g/gehrilo01.shtml

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/w/willite01.shtml

tell me how gehrig did?

[stevenash]

^
Actually you can make a case for Gehrig, but this is where the comparison goes south, Ruth pitched.
My vote is still Ruth, he has more shutouts pitched than Randy Johnson, and for a fat whale, he was fast.

Football is LT
Golf is Jack.
Tennis is Margaret Court
Basketball is MJ (Russell belongs in the conversation)
Hockey is Messier, without Messier Gretzky is not nearly as famous.

[DOM_Toretto]

NHL - Gordie Fukkin Howe

[Spedizzo]

Babe Ruth is the best

just watch The Sandlot

[stevenash]

Babe Ruth is the best

just watch The Sandlot

He was a beast.
4 1/2 tool player.

[jjgold]

The tennis greats like Serena, Fed, Nadal and Joker rank up there with everyone because of unreal physical demands/weather conditions and the sport all year around and everyone in world guns for them weekly many much younger..they defy logic

They never fukkin quit

[Spedizzo]

tennis is not a big 4 sport

[k13]

Bonds better than all mlb listed...

Not even a debate...

[DOM-Ganador]

JIM BROWN?? Has to be in discussion, no?

[stevenash]

Did all the hockey guys forget about a man named bobby orr

Mike Bossy was better.

[stevenash]

JIM BROWN?? Has to be in discussion, no?

Yes, without a doubt, and if somebody puts him #1 I would respect that.

[Jayvegas420]

Putting Orr & Lemieux ahead of Gretz & Mr. Hockey is nonsensical & shows your lack of history in that particular sport. No one & I mean NO ONE dominated their sport more thoroughly than Wayne Gretzky. If Orr's knees.....if lemieux's back....blah blah...

If I tried harder & did t get hurt when I was 11 I could have been the greatest...
Doesn't mean that I am.

Basketball us the same.

Football & baseball are a little different because of positionality.

[DrunkHorseplayer]

Lawrence Taylor
Mike Schmidt
LeBron James
Mario Lemieux (not close)

[Big Bear]

Just because hope solo's clit is almost as long as your cokk, it does not make her the best soccer player ever bear.

haha i just think she is hot man.

i have never watched a womens soccer game.

and when i say she is hot i am factoring in her personality. I love that fire that she has.

[Big Bear]

Bonds better than all mlb listed...

Not even a debate...

thank you!

atleast somebody here has a fukkin clue!

Just watching Barry Bonds step into the batters box would give me chills. The type of dude that watching him play causes the hair on your arms and back stand up.

Amazing player. Definitely worth the ticket price to see him.

[stevenash]

Lawrence Taylor
Mike Schmidt
LeBron James
Mario Lemieux (not close)

Michael Jack Schmidt.

The greatest 3rd baseman of all time.
Not even up for debate.
Almost 550 homeruns, 10 gold gloves.......

[stevenash]

thank you!

atleast somebody here has a fukkin clue!

Just watching Barry Bonds step into the batters box would give me chills. The type of dude that watching him play causes the hair on your arms and back stand up.

Amazing player. Definitely worth the ticket price to see him.

Cheater, plus Ruth was better.
How many games did Bonds win? How many strikeouts did he have?

[Jayvegas420]

Positionality

[ByeShea]

Just watching Barry Bonds step into the batters box would give me chills.

Same here - but this was only after he went into orbit ('roids).

I've never seen anything like it, that .700 OBA and practically standing on top of the plate - and the arm pads - and slapping singles out of the park. Totally unreal, surreal. Was fun while it lasted, but no way any of those dudes go in the hall. Tell you the truth, most of the players in that era (including Saint Mariano, but there are too many to list) are suspect as hell.

Griffey, Jr / Thome / Frank Thomas - these players probably did not do steroids, as the arc of their performance relative to age a mirrored that generations of baseball players before them. The game of baseball and the way it's played essentially doesn't change.

[TheLock]

lock you have a hangover pal?

lol at lou gehrig? you okay?




tell me how gehrig did?

I'll tell you how Gehrig did:

He had a career WAR of 116.3

Ted Williams had a career WAR of 130.4