Jimmy Rollins is a Hall of Famer

[dlunc3]

Cue the haters

[The Giant]

Every baseball writer says otherwise, but if you say he is, I'll take your word for it.

[t-wizzle]

You're listening 97.5 I guess.

[dlunc3]

You're listening 97.5 I guess.

Na I hate Mikey Miss.. Ellis and Gargano are much better.

Buddy at work trying to tell me he's not.

[dlunc3]

Every baseball writer says otherwise, but if you say he is, I'll take your word for it.

Its really not even close. He can almost be considered in the elite class

[The Giant]

Its really not even close. He can almost be considered in the elite class

First ballot?

Unanimous?

[dlunc3]

First ballot?

Unanimous?

He probably won't be, but should. Compare his numbers with hall of fame short stops.

[sourtwist]

Love threads that are made just to piss people off

[downsouth]

I agree and think he gets close to maddox vote totals from last year

[jjgold]

lol

Drunks

[dlunc3]

Love threads that are made just to piss people off

you mean to discuss sports in players talk? who would ever think to do that?

[Punta de Mita]

Good player but not a HOF'er. Not even close

[will2survive]

not even a great player nevermind hall of famer. Was a good player with one MVP season; nothing else

[Big Bear]

honestly what i dont get is why people care about individual awards like this.

baseball is a team game.

only award that matters IMO are World Series trophies.

[Punta de Mita]

not even a great player nevermind hall of famer. Was a good player with one MVP season; nothing else

^this

[dlunc3]

Good player but not a HOF'er. Not even close

His numbers shatter many hall of fame short stops. His numbers put him in the elite hall of fame short stop category

[dlunc3]

Best short stop in the nl in his generation and its not even close.

[Chi_archie]

similar stats to Alan Trammel and it doesn't look like he is getting in either

[stevek173]

no chance