Does Randy Johnson get into the HOF on the first ballot?

[frogsrangers]

He was a good lefty but was pretty low key and quiet, apart from 2001 Diamondbacks never really pitched for a contender or even a major market team until he played for the Yankees past his prime.

Do you still think he will get in when they vote in January?

[BatemanPatrickl]

The dead bird votes NO.

[Chi_archie]

he pretty low key and quietly won 4 straight Cy Young awards with a total of 5 of them in his career

[Shark]

No question he gets in first ballot

[MUHerd37]

Absolutely. Guy was great.

[jjgold]

Yes

In his prime top five most dominant pictures of all time

[Chi_archie]

2nd all time in strikeouts to nolan ryan

1 no-hitter 1 perfect game

300 wins, and I bet he didn't have 100 career wins before he turned 30

as previously mentioned 5 cy young trophys plus 3 2nd place finishes

[DiggityDaggityDo]

The dead bird votes NO.

FIrst ballot for this alone.



Also... mullet.

And he was great in Joe Dirt.

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Will he go in as a Mariner or a Dback?

[Chi_archie]

Will he go in as a Mariner or a Dback?

expo

[GUMMO77]

Will he go in as a Mariner or a Dback?

Redneck

[whtsox13]

Si.

[Pauulzcappin]

how is this even debatable... even the konerko hof thread was better, at least there was some actual discussion on it

[Cuse0323]

No doubter

[upscope]

Easy~

[boeing power]

If he's not a first ballot guy , nobody is.

High peak and longevity.

[Dirty Sanchez]

These old geezer voters have some serious issues...until many of them die off there are players that have no shot

[will2survive]

YES---A 1st Ballot HOF'er

[STAX]

best lefty in the last 30 years