Matthew Stafford considered a bust yet?

[Deuce]

#1 pick. 4 of his 5 years horrid QB rating. Top 10 in pay. Hasn't won shit.

[No coincidences]

At least we paid him like the star that he isn't.

[Deuce]

At least we paid him like the star that he isn't.

Not saying much but best QB Detroit has had in decades.

[jjgold]

Another bad year and i woud release him

Two biggest winners ever in Detroit

Isaiah and Rodman

[Ghenghis Kahn]

he sucks when it counts.

the whole team sucks.

bunch of clowns running around like gorillas.

[easyliving]

needs a better coach

[CMNoney]

Reserving judgement untill I see him under a real coach.

[MUHerd37]

Inaccurate and does too much stupid shit. Acts like Brett Favre too much.

[BigDeem5]

He is a worse Romo.

Not a winner and doesn't even have QB Rating or TD/INT ratio of Romo.

He is a garbage time/fantasy QB.

[homie1975]

the head coach is the problem

[packerd_00]

No question about it,he single handely threw last weeks game away. The man never learns from his mistakes,theres no pride in his game.

[TheMoneyShot]

Some coaches can't teach or relate to specific players. I think Stafford is one of those kids. Not entirely the kids fault. But looks horrible out there.

[packerd_00]

the head coach is the problem

No I dont buy he's the reason Stafford is so bad. Granted the HC is terrible at leading,its up to Stafford to take care of his buisness.

I will say also the HC was to blame in that he was so damn arrogant he refused to replace Stafford with Hill,even when everyone could see the Lions were in desperate straits.

[Deuce]

Another bad year and i woud release him

Two biggest winners ever in Detroit

Isaiah and Rodman

Yzerman and Howe you mutt. Kaline and Cobb.

[packerd_00]

Yzerman and Howe you mutt. Kaline and Cobb.

Dont forget the great Terry Sawchuk

[RudyRuetigger]

No I dont buy he's the reason Stafford is so bad. Granted the HC is terrible at leading,its up to Stafford to take care of his buisness.

Don't kid yourself. The team is undisciplined including Stafford's throws. Would love to see him throw those with bellicheck as coach

[opie1988]

I think Stafford could be a pretty good QB. He certainly has the arm.

To those considering releasing him, who exactly would you replace him with that would be a definite upgrade?

[packerd_00]

Don't kid yourself. The team is undisciplined including Stafford's throws. Would love to see him throw those with bellicheck as coach

Not saying they arent,but Jim isnt the reason Stafford is sh!t at throwing the ball,he's been in the league to long to be making these sorts of mistakes.

[packerd_00]

I think Stafford could be a pretty good QB. He certainly has the arm.

To those considering releasing him, who exactly would you replace him with that would be a definite upgrade?

They wont release him,not with that contract.

[Allure]

Without megatron he is worse than gabbert and weeden. Pretty much sums it up I guess.

[oddtodd]

Had people on here telling me that it was "ludicrous" to think Wilson was better than stafford just a week ago. Funny how quick the perception changes.. at least in this case everyone seems to have clued in. Never seen a QB throw more swing passes to an RB into the turf. He has absolutely no form.

[No coincidences]

Don't kid yourself. The team is undisciplined including Stafford's throws. Would love to see him throw those with bellicheck as coach

Hell, I'd even settle for Bill O'Brien at this point.

Or an empty chair.

[lunch]

A bust? He basically took Detroit from a piece of turd to a serious team. They are competitive which is all any NFL owner can ask for

[d2bets]

A bust? He basically took Detroit from a piece of turd to a serious team. They are competitive which is all any NFL owner can ask for

He was on that piece of turd team. They didn't get "serious" because of him, they got better because they used all those high picks to get some pieces around him.

[d2bets]

A bust? He basically took Detroit from a piece of turd to a serious team. They are competitive which is all any NFL owner can ask for

Really? That's all?

[InTheDrink]

Another bad year and i woud release him

Two biggest winners ever in Detroit

Isaiah and Rodman

Kirk Gibson checking in pal

[RubberKettle]

Surely Schwartz will be fired?

Team needs disciple not a new qb. Stafford must reduce the turnovers or he will be a bust.
Still too soon IMO.

[King Mayan]

No.. He's white.. He gets 7 more years to suck...then yeah he will be a bust...

[seaborneq]

He is what he is. A sometimes spectacular fantasy machine, but undisciplined gunslinger nonthelesss.

[opie1988]

Kirk Gibson checking in pal

Fukk yeah, pal.

Gibby is my all-time fave player. I was 14 in 1984, when he was THE MAN. Sick run that team went on.

[C-Gold]

Matt Stafford is complete garbage. He is the Daunte Culpepper of this era. Take Megatron away and he's Rex Grossman.

[lakerboy]

Another bad year and i woud release him

Two biggest winners ever in Detroit

Isaiah and Rodman

f course steve yzerman won nothing.either did gordie howe

[InTheDrink]

Fukk yeah, pal.

Gibby is my all-time fave player. I was 14 in 1984, when he was THE MAN. Sick run that team went on.

makes sense when your fav teams best player was jim sundberg

[opie1988]

makes sense when your fav teams best player was jim sundberg

You best check yo' self.

Jim Sundberg kicked ass, pal. So did Buddy Bell.

[slacker00]

Stafford just signed a $53 million 3 year deal before this season with $41.5M guaranteed. He's got two more years.

One thing to remember, he's only 25 years old. He graduated high school and college early. He's got room to grow.