Tony Romo or Phillip Rivers?

[WildBillCappin]

I am a diehard Eagles fan but even I had to come in to say "Romo". I hate him and he is a giant choke artist, but he has about the highest QBR in the 4th quarter like all-time. Like i said i hate Romo, but who is Phillip Rivers? Hahah

[slacker00]

Andy Dalton

Good choice. I see Dalton as a Flacco-type guy, not too flashy, but can get it done when it counts.

Why not add Cutler to get the Holy Trinity of overrated quarterbacks in the NFL these days?

Let's see what Cutler does with an actual offensive line this year.

[EASports]

Andy Dalton

This guy is properly rated. He stares down his intended receiver B4 he even breaks the huddle. I loved Dalton @TCU as I lived 10 minutes away from the campus during his career. As I was appreciative of finally having a decent college football team in the DFW area. Nevertheless, running the spread option @TCU greatly enhanced his effectiveness. That is not an option in the pros, and his decision making leaves a lot to be desired.

[lemart5]

Romo no question about it.

[easyliving]

like I said before bunch of clueless posters in this thread

[slacker00]

Rivers had some good throws today. Dallas still in control of that division, sadly enough.

[Luckycharms2012]

Romo has no heart and isn't clutch. Rivers all day.

[DoYouNotGetIT]

You cannot be overrated if everyone thinks that you're not a elite QB. Cutler, Rivers, and Romo NO ONE believes they're in the same conversation as Eli Manning, Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, or Aaron Rodgers.

I would take Rivers over Cutler and Romo. Then I would take Cutler over Romo. Romo is great at finding a way to lose. Cutler will have really bad games that cause you to lose like today. Rivers is with the Chargers organization which is crap.

[Smoke]

Well its quite obvious now

[DoYouNotGetIT]

Well its quite obvious now

No 10 weeks from now when the Bears have a better record than the Cowboys and Chargers people will say Cutler is the better QB. Rivers is better in my opinion. I am a Bears fan, but knows the Chargers organization is inept. No, the Cowboys organization doesn't cause Romo to lose play-in games for the playoffs.

[ragman]

If you had to have one of these guys be QB for your favorite team which one would you pick?

( Not talking fantasy football)

i'm saying if one of these gueys had to be your QB in real life... if you owned an NFL franchise.

I know how Rivers looked yesterday, but I'd still take Romo.

[easyliving]

[jjgold]

Rivers with another great game

If Rivers was on Dallas they would of won superbowl

[easyliving]

Rivers with another great game

If Rivers was on Dallas they would of won superbowl

If Chargers had a better head coach all those years Rivers would have won a Super Bowl in SD

[easyliving]

[easyliving]

Rivers with another playoff win

[Luckycharms2012]

Rivers all day all night.