Who is your most UNDERRATED MLB player the first half?? Mine's easy.

[Big Bear]

Nobody has mentioned Howie Kendrick or Jermey Hellickson

[El Nino]

Carlos Gomez has the highest WAR rating in the show.

Struggled to close out before the break. Swinging way too hard and at bad pitches. He's due for a correction, may be after the break if he doesn't settle down.

[dlunc3]

ben revere

[Itsamazing777]

Drew Smyly. Dude is lights out of the pen

[BennyBigNuts]

I just looked it up to confirm.

Both Harvey and Segura are not eligible for ROY.

Underrated Player(s).

I have a few.

Mike Leake (SP) Reds. Leake barely took the #5 starter spot for the Reds coming out of camp. Chapman almost bumped him to middle relief.

What has Leake done?

8-4, 2.69 ERA.

Correct, he is not.

Jimmy Loney .315 .366 OBA.
Not your prototypical first baseman, but getting it done from day one all season.

Josh Donaldson 16-61 .310, rock solid .379 OBA
Considering he plays in a graveyard that is Oakland, those numbers are muy impressive.

Koji Uehara 44 games pitched in relief.
60 K's in 42 IP's (do the math)
1.70 ERA 0.76 WH/IP

My boy Nasher always with the goods. Good calls.
But I'm not a buyer into Mike Leake OR James Loney.
Very good first halves for both, but doubt they continue.

PAUL GOLDSCHMIDT is my boyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
Definitely the real deal. Guy just looks like he's gonna whack one everytime he steps to the plate.

[BennyBigNuts]

Struggled to close out before the break. Swinging way too hard and at bad pitches. He's due for a correction, may be after the break if he doesn't settle down.

Gomez will never last, unless it Roids. Having a MELKY type year for sure.

[Chi_archie]

Russell Martin

guy has been MVP for Pirates first half

[You mad bro]

Mike trout

[daneblazer]

Matt Carpenter

[EmpireMaker]

I got hammered for insisting that Trout is not just better than Harper, but it's not even close.
I haven't heard from those chirpers in a long time.

I agree Trout is much better than Harper
Puig is better than Harper too

[stevenash]

Mike trout

My man YOU MAD BRO !!!

Last year was "Harper is the man, Trout is a flash in the pan, wait until the second half", lit it up the second half last year.
Then all winter it was "Trout is 30 lbs overweight, he'll have a sophomore year jinx and crash and burn, yadda, yadda, yadda"

Me thinks I am seeing a pattern here.

2012
Trout 30-83 .326 .399 OBA 129 runs scored, 49 stolen bases .................

2013 (first half-do the simple math and multiply by two)
Trout 15-59 .322 OBA .399 OBA 65 runs scored 21 stolen bases

Scary isn't it.

[stevenash]

I agree Trout is much better than Harper
Puig is better than Harper too

Harper is what he is
An excellent defensive outfielder but he's a .268 hitter with an above OBA will hit 22 homers but drives in only 55 to 60

2012	19	WSN	NL	139	597	533	98	144	26	9	22	59	18	6	56	120	.270	.340	.477	.817	119	254	8	2	3	3	0	*89/7	AS,MVP-30,RoY-1
2013	20	WSN	NL	58	242	201	38	53	9	2	13	29	6	3	36	44	.264	.371	.522	.893	143	105	3	0	2	3	2	79/8	AS

Is Harper better than Trout? That's a clown question bro.

[BennyBigNuts]

Mike trout

My man YOU MAD BRO !!!

Last year was "Harper is the man, Trout is a flash in the pan, wait until the second half", lit it up the second half last year.
Then all winter it was "Trout is 30 lbs overweight, he'll have a sophomore year jinx and crash and burn, yadda, yadda, yadda"

Me thinks I am seeing a pattern here.

2012
Trout 30-83 .326 .399 OBA 129 runs scored, 49 stolen bases .................

2013 (first half-do the simple math and multiply by two)
Trout 15-59 .322 OBA .399 OBA 65 runs scored 21 stolen bases

Scary isn't it.

[daneblazer]

The angels got hammered in that Greinke trade

[You mad bro]

My man YOU MAD BRO !!!

Last year was "Harper is the man, Trout is a flash in the pan, wait until the second half", lit it up the second half last year.
Then all winter it was "Trout is 30 lbs overweight, he'll have a sophomore year jinx and crash and burn, yadda, yadda, yadda"

Me thinks I am seeing a pattern here.

2012
Trout 30-83 .326 .399 OBA 129 runs scored, 49 stolen bases .................

2013 (first half-do the simple math and multiply by two)
Trout 15-59 .322 OBA .399 OBA 65 runs scored 21 stolen bases

Scary isn't it.

I was drunk and make a thread saying Harper would be bett than trout lol .. Smh

[boss_of_um]

It's Josh Donaldson hands down and not close

Agreed. The fact he is not an All Star seals the deal when talking about underrated when you look at all of his stats and advanced stats.

[You mad bro]

Agreed. The fact he is not an All Star seals the deal when talking about underrated when you look at all of his stats and advanced stats.

Machado and miggy are better .. That's why he isn't on the all star team .. He def should be somehow cuz he's playing out of his mind lol

[stevenash]

Nobody has mentioned Howie Kendrick or Jermey Hellickson

Helickson yes, Kendrick is putting up his usual .300 type season though. (He is a .300 lifetime hitter, well, .293 to be exact)
Kendrick has been an all star before

[stevenash]

I was drunk and make a thread saying Harper would be bett than trout lol .. Smh

Can relate.

[BennyBigNuts]

I was drunk and make a thread saying Harper would be bett than trout lol .. Smh

I think the funniest thread I saw all year was opening day this year. 5 seconds after Harper hit his 2nd HR of the game someone posted MVP ROFLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
Too lazy to go look for it. It was hilarious though.
Harper has a sweet swing to watch, but after seeing another half year between these 2 now, it seems like Trout is going to be the better player. I'm a Trout fan though I love watching the kid. I don't understand why he doesn't play CF everyday though.

[You mad bro]

I think the funniest thread I saw all year was opening day this year. 5 seconds after Harper hit his 2nd HR of the game someone posted MVP ROFLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
Too lazy to go look for it. It was hilarious though.
Harper has a sweet swing to watch, but after seeing another half year between these 2 now, it seems like Trout is going to be the better player. I'm a Trout fan though I love watching the kid. I don't understand why he doesn't play CF everyday though.

dude I love trout.. I was drunk and prob saw someone sucking him off on this forum lol and I ranted . Fml lol

btw we still have to make love like we said

[BennyBigNuts]

dude I love trout.. I was drunk and prob saw someone sucking him off on this forum lol and I ranted . Fml lol

btw we still have to make love like we said

LOL you sick fukkk
Now you're starting to scare me.

[Big Bear]

John Jaso- Oakland A's Catcher

Very good defensive catcher...
Works the count better than anybody and draws a lot of walks.

clutch hitter too.

very clutch. Just won the game for the A's.