Best QB In NFL???

**mad** · 12-20-05, 01:05 AM

Brady for me.

**isetcap** · 12-20-05, 01:06 AM

kyle orton

**moses millsap** · 12-20-05, 01:10 AM

Voted for Brady. A proven winner.

**imgv94** · 12-20-05, 01:11 AM

Alex Smith.. No It's Tom Brady

**mad** · 12-20-05, 01:13 AM

What about best up and coming QB, Brees or Eli?

**imgv94** · 12-20-05, 01:17 AM

Originally posted by mad

What about best up and coming QB, Brees or Eli?

Tie?? But doubt either of them would be half as
good without there RB's LT&Barber.. Also If Brees
Didn't have Gates?? He would be on the bench
watching Phillip Rivers..

**Dead Money** · 12-20-05, 01:22 AM

Peyton is probabbly the best, but winning 3 championships in 4 years caused me to vote for Brady.

Plus being from New England and seeing him play a few times a year helped also.

**Aces** · 12-20-05, 01:29 AM

Peyton no question about it.

**bigboydan** · 12-20-05, 02:09 AM

Originally posted by mad

What about best up and coming QB, Brees or Eli?

Eli buy miles when it's all said and done IMHOO

This kid has the great bloodlines and is bread for and groomed for football. not to mention the fact that, both peyton and Eli spend time working out in the off season studying films,training,ect,ect.

**Razz** · 12-20-05, 02:21 AM

I hope whoever voted for Jake Plummer was joking. How he and Vick got on this list instead of Brees was already surprising enough, but then to see someone actually vote for one of them. Wow.

**onlooker** · 12-20-05, 02:26 AM

I voted for Peyton.

But for the up and coming QB, Palmer has to be at the top of the list.

**Senator7** · 12-20-05, 02:27 AM

No question. Peyton for me.

**isetcap** · 12-20-05, 02:30 AM

Between Brees or Eli?
Are you serious?

Eli has ALWAYS been the most overrated quarterback I have ever seen. His whole reputation is based on people saying "he may be the best arm in the family", which is just utterly absurd. Look at his numbers and then think of all the weapons he has around him. Barber (MVP candidate), Shockey, Burress, Toomer, solid O-line, and a good defense to cover up his mistakes.

For up and coming quarterbacks you obviously want Palmer or Roethlisberger but Brees plays a similar game to Brady so throw him in there also. I can easily name 15 quarterbacks I would take before Eli and every single one of them would make the Giants a better team...

**mad** · 12-20-05, 02:51 AM

Yeah i forgot about BIG Ben, seems like he's what you might call an established QB, but i suppose he ain't been there that long.

As for Eli, i suppose it's good to have a big bro like Peyton, and a dad like Archie to toss the ball around with in the backyard, during those balmy summer evenings.

Who'd ya vote for isetcap?

**isetcap** · 12-20-05, 03:02 AM

Well, I tried to vote for Peyton but then I became violently ill when I discovered that Donovan McNabb and Jake Plummer were a part of the poll.

Tom Brady is right up there with Peyton, but I feel that New England is more of a unit functioning its highest level whereas Peyton is truly a quarterback who has redefined the position. Perhaps it's a replay of 80s debate: Montana (Brady) vs. Marino (Manning).

If you ask me who I want if I need to win the game...Is there really any question?
Tom Brady of the New England Patriots

**isetcap** · 12-20-05, 03:05 AM

Alright who is the joker that voted for Jake Plummer?

...forum needs a "mute" button

**Concorde** · 12-20-05, 03:18 AM

Originally posted by isetcap

kyle orton

Agree.

**isetcap** · 12-20-05, 03:24 AM

Originally posted by isetcap

kyle orton

Oh I'm sorry...I thought the poll was for "Best Shave in the NFL"

**pags11** · 12-20-05, 05:47 AM

Brady's the man...I'll take rings over stats any day of the week...

**sharp_E** · 12-20-05, 05:52 AM

Originally posted by pags11

Brady's the man...I'll take rings over stats any day of the week...

Thats what really counts in the NFL.

**isetcap** · 12-20-05, 06:50 AM

and that's why trent dilfer is better than Peyton

**BuddyBear** · 12-20-05, 02:58 PM

Hard not to pick Manning....i have a feeling when all is said and done Manning will have won as many if not more super bowls than Brady and his stats are going to eclipse his as well...but both will be in the Hall of Fame i am sure.

**onlooker** · 12-20-05, 02:59 PM

Originally posted by pags11

Brady's the man...I'll take rings over stats any day of the week...

Manning may add a ring to those stats this year.

**isetcap** · 12-20-05, 03:09 PM

you can't get a ring if you don't even play in the superbowl, and the colts won't be playing in this year's classic.

Apparently somebody else thinks this poll is a huge joke because I see another vote for Jake Plummer.

**onlooker** · 12-20-05, 03:28 PM

Originally posted by isetcap

you can't get a ring if you don't even play in the superbowl, and the colts won't be playing in this year's classic.

Im glad you can tell the future. We never know.
The key word in my last post "may". His team just has a good shot at winning the superbowl.

This thread/poll being a joke? Well people are entitled to their opinions.

**Illusion** · 12-20-05, 04:15 PM

Peyton, even though Brady has the rings. Brady is number 2 however.

**hoppa_long** · 12-20-05, 08:44 PM

peyton or Brady hmmmm Brady gets my vote

**imgv94** · 12-20-05, 09:26 PM

mark bulger