Crosby vs Ovechkin vs Malkin

cobra_king · 03-02-09, 05:42 PM

Right now i'd take Ovechkin hands down. In 5 years it might be a different story as i'm not sure how his body will hold up with the way he plays. Hopefully it will because he's a treat to watch every time he's on the ice.

Sunday Rider · 03-02-09, 06:02 PM

Ovechkin's goal vs Montreal was all about him being the runaway train that he is.. he saw an opportunity n used all his guts and determination to get it done even with someone on his back.. Reminds me of Rocket Richard.
Crosby is full of skill but more of a finess player who's got amazing vision on the ice. Some of his passes make u think does he have an extra pair of eyes behind his head.. a la Gretzky.

In terms of leadership, you gotta love Ovetchin's lead by example hard work ethic.. Crosby's an ambassador to the league and talks like one too.. a lil too whiny for sum.

I also like Malkin, plenty of skill between his ears.. tho his face always make me think he'd got down syndrome :P

VegasDave · 03-02-09, 06:03 PM

Before I vote, I want to clarify;

Do I get one of these players for my team right now (this season), or am I building a team around one of these guys so who do I want long term/for their career?

Sunday Rider · 03-02-09, 06:05 PM

Ur building a team around your superstar.. U get one pick between these three players.
U're basically gonna keep this player in your team FOREVER and you wouldnt trade him for the world!!!

Axis · 03-02-09, 06:08 PM

Crosby is a whiny sack of shit...I would not want him as my captain...I don't care if he's good.

Ovechkin LOVES PLAYING. It's clear...every time he touches the ice...he's there to win...and he gets excited about a goal, whether he scores or not...that's the man you want leading your team.

Sunday Rider · 03-02-09, 08:38 PM

Ovechkin said he's gonna try and beat Gretzky's 92 goals in one season next year.. In this day and age with goalie's equipments covering most of the net... that would be AMAZING if he does.

element1286 · 03-02-09, 09:36 PM

Malkin, running away with the scoring race, should win MVP if the Pens make the playoffs.

Sunday Rider · 03-02-09, 10:48 PM

Yeah.. I picked Malkin in my fantasy hockey team with 3rd pick overall.. got quite a STEAL

Axis · 03-03-09, 12:21 AM

It's not even about the points for me...you want someone who shows they want to win...and they are excited about winning. Clearly, Malkin/Crosby want to win...but I love how Ovi puts it out there...

If I were to start a team around someone...I'd think about Datsyuk too... dude just creeps along the top in points...has the sickest hands...ever...yea...ever...and is always a finalst for the best defensive forward...leads the league in take-aways...that's a guy you want.

cobra_king · 03-03-09, 01:15 AM

Originally posted by Sunday Rider

Ovechkin said he's gonna try and beat Gretzky's 92 goals in one season next year.. In this day and age with goalie's equipments covering most of the net... that would be AMAZING if he does.

Ovechkin is the man but he's living in a fantasy world if he thinks he'll get close to this record next season.

VegasDave · 03-03-09, 01:37 AM

Originally posted by cobra_king

Ovechkin is the man but he's living in a fantasy world if he thinks he'll get close to this record next season.

That one is untouchable, but the alltime goals record is not, assuming he can stay healthy and keep up this level of play into his 30s.

xxx · 03-03-09, 01:48 AM

NHL stereotypes, they are a changin'

VegasDave · 03-03-09, 02:07 AM

What is sad to me is that I don't think some of you realize how good Sidney Crosby is.

Ovechkin is more intense, he's much cooler, he's an absolute beast and an amazing player.

That said, Crosby makes the players around him better, and his vision on the ice is second to none.

He averages 1.366 points per game, compared to Malkin's 1.263 and Ovechkin's 1.277.

Points aren't everything, and you can't go wrong with this elite group no matter how you cut it. I just think Crosby is the right pick.

cobra_king · 03-03-09, 02:11 AM

I know how good Crosby is. And to be honest, i like him, even if alot of people don't like him because of his perceived whining. The guy is an exceptional talent, and to be honest i'd like him to be the best player in the game because of his skill set. But right now, at this time, when you watch Ovechkin on a nightly basis, the guy is a threat to score EVERY time he touches the puck. Plus he brings so much more then just that to the table. He's won me over for right now. I just wonder how long he will hold up with the way he throws his body around.

hockeytown11 · 03-03-09, 12:53 PM

why is Crosby even in the same poll with the other two? Datsyuk and Zetterberg are both CLEARLY better leaders and players than Crosby.

Sunday Rider · 03-03-09, 11:08 PM

Originally posted by xxx

NHL stereotypes, they are a changin'

GREAT ARTICLE XXX

Axis · 03-04-09, 12:29 AM

Originally posted by hockeytown11

why is Crosby even in the same poll with the other two? Datsyuk and Zetterberg are both CLEARLY better leaders and players than Crosby.

Thank you.

Sunday Rider · 03-04-09, 01:04 AM

I put those 3 together because they are all in the same age bracket so to speak.