What do you guys think of Jeter vs. Utley?

[fifawcs]

2008 MLB All Star Game (NL vs AL) Tues, July 15 (8:00pm EST)
Most Hits + Runs + RBIs

Both players must have an At-Bat for action. Singles Only. Max $300.
Chase Utley (NL) -135
Derek Jeter (AL) +105

Here are Jeter's All Star Game Stats:
-Played in 8 games
-8 hits in 16 at bats
-3 runs, 1 double, 1 home run
-3 RBIs
-5 Strike Outs, 1 GIDP
-.500 AVG, .750 SLG
-Knows how to hit in Yankee Stadium

Utley's:
1 hit in 4 at bats, .250 average
Games Played: 2
He's never played in Yankee Stadium, will be very nervous like yesterday's HR derby.

[fifawcs]

I ended up taking Jeter +105