I know there are too many threads on this topic already but I want to get all the evidence in one thread, right at the beginning where everyone can easily see it.
Slow-mo replays @ 1:00
<iframe src="http://videos.sportsgrid.com/embed/player/?r=1252500156406313.2&content=BKPF281XYF 72WVLQ&widget_type_cid=svp&read_more=1" width="590" height="421" frameborder="0" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" scrolling="no" allowtransparency="true"></iframe>
"Even if you just use logic, you can make the right call. If the catcher missed the tag, he would try to reapply the tag. The batter missed homeplate by 3 feet but the catcher didn't care because he knew he made the tag with the first swipe. There's no way the catcher would have the wherewithal to pretend like he tagged the runner if he in fact did not, especially when he had more opportunities to complete the tag."
Slow-mo replays @ 1:00
<iframe src="http://videos.sportsgrid.com/embed/player/?r=1252500156406313.2&content=BKPF281XYF 72WVLQ&widget_type_cid=svp&read_more=1" width="590" height="421" frameborder="0" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" scrolling="no" allowtransparency="true"></iframe>
"Even if you just use logic, you can make the right call. If the catcher missed the tag, he would try to reapply the tag. The batter missed homeplate by 3 feet but the catcher didn't care because he knew he made the tag with the first swipe. There's no way the catcher would have the wherewithal to pretend like he tagged the runner if he in fact did not, especially when he had more opportunities to complete the tag."