McCutchen best centerfielder in the game??

[Whippit]

btw correct answer is Aaron Rowand

gimme the gritty vet with 2 rings who plays with a busted face vs some prepubescient hairless nigerian jumping bean

[Metalhead]

Defense only, it's probably Franklin Gutierrez.

[nitty48]

he definitely has the skills to be #1 but hasnt put it all together yet.

[hothandsmgee]

Are they saying this as fantasy wise?

[forloveofthegame]

Are they saying this as fantasy wise?

Nope "clearcut" best centerfielder in the game RIGHT NOW. -MLB network

[timmyboy34243]

at this time he's awfully good but i have a tough time putting " the best " label on him........

[element1286]

I watch him everyday, and I can tell you the defensive worries are real, he isn't bad, but he needs work on his jumps, UZR agrees.

For the next 5 years Colby Rasmus is the only players I would even discuss taking over McCutchen in CF. Hamilton is going to move to a corner as he ages, and CarGo is going to bulk up and move to a corner spot. I guess Victorino should be included, but I don't consider him a star, solid regular who plays on a good team. After those guys, everyone has a flaw.

All defense, questionable offense guys like Gardner, Bourn, and Guitierrez.

Vets who broke out late have shorter primes; Pagan, Byrd, and Torres.

Young players who are overrated; Chris Young, Austin Jackson, Matt Kemp.

Old players who are overrated; Hunter, Granderson, Upton.

[wiffle]

btw correct answer is Aaron Rowand

lolwat.

i think you are leveling, but he had a .287 woba last year and is an average defensive cf.

[icancount2one]

Flyin' Hawaiian ftw.

[goblue1988]

I'm not sure how you figure Torii Hunter as 'overrated'.

Angel Pagan is a piece of shit.

[oiler]

Was a bit surprised when MLB Network made him the #1 centerfielder in the league but do believe it is much deserved. Thoughts?

i bet this came out of the pittsburgh area,not even in the top five maybe top ten

[Whippit]

lolwat.

i think you are leveling, but he had a .287 woba last year and is an average defensive cf.

he's on downside of career, but a consistent gamer as anybody & i think numbers are overrated

[Squirrel]

WTF does him being a "gamer" have to do with anything?

People tell me Craig Counsell is a gamer, that must make him one of the best SS's in baseball, yes?

[Whippit]

craig counsell couldn't hold aaron rowand's jock

[hothandsmgee]

I dont know maybe if sizemore is completely healthy im taking him

[smitch124]

The Giants would probably trade Rowand for a bag of balls if the other team would pay half his salary.

[wiffle]

I'm not sure how you figure Torii Hunter as 'overrated'.

Angel Pagan is a piece of shit.

angel pagan>>>> torii hunter for 2/36m

plus he has a cool name