Josh Johnson is better than Halladay

[THA_DIESEL]

Halladay is overrated.

If Johnson had a good as a batting lineup as the Phillies, he would be given the spotlight he deserves.

[Pauulzcappin]

Now he'll probably break his leg and will never be able to pitch again...

[cro]

lol

[dodger33]

Obviously you have no clue about baseball.

[dodger33]

Halladay pitched for the Blue Jays his whole career and EARNED his way into the spotlight. Go look up who has the most complete games in the last 3 years.

[Footballtime]

Johnson is good, not sure better then Halladay. Have Johnson pitch in the AL East for 7 years then we can see what Johnson really has. Halladay pitched well for many many years in the toughest diivision in baseball, GL FBT

[THA_DIESEL]

Halladay getting eaten alive by the Bronx Bombers.

[jboy4]

5-3 is eaten alive. I think his ERA is now a MONSTER 2.39.

[Cappinpicks]

halladay is overrated

[jboy4]

halladay is overrated

I didnt know someone with his numbers could be overrated. He just threw a perfect game a couple of weeks ago.

[mann2chc]

not to take anything away from johnson BUT to mention him in the same sentence as halladay is crazy... johnson is good but the bullpen has to come in for him... halladay, on the other hand, is basically a day off for the bullpen... therefore, NO COMPARISON!!!

[DennisGreen]

Stupid thread. Both are stud #1 pitchers. No need to compare them. End thread.

[jose21_us]

Both are probably top 5 pitchers in the NL. Glad to have at least one of them on my team...

[phLLyphan11]

This thread is retarded.

[ThaTopMoron]

Halladay is overrated.

If Johnson had a good as a batting lineup as the Phillies, he would be given the spotlight he deserves.

Yeah he is doing better THIS SEASON

Good job noticing that.

[Patrickz0rs]

Phillies can't hit shit in a toilet.

[stealthyburrito]

just last week the phillies were betting on their own games, now there offense is great. what's next?

florida also has more runs, more HRs, more TBs, higher BA, higher OPS this year then philly.

[Dukebluejms]

Both are very good, but one bad outing does not mean that Halladay is overrated.

[Cappinpicks]

Halladay has some bad outings and isn't as consistent as people make him out to be. I've seen him blow up a lot last year even to medicore teams

[Eagle1958]

I'll take Halladay any day of the week over any other pitcher in baseball.

[mitote]

Who is Josh Johnson?

[cubswin]

Next time lay off the game

[whatsgood5]

Both are excellent pitchers, Halladay's slightly better though.

[bigsmitty]

All the best Deesel...I like the thread. J.J. has had the novelty and all- One game does not a career make...Fantastic players feel their losses, eat them breathe them baby and they get stronger and meaner. As of this point RH has my vote. Cheers

[THA_DIESEL]

Halladay is overrated.

If Johnson had a good as a batting lineup as the Phillies, he would be given the spotlight he deserves.

Johnson also has the trust of his teammates, Halladay has none of it.

[brock]

Money on Florida tofay.

[ciynister19]

I still like Halladay more but not by alot

[j_dunn2]

Johnson also has the trust of his teammates, Halladay has none of it.

And this statement is backed by what facts and/or testimony from which Phillies players?

To claim that Josh is markedly better than Roy is one thing, as youre certainly entitled to your opinion (as wrong as it is). These types of statements will leave ones mouth often when they drop a bomb on Roy, the Phils lose, and he costs you a boatload with his -200 odds every game. He cant win all 35 starts with 35 CG's, yano?

However, to say that Halladay has NO trust from his teammates is a wild statement regardless of what your opinion is. I dont think any player takes the field ready to chalk the game up as a loss, especially behind ROY HALLADAY ???????

That was really a crazy statement hahaha

[MarlinsFan2212]

100% Agreed.....Immensely Bias over here though lol.