Umpire doing a great job..

PassUrChipZ · 10-19-13, 10:58 PM

This umpire is good really good!!

hockey216 · 10-19-13, 10:58 PM

the the ump do poorly by not calling back the grand slam also?

PassUrChipZ · 10-19-13, 11:03 PM

Missed strikes lol. That guy won't around for the playoffs again big doesn't matter I paid him well!

PassUrChipZ · 10-19-13, 11:06 PM

Wouldn't be a grAnd slam if the batter was called out. Can't miss calls like that changes the entire complextion of the inning. You fool

hockey216 · 10-19-13, 11:13 PM

the HR was on the 3rd pitch... both pitches 1 and 2 were strikes. gomes only had 1 ball called, ellsbury had 0 balls called. victorino had 0 balls called.

even if you take back the bogaert walk, then its just a 3 run shot and they lose by 2.

they lost by 3 runs, not 1. dont blame the ump. tigers gave up a grand slam. they lost fair and square.

the K's that ump didnt call for tigers in innings that no runs were scored had 0 effect also.

PassUrChipZ · 10-19-13, 11:25 PM

Well we will see if the guy umpires another playoff
game. Maybe in 4 years he will. Problem is u are assuming the same inning would happen with a strikeout. Enough said I can't convince a simpleton. In life there is always a reaction to an action can't assume anything.

frugalgambler · 10-20-13, 12:49 AM

Had the K's been called, Scherzer would have lasted longer. It is clear that the MLB office is fed up with low-scoring games so they told the umpires to tighten the strike zone. The second game in a row this happens. Not that I am complaining: I won on that GS tonight.

hockey216 · 10-20-13, 01:27 AM

Originally posted by PassUrChipZ

Well we will see if the guy umpires another playoff
game. Maybe in 4 years he will. Problem is u are assuming the same inning would happen with a strikeout. Enough said I can't convince a simpleton. In life there is always a reaction to an action can't assume anything.

if you can't assume anything, how do you assume that when team loses by 3 runs, that taking back 1 walk would have erased 3 future runs?

detroit gave up a grand slam. victorino blasted that ball all the way to china. stop blaming ump. tigers lost by 3 runs. it wasnt a 1 run game.

you can't assume that 1 walk would take back a later home run. maybe it would, maybe not. maybe the next 2 batters after victorinos grand slam would have gotton on base and driven runs in instead of gotton out.

who knows... but you lost by 3 runs. umpire cant call back a grand slam that was blasted out of the park. umpire cant erase 3 runs off board.

tigers lost fair and square.