43 State Attorneys General Urge CFTC to Withdraw Sports Prediction Market Rule
Last Updated: November 20, 2026 3:54 PM EST • 3 minute read X Social Google News Link
Attorneys general from 43 states and Washington, D.C., are urging the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw a proposed rule that would explicitly classify sports prediction-market contracts as financial derivatives.
The bipartisan coalition submitted its formal objection Nov. 18, the final day of the public comment period.
The states argue that the proposal would allow prediction market apps operators to bypass state gambling regulations, including licensing requirements, age restrictions, and responsible-gambling protections.
"A sports bet isn't a derivative just because the CFTC says so," Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson said in a statement.
Wilson led the effort alongside attorneys general from Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee, and Utah.
What the CFTC wants to change
The CFTC announced its proposal on Oct. 9 and published it in the Federal Register ten days later. The measure would explicitly include event contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather within the regulatory definition of a swap.
These contracts generally allow customers to trade on whether an event will occur, with winning contracts typically paying $1. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig argues that such contracts are financial instruments already covered by federal commodities law.
The commission maintains that national regulation provides consistent oversight while supporting trading activity, market liquidity and price discovery.
A separate interim rule, effective Oct. 19, excludes qualifying traditional sportsbook wagers and casino games from the swap definition. That distinction is central to the dispute: The CFTC considers exchange-traded event contracts different from wagers accepted by licensed sportsbooks, such as at the best sports betting sites.
States challenge federal authority
The attorneys general reject that distinction, arguing that sports contracts remain gambling products regardless of how transactions are structured. They contend Congress never authorized the CFTC to assume oversight of sports betting through its authority to regulate derivatives.
The coalition also questions whether the agency can adopt the proposal with only one sitting commissioner, raising concerns about procedural requirements.
Its letter points to federal appeals court rulings supporting state gambling oversight, although other courts have reached different conclusions.
"The most straightforward answer is that sports bets are not derivatives subject to the CFTC's jurisdiction," the coalition wrote.
The states also warn that the proposal could encourage conventional sportsbooks to restructure their operations as prediction markets to avoid state taxes and licensing requirements.
The CFTC acknowledges that its proposed framework could encourage more companies to enter federally regulated markets. It also recognizes potential consumer risks associated with speculative trading and gambling-like behaviour.
However, the agency maintains that federal exchange rules provide protections for market participants.
Proposed rule remains under review
The November filing follows a separate July letter in which 44 attorneys general urged the CFTC to recognize state authority over sports prediction markets. The latest coalition wants the agency to withdraw the proposal and reconsider its approach.
The letter does not change existing federal regulations or resolve ongoing lawsuits involving prediction-market operators and state gambling regulators.
For now, the CFTC must review the public comments before deciding whether to finalize, revise or abandon its proposal.
Andrew Reid X social