Sportsbook Handle Slips as AGA Poll Backs Prediction Market Rules
Last Updated: November 17, 2026 2:02 PM EST • 3 minute read X Social Google News Link
U.S. sportsbook wagering has declined year over year in eight of the past 10 months, according to new research examining the growing competition between traditional sportsbooks and prediction markets.
The findings come alongside an American Gaming Association (AGA) survey showing that 82% of respondents believe prediction market apps should be regulated as gambling rather than financial products.
Both reports were released Nov. 16, adding to the debate over how expanding prediction markets are affecting the regulated sports betting industry and the best sports betting sites.
Sportsbook handle declines in eight of 10 months
RG analyzed sports betting reports from 32 jurisdictions and found that monthly handle declined year over year in every month between December 2025 and September 2026, except June and July. Those two months benefited from the FIFA World Cup.
In September, sportsbooks across 30 reporting jurisdictions accepted $13.06 billion in wagers, down 0.7% from a year earlier.
Despite the monthly declines, total handle increased 2.5% to $101.7 billion between January and August. Excluding the two World Cup months would leave a 2.9% decline, according to RG.
The research suggests prediction markets are contributing to the slowdown, although their exact impact remains uncertain. Citizens analyst Jordan Bender estimated in September that approximately 4% of regulated sportsbook handle had permanently shifted to prediction markets.
RG estimates that diversion accounts for roughly one-third of the slowdown in sportsbook growth.
Prediction-market volume isn't sportsbook handle
Comparing the two industries presents another challenge. Prediction-market trading volume can count both sides of a transaction, while contracts purchased for pennies may contribute their full $1 payout value to reported notional volume.
That makes direct comparisons with money wagered at sportsbooks misleading.
Stifel estimated in October that prediction-market activity grew more slowly than sportsbook handle during September when measured using more comparable figures.
The competing findings suggest prediction markets are attracting significant activity, but don't establish how much business they're taking directly from sportsbooks.
AGA poll finds support for gambling oversight
The AGA's new survey found that 82% of respondents supported regulating prediction markets as gambling products. Support included 84% of Democrats, 82% of Republicans and 80% of independents.
Another 75% considered sports contracts on prediction markets fundamentally equivalent to traditional sportsbook bets.
Respondents also supported specific consumer protections, including age verification at 21 (74%), responsible-gambling messaging in advertising (74%) and compliance with state self-exclusion lists (70%).
Notably, half believed prediction markets were already licensed by state gaming regulators. AGA President and CEO Bill Miller called for the same oversight and consumer protections required of state-licensed sportsbooks.
The survey included 2,268 registered voters aged 21 and older, conducted online Sept. 2–18. Its reported margin of error was two percentage points. The AGA represents the established gaming industry and has advocated for stronger state regulation of sports prediction markets.
Federal regulation remains in place
Prediction-market companies maintain that their contracts are financial products regulated under federal commodities law.
Kalshi, for example, operates as a Commodity Futures Trading Commission-designated contract market and allows customers as young as 18 to trade.
That differs from the 21-and-older standard supported by respondents in the AGA survey.
The survey does not change existing regulations, and the sportsbook research does not establish that prediction markets caused the entire handle decline.
Together, however, the findings highlight growing competition between the two industries and continuing disagreement over how sports event contracts should be regulated.
Andrew Reid X social