College Football ATS Picks Week 12: Predictions Against the Spread

Which teams will cover in Week 12? We make our college football picks against the spread and explain why we’re taking each side.
Temple Owls quarterback Jaxon Smolik (14) runs with the ball as we break down our college football ATS picks for Week 12.
Pictured: Temple Owls quarterback Jaxon Smolik (14) runs with the ball as we break down our college football ATS picks for Week 12. Photo by Matthew O'Haren / Imagn Images.
Enjoying SBR content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

My college football ATS picks went 2-1 on my top three plays of the week, including an outright 34-6 Arkansas upset of South Carolina as a 7.5-point underdog.

This week's college football Week 12 predictions are highlighted by an early-week play in Thursday night's kickoff between Rice and Temple. I also make the case for why Baylor and SMU are catching too many points against No. 12 Texas Tech and No. 5 Notre Dame, respectively.


College football picks against the spread: Week 12

See all of our experts' college football picks for Week 12 based on the latest college football odds.

Matchup ATS pick  Odds
Rice vs. Temple Temple -2.5 -130 via BetMGM
Western Kentucky vs. Liberty Liberty -16.5 -118 via DraftKings
UL-Monroe vs. Appalachian State Appalachian State -13.5 -110 via BetMGM
No. 4 UCLA vs. Michigan Michigan +4.5 -120 via FanDuel
No. 12 Texas Tech vs. Baylor Baylor +3.5 -110 via FanDuel
Northern Illinois vs. North Dakota State North Dakota State -25 -110 via BetMGM
SMU vs. No. 5 Notre Dame SMU +20.5 -105 via DraftKings

Picks submitted: Nov. 16 at 3:15 p.m. ET. Odds subject to change. 

📃 Affiliate disclosure

Sportsbook Review may receive a commission if you sign up through our links. Not intended for use in MA. Bonuses not applicable in Ontario. 21+ only. (Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)


Best college football ATS picks

Temple -2.5 (-130 via BetMGM) vs. Rice

This is likely not the programming ESPN dreamed of when putting a game between Rice and Temple as a standalone game on a Thursday night, as the teams enter at 1-9 and 2-8, respectively. But I find an edge with Temple, who has had great preparation for Rice’s triple-option attack after facing both Army and Navy this season, even if Rice’s version is more modern-looking out of shotgun formation primarily.

Temple went 1-0-1 ATS against the two service academies, even when it didn’t have its best defensive performances, like when it covered as 7.5-point underdogs against Navy in a 42-35 loss.

Entering that game, the Owls ranked in the top 15 offensively in EPA on runs and were also top 30 nationally in passing explosives. The latter was especially important to the team’s offensive success after it was held to 2.1 yards per carry. Thus, their ability to still score 35 points while producing just nine first downs and possessing the ball for just over 19 minutes is encouraging.

I have no confidence in a Rice team that just allowed 20 points, 20 first downs, and 351 total yards to a Tulane squad that entered the week outside the top 115 in Early Downs Success Rate and outside the top 130 in Rush Success Rate.

Play to: -3, pass at -3.5 or higher

⏰️ Set your alarm: Rice vs. Temple

  • Kickoff: Thursday at 7:30 p.m. ET
  • Venue: Lincoln Financial Field (Philadelphia)
  • How to watch: ESPN

Baylor +3.5 (-110 via FanDuel) vs. Texas Tech

File this 3.5-point spread under the heading of “most head-scratching line of the week” as Baylor is coming off a 28-7 beatdown at BYU and Texas Tech is off an impressive 52-27 road win at then-No. 25 Oklahoma State.

Texas Tech’s defense actually did well to limit Drew Mestemaker to 27-of-42 passing for 277 yards since it entered the game ranked 13th in the conference in opponent completion percentage and 15th in passing yards allowed per game. But the Red Raiders also didn’t improve their 38th percentile rating in explosive plays allowed, and Baylor entered last week ranked a respectable top-30 in schedule-adjusted net EPA per play.

I’m giving the Bears a pass for last week’s no-show in Provo due to their travel complications. I cannot back Baylor for an outright upset since it is 1-13 SU against ranked opponents since 2022, but I’m also fading Texas Tech and its 1-2 ATS record as road favorites this season.

Play to: +3.5 (-120), pass at +3 or lower

⏰️ Set your alarm: Texas Tech vs. Baylor

  • Kickoff: 3:30 p.m. ET
  • Venue: McLane Stadium (Waco, Texas)
  • How to watch: FOX

SMU +20.5 (-105 via DraftKings) vs. Notre Dame

Before one diminishes SMU’s chances in this game because of a 49-7 home loss to Wake Forest, just know that the Demon Deacons have been doing that to many opponents of late. Wake Forest has covered eight straight by an average of 26.5 points per game.

Notre Dame’s schedule has been widely criticized, and outside of Darian Mensah (who threw for 269 yards and three touchdowns against the Fighting Irish without Malachi Toney), it hasn’t faced a quarterback who poses a threat of consistently pushing the ball downfield.

SMU’s Kevin Jennings has already eclipsed his career-highs of passing yards totals twice this season (430 and 439) after entering the season ranked second in school history in passing yards and completion percentage, and fourth in touchdowns.

The Mustangs are 0-2-1 ATS against ranked opponents this season, but this is too many points to lay with a Fighting Irish squad that may not have any way of earning a top-4 seed in the College Football Playoff and a subsequent bye if teams (like Texas) ranked below them continue to stockpile impressive wins against more difficult schedules.

Play to: +19.5

⏰️ Set your alarm: SMU vs. Notre Dame

  • Kickoff: 7:30 p.m. ET
  • Venue: Notre Dame Stadium (Notre Dame, Ind.)
  • How to watch: NBC