Originally <a href='/showthread.php?p=19724380'>posted</a> on 09/24/2013:
You're right.
Doc is a much better pitcher.
Halladay has 5 times as many shutouts as Pettitte.
Halladay has almost 3 times as many complete games.
Halladay has a lower ERA.
Halladay has a lower WHIP.
Halladay has more K's per 9 innings.
Halladay gave up fewer HRs.
There isn't a single fuking thing you can come up with that would make anyone think Pettite was better than Doc.