[compsmoker]

I took a wager on 5dimes for Georgetown (1st 10 min) 2nd Half -1½ -112* vs Pittsburgh (1st 10 min) .

Half time socre was 37-22

Acording to ESPN at

10:05

47-34

Greg Whittington made Three Point Jumper. Assisted by Otto Porter Jr..

So I thought I covered with 5 seconds to spare. However the ticket is marked as a loss. Speaking with 5dimes they said the ball was not through the basket at 10:00 so the basket did not count.

They may very well be 100% correct. However public information I have says they are wrong. Anyone out there able to help me verify if this basket made it before the 10:00 mark? Ball has to be 100% through the net by 10:00 for it to count.

Any help is much appreciated.

[Isaiah]

I took a wager on 5dimes for Georgetown (1st 10 min) 2nd Half -1½ -112* <small>vs</small> Pittsburgh (1st 10 min) .

Half time socre was 37-22

Acording to ESPN at

10:05

47-34

Greg Whittington made Three Point Jumper. Assisted by Otto Porter Jr..

So I thought I covered with 5 seconds to spare. However the ticket is marked as a loss. Speaking with 5dimes they said the ball was not through the basket at 10:00 so the basket did not count.

They may very well be 100% correct. However public information I have says they are wrong. Anyone out there able to help me verify if this basket made it before the 10:00 mark? Ball has to be 100% through the net by 10:00 for it to count.

Any help is much appreciated.

Play by play tracker indicates 3 pointer was made with 10:06 left in 2nd half. You won your bet.
See full play by play tracker at http://www.cbssports.com/collegebask...108_PITT@GTOWN

[compsmoker]

Same info as ESPN but your link at http://www.cbssports.com/collegebask...108_PITT@GTOWN states 10:06 instead of 10:05. Speaking with 5dimes they said they have video of all the games and on TV the basket was not made in time. I guess I will need to see a video of the game in order to verify myself. Anyone have link to a video of the game if it's legal to post?

[Isaiah]

Same info as ESPN but your link at http://www.cbssports.com/collegebask...108_PITT@GTOWN states 10:06 instead of 10:05. Speaking with 5dimes they said they have video of all the games and on TV the basket was not made in time. I guess I will need to see a video of the game in order to verify myself. Anyone have link to a video of the game if it's legal to post?

I am calling bullsh*t on this one. In basketball 5 or 6 seconds is an eternity, did the ball hang in the air that long before going through the basket? Perhaps it was a rainbow up to the rafters that finally came down through the bucket at 9:59? Yeah right. Both CBS and ESPN recorded the basket with 10:06 and 10:05 left in the game respectively.

Did they have had more action on GT than Pitt?

[waldroprob]

They're wrong, but of course Tony will never admit it. People need to learn to stick with the vanilla -105 at 5Dimes, they will angle props and have a history of just stealing money by grading the side with all the action as a loser (see the hotdog eating contest prop from a few years ago).

I wouldn't be surprised if the Pitt side of that bet lost too (if anyone actually bet it).

[Isaiah]

They're wrong, but of course Tony will never admit it. People need to learn to stick with the vanilla -105 at 5Dimes, they will angle props and have a history of just stealing money by grading the side with all the action as a loser (see the hotdog eating contest prop from a few years ago).

I wouldn't be surprised if the Pitt side of that bet lost too (if anyone actually bet it).

The manager on duty at the time was "CHRIS". And he couldn't be bothered to live chat about it either. Unbelievable.

[rcene]

The manager on duty at the time was "CHRIS". And he couldn't be bothered to live chat about it either. Unbelievable.

That really stinks Isaiah. You won your bet, and five dimes stole a winner from you. One reason I do not bet into five dimes is because of stuff like this.

Tony thinks because he offers alot of different odds that gamblers should thank him when he screws them over. Fukk that shit!

[tto827]

I would think you'll get your money. Submit a complaint, clearly you won. If this happens more than once, I would withdraw my funds after getting it corrected, and then speak directly to the dumbfukk who said they couldn't change it. Remind him of how stupid he is before finding a book that doesn't hire asshats like him.

[compsmoker]

Only way for me to know for sure is to find a video link and watch it. I bet there is a package somewhere I can purchase for this game.

Please note I'm not discounting 5dimes account of what happened. They can very well be on the right side. It's hard in circumstances like this because publicly available information says I won but they say they have private information that says I lost.

[tto827]

Only way for me to know for sure is to find a video link and watch it. I bet there is a package somewhere I can purchase for this game.

Please note I'm not discounting 5dimes account of what happened. They can very well be on the right side. It's hard in circumstances like this because publicly available information says I won but they say they have private information that says I lost.

They don't have shit dude, I doubt ESPN and CBS got it wrong. Someone graded it as a loss, and the guy you spoke to was too lazy to look into it.

[Isaiah]

They don't have shit dude, I doubt ESPN and CBS got it wrong. Someone graded it as a loss, and the guy you spoke to was too lazy to look into it.

Exactly. I will be shocked if they don't reverse the grade tomorrow. If they don't I will be cashing out immediately.

[tb1984]

You should file a complaint http://www.sportsbookreview.com/sportsbook-complaint/, and SBR will look into it.

[rcene]

Espn 3 does not have the replay loaded for this game yet. When the link is there you can re watch the game on Espn 3.

Hopefully that is not necessary and five dimes gets their shit together.

[exstatman]

I stopped betting the college 10 minute bets for this reason, they operate differently than the NBA games, which use NBA.com. 5Dimes says they use their own tape to judge college 10 minute wagers, so it's almost impossible to dispute.

[compsmoker]

They don't have shit dude, I doubt ESPN and CBS got it wrong. Someone graded it as a loss, and the guy you spoke to was too lazy to look into it.

They did look into it. I waited for them the double check on their end and the person I was chatting with said they verified that the basket did not count.

They clearly stated they had video of the basket not going through the net 100% before the 10:00 expired.

I'm not ready to file a complaint yet. I have no video evidence and 5dimes may be in the right here. I have publicly available information that says I won but it's not video proof and that is what is needed. I won't file a complaint unless I can get video proof. Other wise there is nothing that can be done.

[tto827]

Espn 3 just put the replay link up for the Pitt and Georgetown game. I will watch it myself.

Here is the link...http://espn.go.com/watchespn/index/_...y/days/days-0/

And exstatman, if video shows it went in before then, and they don't change it. I think many people will join me in trying to ruin 5dimes, cause that is ridiculous.

[bostonboss]

I stopped betting the college 10 minute bets for this reason, they operate differently than the NBA games, which use NBA.com. 5Dimes says they use their own tape to judge college 10 minute wagers, so it's almost impossible to dispute.

if u think those guys are actually watching the games.....i have oceanside property in iowa to sell you

[tto827]

They did look into it. I waited for them the double check on their end and the person I was chatting with said they verified that the basket did not count.

They clearly stated they had video of the basket not going through the net 100% before the 10:00 expired.

I'm not ready to file a complaint yet. I have no video evidence and 5dimes may be in the right here. I have publicly available information that says I won but it's not video proof and that is what is needed. I won't file a complaint unless I can get video proof. Other wise there is nothing that can be done.

They tell you that they actually care about the player also. The dude probably went and grabbed a bag of cheetos, played a game of pong, then came back with your answer. I'm not going to watch the video I posted below but many will.

[tto827]

According to the other thread on this, shot was taken at 10:01, and it was damn close. May have gone through at 10:00, may have been at 9:59, guess the book may have been in the right here. ESPN and CBS just put a random time up, thats pretty sad.

[compsmoker]

Video up. You tell me if I won or not

http://espn.go.com/watchespn/player/...ize/condensed/

Time stamp: 1:35:56

Ball has to clear the net to count. From this video I think I lost by about .20 of a second. Ball did not clear basket till 9:59. So 5dimes is correct in marking this wager as a loss IMO.

[LVHerbie]

Not the best but a screen shot from the replay on espn3... It looks like the ball is still in the air at the 10 minute mark...

[Justin7]

5d has a rule on point: NCAA first and next 10-minute results are determined from digital recordings of television broadcasts. The ball must be completely through the cylinder and net before 9:59 remaining for a basket to be official in the first 10 minutes of a half.

This surprised me, since I expected them to use an internet source. But their rule is clear. You might ask them for a copy of the video to confirm it... But if all is what people say, this was correctly graded.

For the record, this is not the position of SBR, as I am no longer a mod/dispute specialist here.

[Isaiah]

Video up. You tell me if I won or not

http://espn.go.com/watchespn/player/...ize/condensed/

Time stamp: 1:35:56

Ball has to clear the net to count. From this video I think I lost by about .20 of a second. Ball did not clear basket till 9:59. So 5dimes is correct in marking this wager as a loss IMO.

It would be interesting to find out if anyone had the other side on this and how 5Dimes graded their wagers. Just saying.

[ThaWoj]

Hope u stay active in these forums justin. Your insight and youtube videos are always appreciated

Tough beat for u guys, sorry.

[bostonboss]

5d has a rule on point: NCAA first and next 10-minute results are determined from digital recordings of television broadcasts. The ball must be completely through the cylinder and net before 9:59 remaining for a basket to be official in the first 10 minutes of a half.

This surprised me, since I expected them to use an internet source. But their rule is clear. You might ask them for a copy of the video to confirm it... But if all is what people say, this was correctly graded.

For the record, this is not the position of SBR, as I am no longer a mod/dispute specialist here.

why no longer a mod?

[tb1984]

The ball went through after the 10:00 mark.

[bostonboss]

may all your photo finishes be winning ones...in the words of todd shrupp

[tb1984]

That was a really brutal beat.

[compsmoker]

It would be interesting to find out if anyone had the other side on this and how 5Dimes graded their wagers. Just saying.

It would be interesting but my guess is they would of marked it a win. Can't see why they would not. I know books have a poor reputation and they deserve it as they all have poor customer service but places like 5dimes do seem to taking grading bets correctly very seriously.

This is why I did not rush to file a complaint on this game and I did not flame 5dimes in this thread. I just wanted help finding video proof of the win/loss.

Thanks everyone for taking the time to post and help out.

[5mike5]

brutal

[cutter2225]

5d has a rule on point: NCAA first and next 10-minute results are determined from digital recordings of television broadcasts. The ball must be completely through the cylinder and net before 9:59 remaining for a basket to be official in the first 10 minutes of a half.

This surprised me, since I expected them to use an internet source. But their rule is clear. You might ask them for a copy of the video to confirm it... But if all is what people say, this was correctly graded.

For the record, this is not the position of SBR, as I am no longer a mod/dispute specialist here.

Thats a retarded rule IMO. Should be standard to use official boxscores, in which case this is a winner but in this case looks like 5 Dimes is covered.

[Justin7]

It would be interesting but my guess is they would of marked it a win. Can't see why they would not. I know books have a poor reputation and they deserve it as they all have poor customer service but places like 5dimes do seem to taking grading bets correctly very seriously.

This is why I did not rush to file a complaint on this game and I did not flame 5dimes in this thread. I just wanted help finding video proof of the win/loss.

Thanks everyone for taking the time to post and help out.

Despite the smack you may hear, 5d is one of the safer books out there, and I'd lay -10000 that they graded both sides consistently. Tony may have a strong ego (don't most winning sports bettors?) but in the one case where he and I disagreed, he treated the player fairly.

This post does not reflect the opinion of SBR. For that matter, any post I have ever made in the past was just my opinion, so nothing has really changed.

[Justin7]

Thats a retarded rule IMO. Should be standard to use official boxscores, in which case this is a winner but in this case looks like 5 Dimes is covered.

If I were writing the rule, I might do it differently. But the rule is clear, and can be verified online. That makes it fair, even if it takes slightly more effort than reading a play-by-play.

[JasonDC]

If I were writing the rule, I might do it differently. But the rule is clear, and can be verified online. That makes it fair, even if it takes slightly more effort than reading a play-by-play.

justin, any chance you can swing on over to one of the betislands threads and tell us anything you might know about any potential bailout..i just came in these forums recently but from what everyone says you seem to be the man who might have some information about this.

[compsmoker]

Thats a retarded rule IMO. Should be standard to use official boxscores, in which case this is a winner but in this case looks like 5 Dimes is covered.

Problem with that is which box score? cbs has this basket going in at 10:06 and espn at 10:05. I think video is the best route. As for the basket counting, I think 5dimes clear rule makes sense. Has to be 100% clear of the net. Better then saying ball has to be inside the rim of half way through the basket. I lost the wager fair and square. Had I been on the other side I would of harped if I lost the wager in this case.

Kudos to 5dimes for getting it right. However I did not like the chat I had with customer service. Repeating themselves over and over made me feel they where not listening to me and I felt they did degrade my opinion. I also do not like that they could not provide me any public available source to verify what they where saying. Every wager should have a publically available source they can point to for grading.