Originally Posted by
indio
Fact is, the top 10 teams in college football this year aren't that much different in terms of ability,record,and any of them could beat another top 10 team. That so much energy is spent debating what conference did this,what teams did that, and strength of schedule, resume's,blah, blah, blah, is ridiculous and shows just how truly stupid a 4 team playoff,picked by an "exalted committee", truly is. Real championships are played on a field, by teams that earned their place, and where the best teams can be beaten on the field, NOT by some corporate boardroom of Napoleonic bureaucratic overseers who declares what 4 teams are worthy to enter the arena.
I'm still wondering how a #4 ranked TCU team that then went out and won their final game 55-3, gets leapfrogged out of the playoff in 2014, when their only loss was on the road to the #5 team in the country who needed to rally from a 21 point 4rth quarter deficit that was aided by bad referees, and the team that leapfrogged them got beat up at home by 2 TD's by an unranked Virginia Tech team?
Bo Schembechler said it best when he said there is no such thing as a Div 1a college football champion. Until they go to some format where there is a performance criteria in place before the season starts to qualify for a playoff that holds at least 8 teams, there never will be. Fact is, these bowl games with their huge corporate sponsorship money and TV deals still rule the roost, as that is the ONLY reason there is not a legitimate playoff format in place, because otherwise, it's a piece of cake. The whole "well, we want to keep the regular season important" argument has about as much veracity as the NFL saying they don't want gambling on their games because it might jeopardize the integrity of the league.
I vividly remember when Utah went undefeated in 2008, and not one mention was made of them being a top team by so called "authorities". They went to the Sugar Bowl to face a 1 loss Alabama team whose only loss was to #4 Florida (and eventual BCS champ) in the SEC title game. Utah just utterly destroyed them, and instead of sports "journalists" saying how good Utah was, and that it's a travesty they didn't get a chance to play for the title, all they said was, gee whiz, Alabama must not have been motivated.
I swear, college football politics makes grown men act like a clique of 14 year old girls in school, pointing out who the popular and cool kids are, and who isn't. And all I know, is that if this committee gets on it's knees again to blow undeserving Ohio State into the playoff yet again, they will have dispatched any of the minute fragments of credibility they pretend to still have.