Originally Posted by
RogueScholar
I'm sorry, I was speaking from the point of view that his dismissal for lying was merely a pretext for attempting to remove a gay kid from the locker room, irrespective of the age of who he was kissing. In hindsight that's a poor assumption, because there are a lot of ugly reasons that could've motivated this unfortunate circumstance, and we shouldn't take any of them off the table.
I can of course see your concerns as a parent, and I'm sure my own parents would've been mortified at all the 30-40 year olds I dated shortly after coming out of the closet in college. I'm happy to report though that none of them took advantage of me and my "Daddy complex," and a couple of them made significant contributions to my life long after the sex was over, and out of respect for that I can't bring myself to join you in condemning all relationships between teenagers and older men (I was 16 when I came out). I think you can even find vast disparities in sophistication between people who are the same age, and even between a 30 year old and a 60 year old.
While it's a nice dream to want all relationships to live up to a truly egalitarian standard, the fact is that in humans we're often attracted to precisely the qualities we sense lacking in ourselves. As young people, that's sophistication and stability, and as we age it's innocence and vitality. The only protection we have against manipulation in any relationship is true love, and that's a hard thing to gauge no matter your age. In fact, I think I might be more guilty of manipulating those older guys into lavishing me with money and gifts than they ever were of toying with my emotions or taking advantage of my lack of reservation in matters of love.
All of this is my way of saying that I really can't bring myself to seeing their relationship as wrong or inappropriate before I know them both and how they treat each other. That's why I took the stance I did, that this is yet another case of a gay man being excluded from something once it's learned that he's gay. In my mind that's all there is to argue, because anything else involves substituting our judgment for this kid's judgment (or even his parents) and now that he's an adult, we'd only be compounding his problems by suggesting that his status as an adult is probationary in some respects.