Diggity -
Let's start with basics.
For a hypothesis to be scientifically sound, it must be filtered through the Scientific Method. Several things make GW Fail this.
1. For a hypothesis to pass scientific mustard, there must be a way to disprove it. Show me that. How can GW be proven wrong?
2. Full disclosure. Why no sharing of data?
3. Documentation and replication.
Blame Bush now.