Originally posted on 12/17/2017:

Quote Originally Posted by mtofell View Post
He was clearly short of the goal line with his knee down so it wasn't going to be a TD anyway. Of course, there's a big difference between the 10 and the 1. I was watching with the sound off (long story) and didn't realize they were looking at possession all the way to the ground. It sure looked like a catch but short of the goal line. All this micro-managing of replays really has screwed the game up IMO. I liked it better a generation ago when if it looks like a catch, it's a catch.
wrong. nobody touched him while he was down so it wasn't going to be marked short. you have to be touched while down