[cakasmaloy]

I know this isn't a Fantasy forum but I'd still appreciate some insight if any of you guys can help me out.

I'm in an 8man ppr league with a 4 man bench and have been proposed the following trade.

My Joseph Addai in exchange for his Shonn Green and Beanie Wells.

At first I know most of you are thinking of course I should make this trade, but when considering the small bench and my already strong lineup I am hesitant. I would have to trade addai who has strong ppr value AND drop a player in place of beanie wells who I don't think really has a fit on my team. If I knew for certain that Donald Brown was going to take a large enough workload away from addai then Id be all over this but that uncertainty is killing me.

My team:
QB SCHAUB
RB R RICE
RB DEANGELO WILLIAMS
WR S SMITH NYG
WR W WELKER
TE D CLARK
FLEX J ADDAI
-------------------
WR HINES WARD
WR TERRELL OWENS
RB RICKY WILLIAMS
RB TIM HIGHTOWER

[Lincoln73]

make the deal, addai is injury prone and you are getting 2 good young running backs with huge upside.

[cakasmaloy]

make the deal, addai is injury prone and you are getting 2 good young running backs with huge upside.

Who would you suggest I drop in place of wells?

[Full Time Hobo]

Beanie is basically someone to sweeten the deal.... Many dont see him doing well this year so watch out. And you already have Hightower from the cards.

You have a strong bench. Addai is injury prone, yes, but keep in mind the jets picked up LT so Greene wont be a solid num 1 back....

If you accept... id say kick TO... hes hit or miss... especially with Carson Palmer at QB... thats me though.

[cakasmaloy]

Beanie is basically someone to sweeten the deal.... Many dont see him doing well this year so watch out. And you already have Hightower from the cards.

You have a strong bench. Addai is injury prone, yes, but keep in mind the jets picked up LT so Greene wont be a solid num 1 back....

If you accept... id say kick TO... hes hit or miss... especially with Carson Palmer at QB... thats me though.

Who would you consider more of a threat to steal touches.... LT from Greene or Donald Brown from Addai?

[BGboothA]

Greene is the #1 back in NY. LT will get some of the third down work, but Greene is the workhorse. In Indy its going to be more of a 60/40 split. There is no brainer here. Take the deal.

[officepoolguy]

I know this isn't a Fantasy forum but I'd still appreciate some insight if any of you guys can help me out.

I'm in an 8man ppr league with a 4 man bench and have been proposed the following trade.

My Joseph Addai in exchange for his Shonn Green and Beanie Wells.

At first I know most of you are thinking of course I should make this trade, but when considering the small bench and my already strong lineup I am hesitant. I would have to trade addai who has strong ppr value AND drop a player in place of beanie wells who I don't think really has a fit on my team. If I knew for certain that Donald Brown was going to take a large enough workload away from addai then Id be all over this but that uncertainty is killing me.

My team:
QB SCHAUB
RB R RICE
RB DEANGELO WILLIAMS
WR S SMITH NYG
WR W WELKER
TE D CLARK
FLEX J ADDAI
-------------------
WR HINES WARD
WR TERRELL OWENS
RB RICKY WILLIAMS
RB TIM HIGHTOWER

My first instinct would be to do it so that you have running back depth...but keep in mind that Greene does not catch any passes and in a ppr league you will want the catches in the flex. Also Wells is going to split carries with one of your backs already.

Overall though I would do it because starting running backs are hard to come by and you already have some pass catching running backs on your roster. So do it.

[cakasmaloy]

Thanks for the advice. Now I just gotta figure out who to drop since I can only hold 4 players on my bench...

Which of these 4 should I drop in 8 man PPR league?

Hines ward
Terrell Owens
Ricky Williams
Tim Hightower

[gryfyn1]

Take It - ditch Hightower, hes going to be the number two back on an awful arizona team -

IF you have any faith in the Jets then Shonne green is a huge pick-up, he will need to pick up the slack that Jones had last year (1400 yrds, 14 TDs), and Sanchez isn't going to morph in a great passer and the Jets wont morph into a throwing team.

[BIGDAY]

Hightower is out for sure!

[Chugs]

Definitely take this deal. The amount of touches Greene will get will make up for his PPR downside and I could see Addai losing his job to Brown by the end of the season. Thomas Jones had 330 carries last year and Greene still had over 100 and 500 yrds, thats how committed the Jets are to the run. And I would drop Hightower for Beanie or even Ricky if you want to keep the Ari backfield intact.

[cakasmaloy]

Any other insight with who to drop? I'm worried about droppin Hightower when he might be the one to end up having the big game against STL this weekend. All this beanie wells injury, fumble stuff is scaring me.