MY TEAM
S Vogt C, 1B, RF
F Freeman 1B
D Gordon 2B
M Carpenter 3B
X Bogaerts 3B, SS
A. Hechavarria SS
J Upton LF
A Pollock CF
J Heyward RF
J Marisnick CF, RF
M Trumbo 1B, LF, RF
C Utley 2B
J Mauer 1B
Y Grandal C, 1B
J Lamb (DL) 3B
C Gomez (DL) CF
PITCHING:
J Nelson SP
D Price SP
C Archer SP
M Gonzalez SP
R Porcello SP
H Iwakuma SP
A Cobb (DL) SP
J Papelbon RP
C Kimbrel RP

As you can pretty obviously see here, I need a SP or 2 if I'm going to be competitive this year. So here's what I'm thinking.


1. He wants both Bogaerts and Upton. I am thinking I only want to lose on or the other. If I did decide to trade both, he said he'd give Reyes, Braun, and an SP (either Carrasco, Smyly, or Kennedy)

I'm proposing ONLY Bogaerts but adding Trumbo to the mix. I'm wanting Reyes and and SP in return.

Bogaerts and Trumbo for Reyes and an SP. Either Carrasco, Smyly, or Kennedy (coming off DL this weekend)

In your minds is that a fair trade?

Or any ideas to go about this differently?

HIS TEAM
W Ramos C
E Encarnacion 1B
R Cano 2B
A Rodriguez 3B
J Reyes SS
B Moss 1B, LF, RF
M Betts 2B, CF, RF
A Pollock CF
J Soler RF
G Polanco RF
R Braun RF
Y Tomas 3B, RF
C Yelich (DL) LF, CF
PITCHING:
T Bauer SP
A Bradley SP
C Martinez SP. RP
A Wood SP. RP
D Smyly SP
J Soria RP
A Miller RP
M Melancon RP
E Volquez SP
C Kluber SP
C Carrasco SP, RP
C Rodon RP
I Kennedy (DL) SP