1. #1
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Underdog experiment

    OK, since 1, count em 1 person wants to see this, I guess I'll do it. The idea is to bet 1 unit on all the underdogs, every day, and track it. I forget who it was that did this last year, but it was fairly solid until August or so.

    For yesterday's and today's games:

    Mets 128
    Braves -105
    Nats 105
    Rays 150
    Tigers -105
    Dodgers -105
    Indians 100
    Reds 100
    Rox 100
    Royals 145
    As -105
    Pirates 170
    Os 180
    Rangers 130

    Results later, as well as a running tally thanks to Excel's nested IF and AND statements.

  2. #2
    babaoriley
    babaoriley's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 12-11-06
    Posts: 2,316

    Should be interesting. Thanks for doing this.

  3. #3
    LT Profits
    LT Profits's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 10-27-06
    Posts: 90,963
    Betpoints: 5179

    Hey jetserson,

    I like the idea but I would only play on dogs of +101 or more, i.e., plays where the profit REALLY exceeds the risk. Also, those look like square lines you posted, so I would look for a reduced juice book. For example, I bet Oakland at +117 at 5 Dimes, a far cry from your -105.

    Still, this should be very interesting.

  4. #4
    rjt721
    rjt721's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-06-07
    Posts: 7,929
    Betpoints: 378

    Also looking forward to seeing how this turns out.

  5. #5
    ShamsWoof10
    ShamsWoof10's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 11-15-06
    Posts: 4,827
    Betpoints: 24

    I tried this with basketball before... Dog ML's and I think with hoops there is much more value in dogs ML's because you'll have a +1000 like the Celtics win on SHAMrock day while you don't see many +1000's in baseball.... Anyway it did OK for a bit but overall not all that good.... Favorites wins most of the time and I would like in hoops to try selling points on every favorite to make it a plus line and see how that works... This should be interesting none the less... If you are actually wagering on all of them I wish you the best of luck....

  6. #6
    The HG
    The HG's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 11-01-06
    Posts: 3,566

    Are you going to track it using closing lines? Or opening lines? Or lines at a fixed time?

    Especially early in the year, MLB lines really move. Just today, there were many games that started out with a modest-sized dog, which moved to close to even, and many games that started out close to even that moved to have a modest-sized dog.

    And, especially in today's environment, with Pinny closed to US customers, some people using exchanges a lot, and the uncertainty as to who will and will not continue to bet on MLB games, the results of something like this are likely to be different from what they might have been in the past, or will be in the future if things ever return more to "normal".

    But it will be interesting to see what the results are, for sure.

  7. #7
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Quote Originally Posted by LT Profits View Post
    Hey jetserson,

    I like the idea but I would only play on dogs of +101 or more, i.e., plays where the profit REALLY exceeds the risk. Also, those look like square lines you posted, so I would look for a reduced juice book. For example, I bet Oakland at +117 at 5 Dimes, a far cry from your -105.

    Still, this should be very interesting.
    They are, I copied it right out of my spreadsheet...I believe it was Onlooker who did this last year, starting in June, using opening lines from Pinnacle. I would do it another book, but it's easiest for me to work from Bodog since I'm trying $1 per game, I've got $ on there from poker (as an aside, the pond is indeed drying up), and trying to deposit/cash out is something I only want to do with a book I've dealt with in the past given the current sorry state of affairs.

    If you want to try it for fun with more updated lines or those from an RJ book, let me know and I'll send you the formula for Excel in case you're inexperienced with it or just don't want to think.

    If you want to check the results from last year, sort the "replies" column in Baseball capping and look about 1/4 of the page down, "Blindly Betting Underdogs". Thanks, and sorry about Oakland! (not really, seattle completed my first successful parlay of the year at 24-1 )

  8. #8
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Quote Originally Posted by Ganchrow HG View Post
    Are you going to track it using closing lines? Or opening lines? Or lines at a fixed time?

    Especially early in the year, MLB lines really move. Just today, there were many games that started out with a modest-sized dog, which moved to close to even, and many games that started out close to even that moved to have a modest-sized dog.

    And, especially in today's environment, with Pinny closed to US customers, some people using exchanges a lot, and the uncertainty as to who will and will not continue to bet on MLB games, the results of something like this are likely to be different from what they might have been in the past, or will be in the future if things ever return more to "normal".

    But it will be interesting to see what the results are, for sure.
    Opening, at least for now. I think that's simply the easiest way to do it because if I'm doing it blindly, any movements from open are generally going to be dictated by action at a particular book, am I right?

  9. #9
    AC1318
    AC1318's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 10-09-06
    Posts: 6,712
    Betpoints: 60

    how about tracking home dogs instead less work and I think more profit

  10. #10
    Hulu
    Hulu's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-17-06
    Posts: 664
    Betpoints: 90

    I went back and tracked dogs from opening day until the all star break from 2004 to 2006 and although I'm still working with the data, my initial results show that things vary wildly. 2004 was an amazing year for dogs, showing a profit of 70.45 units whereas 2005 and 2006 showed a slight loss (<3 units in both cases) so I'm not sure blindly betting dogs will consistently yield a profit unless one finds another filter to narrow down the field.

    I plan to go back and get another year of data when I have time.

  11. #11
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    [QUOTE=jesterson;246711]

    Results for 4/2:

    Mets 128 1.28
    Braves -105 0.95
    Nats 105 -1
    Rays 150 -1
    Tigers -105 -1
    Dodgers -105 -1
    Indians 100 1
    Reds 100 1
    Rox 100 -1
    Royals 145 1.45
    As -105 -1
    Pirates 170 1.7
    Os 180 -1
    Rangers 130 -1

    For a loss of $0.62 on the day.
    QUOTE]

    For 4/3:

    Padres 100
    Nats 120
    Dodgers 115
    Pirates 160
    Os 120
    Dbacks 115
    As 105
    Rangers 135
    Mets -105

  12. #12
    LT Profits
    LT Profits's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 10-27-06
    Posts: 90,963
    Betpoints: 5179

    jesterson,

    Judging by the way you graded your plays, I see that you always RISK one unit, thus the -1 at -105 odds and the +0.95 on the -105 winner. This futher illustrates the point that you should probably bet on +101 or higher only, ignoring the "negative" underdogs and +100s. Again, a reduced juice book would mean more plays at better odds.

  13. #13
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Quote Originally Posted by LT Profits View Post
    jesterson,

    Judging by the way you graded your plays, I see that you always RISK one unit, thus the -1 at -105 odds and the +0.95 on the -105 winner. This futher illustrates the point that you should probably bet on +101 or higher only, ignoring the "negative" underdogs and +100s. Again, a reduced juice book would mean more plays at better odds.
    yeah, I know where you're coming from, but he idea is to bet underdogs blindly, regardless of how big or small. And I'm workin on switching books, just need to figure out the logistics of it all without depositing any more cash.

  14. #14
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Results For 4/3:

    Padres 100 1 w
    Nats 120 -1 l
    Dodgers 115 -1 l
    Pirates 160 1.6 w
    Os 120 -1 l
    Dbacks 115 -1 l
    As 105 -1 l
    Rangers 135 -1 l
    Mets -105 0.95 w

    3-6, for a loss of 2.44 units on the day

    Season W/L: 9-14

    Plays for 4/4:

    Nats 135
    Jays -103
    Indians -110
    Dbacks -110
    Rangers 130
    Braves 107
    Cubs 115
    Brewers 100
    Pirates 145
    Mets -110
    Royals 145
    Os 120
    Mariners 105
    Padres -105

  15. #15
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Got behind on posting for a day, so here's 4/4 and 4/5's results:

    4/4:
    Nats 135 1.35 W
    Jays -103 -1 L
    Indians -110 0.90 W
    Dbacks -110 -1 L
    Rangers 130 -1 L
    Braves 107 1.07 W
    Cubs 115 1.15 W
    Brewers 100 -1 L
    Pirates 145 1.45 W
    Mets -110 0.90 W
    Royals 145 -1 L
    Os 120 -1 L
    Mariners 105 -1 L
    Padres -105 0.95 W

    for a net loss of .79 units on the day

    And for 4/5:

    Reds 100 1 W
    Indians -102 -1 L
    Royals 160 -1 L
    Braves 100 1 W
    Nats 110 -1 L
    Rays 250 2.5 W
    As 130 1.3 W
    Giants 102 1.02 W

    For a net gain of 3.82 units (best so far in the young season). It also put us back in the black by 1.54 units on a W/L of 21-24.

    I'll post today's shortly.

  16. #16
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Games for 4/6:

    Rangers 102
    Mariners 140
    Marlins 102
    Nats 102
    Os 200
    Pirates 104
    Rays 108
    Mets -105
    Cubs 108
    Astros 111
    Twins 122
    Royals 153
    Rox 137
    As 110
    Dodgers 102

  17. #17
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Good day for the dogs yesterday, +5.05 units on a W/L of 8-5 (YTD: +6.59 units, 29-29)

    Rangers 102 1.02 W
    Marlins 102 -1 L
    Nats 102 -1 L
    Os 200 2 W
    Pirates 104 -1 L
    Rays 108 1.08 W
    Mets -105 0.95 W
    Cubs 108 1.08 W
    Astros 111 -1 L
    Royals 153 1.53 W
    Rox 137 1.37 W
    As 110 -1 L
    Dodgers 102 1.02 W

    Today's in a bit.

  18. #18
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Let's see if the dogs can keep the run going!

    4/7:

    Cubs 108
    Pirates 153
    Os 185
    Royals 113
    Giants 126
    Mets 101
    Twins 119
    Phillies 102
    Nats 129
    Cards 151
    Rays 115
    Red Sox 117
    As 118
    Rox 135

  19. #19
    moses millsap
    moses millsap's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-25-05
    Posts: 8,289
    Betpoints: 1260

    I think faves went 13-1 on Saturday. Awesome.

  20. #20
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Quote Originally Posted by OWNED View Post
    I think faves went 13-1 on Saturday. Awesome.
    Yeah, it was bad...1-13 for a loss of 11.92 units on the day, - 5.32 for the year on a W/L of 30-42

    Cubs 108 1.08 W
    Pirates 153 -1 L
    Os 185 -1 L
    Royals 113 -1 L
    Giants 126 -1 L
    Mets 101 -1 L
    Twins 119 -1 L
    Phillies 102 -1 L
    Nats 129 -1 L
    Cards 151 -1 L
    Rays 115 -1 L
    Red Sox 117 -1 L
    As 118 -1 L
    Rox 135 -1 L

  21. #21
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    And for today, albeit late:

    Phillies 110
    Braves 120
    Os 140
    Pirates -105
    Nats 125
    Rays 135
    Cubs 110
    Cards 110
    W Sox 170
    Royals 150
    As 130
    Rox 170
    Dodgers 120
    Rangers 120

  22. #22
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Sunday's results:

    Phillies 110 -1 L
    Braves 120 1.2 W
    Os 140 1.4 W
    Pirates -105 0.95 W
    Nats 125 -1 L
    Rays 135 -1 L
    Cubs 110 -1 L
    Cards 110 1.1 W
    W Sox 170 -1 L
    Royals 150 -1 L
    As 130 1.3 W
    Rox 170 -1 L
    Dodgers 120 1.2 W
    Rangers 120 -1 L

    Day: 6-8, -.84 units
    YTD: 36-50, -6.16 units

    And Monday's games (I selected St Louis by accident in a hurry):

    Phillies 122
    Cards -106
    Astros 153
    Tigers 118
    Rox 135
    Brewers 110
    Twins 120
    Royals 185
    Rays 140
    Reds -101
    Giants 114
    W Sox 153

  23. #23
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Another slightly down day for the dogs (5-7, -.65 units):

    Phillies 122 -1 L
    Cards -106 0.94 W
    Astros 153 1.53 W
    Tigers 118 -1 L
    Rox 135 1.35 W
    Brewers 110 -1 L
    Twins 120 -1 L
    Royals 185 -1 L
    Rays 140 -1 L
    Reds -101 0.99 W
    Giants 114 -1 L
    W Sox 153 1.53 W

    YTD: 41-57, -6.82 units

    And Tuesday's games:

    Mariners 172
    Astros 134
    Brewers 115
    Cards 118
    Angels 123
    Os 120
    Royals 135
    Nats 220
    Rays 130
    Twins 125
    Reds 114
    Giants 118
    W Sox -105
    Rox 117

  24. #24
    bigboydan
    bigboydan's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-10-05
    Posts: 55,425

    When you get around the 15-18th range of the month of April. I think thats when you will really notice the dogs start to pick up quite a few units Jesterson.

  25. #25
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Quote Originally Posted by bigboydan View Post
    When you get around the 15-18th range of the month of April. I think thats when you will really notice the dogs start to pick up quite a few units Jesterson.
    Yeah, that's what I was thinking too...Also, I just switched to a reduiced juice book, so that should help.

  26. #26
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Another bad day for the dogs, 5-9, -2.8 units (YTD: 46-66, -9.62)

    Mariners 172 -1 L
    Astros 134 1.34 W
    Brewers 115 1.15 W
    Cards 118 1.18 W
    Angels 123 -1 L
    Os 120 -1 L
    Royals 135 1.35 W
    Nats 220 -1 L
    Rays 130 -1 L
    Twins 125 -1 L
    Reds 114 -1 L
    Giants 118 1.18 W
    W Sox -105 -1 L
    Rox 117 -1 L


    Wednesday's games:

    Pirates 125
    Astros 155
    Brewers -101
    Phillies 135
    Nats 220
    Reds 113
    Giants 137
    Rox 142
    W Sox -102
    Angels 119
    Os 127
    Mariners 150
    Royals 159
    Rays 152
    Twins 134
    Last edited by jesterson; 04-12-07 at 04:45 PM.

  27. #27
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Good Day on Wed, 8-6, +4 units (YTD: 54-72, -5.62)

    Thursday's dogs:

    Phillies 137
    Nats 270
    Angels 127
    Royals 116
    Tigers 116
    Rays 146

  28. #28
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    A marginal loss Thursday, -.14 units, 2-4 (YTD: -4.36 units, 58-77)

    Phillies 137 -1.00 L
    Nats 270 2.70 W
    Angels 127 -1.00 L
    Royals 116 -1.00 L
    Tigers 116 1.16 W
    Rays 146 -1.00 L

    Friday's games:

    Reds 140
    Astros 102
    Giants 140
    Nats 178
    Marlins 102
    Rox 166
    Padres 115
    Royals 161
    Indians 100
    Tigers 138
    Rays 201
    As 101
    Angels -102
    Rangers -102

  29. #29
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    It's been a crazy weekend and I haven't posted the games, but the good news is the dogs are back in the black after a strong Friday and Sunday!

    Fri: 8-6, +4.48 units
    Sat: 4-7, -1.06 units (lines for 2 games posted late, not incl.)
    Sun: 6-4, +3.32 units
    YTD: 74-93, +.97 units

    Monday's games:

    Nats 173
    Mets 104
    Reds 107
    Marlins 108
    Padres 112
    Pirates 117
    Giants 120
    Dbacks 107
    Angels 166
    Royals 183
    Os 105


    It's going to be interesting to see what happens once the weather warms up and power numbers start to moderate.

  30. #30
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Quote Originally Posted by jesterson View Post
    Monday's games:

    Nats 173 1.73 W
    Reds 107 -1.00 L
    Marlins 108 -1.00 L
    Padres 112 -1.00 L
    Pirates 117 1.17 W
    Giants 120 1.20 W
    Dbacks 107 -1.00 L
    Angels 166 -1.00 L
    Royals 183 -1.00 L
    Os 105 1.05 W
    A loss of .85 units on Monday on a W/l of 4-6. YTD: 78-99,
    +.12 units.

    Tuesday's games:

    Pirates 152
    Cubs 107
    Brewers 116
    Marlins 187
    Giants -101
    Dodgers 106
    Indians 125
    Royals 183
    Jays 140
    Os 101
    Rangers 128
    Angels -102
    Twins 100
    Nats 188
    Phillies 108

  31. #31
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    I sure am getting lazy posting....

    Tues: 5-10, -3.77 units

    Wed: 8-7, +3.32 units

    A terrible day yesterday: 2-9, -5.94 units (YTD:93-125, -6.26)

    Friday's games:
    Cards 122
    Nats 152
    Mets 112
    Phillies 120
    Astros 160
    Rox -101
    Dbacks -101
    Pirates 162
    W Sox 103
    Yankees 103
    Jays 118
    Rays 176
    As 109
    Royals 115
    Mariners 117

  32. #32
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    It was a good week for the doggies, overcoming a -8 unit day to finish 46-51, good for 8.73 units, and that's not counting Monday as I neglected to log it. The week put it back in the black by 2.46 units on a total W/L of 139-176 for the young season.

    I figure I'm probably just gonna post the results weekly, as it's easier for me with my crazy schedule/forgetful mind.

  33. #33
    jesterson
    jesterson's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-27-06
    Posts: 139

    Awful awful week, mostly because of the past few days.

    Week: -23.47 units, 29-60 W/L

    YTD: -21.01 units, 168-236 W/L

  34. #34
    Hulu
    Hulu's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-17-06
    Posts: 664
    Betpoints: 90

    Dogs are just not cashing right now. I didn't really expect to see this until June. Hopefully they will rebound somewhat in the next week.

  35. #35
    EBone
    Washington State +140 over Wichita State
    EBone's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-10-05
    Posts: 1,787
    Betpoints: 158

    Quote Originally Posted by Hulu View Post
    Dogs are just not cashing right now. I didn't really expect to see this until June. Hopefully they will rebound somewhat in the next week.
    Ditto. I'm strugglin' mightily because of the above statement. I'm -12 units on the year because history has not shown itself yet this year. Maybe they'll start cashing in June and July. We shall see.



    E

12 Last
Top