There's no square or sharp plays, there's good plays and bad plays. There's good plays based on objective and logical analysis of games and matchups, and there's bad plays based on emotion and myths. The fact that so many people here think that a play backed by the public is automatically a bad play is mind boggling. For every good pick the public makes (pats on Monday night), they make a terrible play (taking a severely banged up giants team on the road against redskins), so it really means nothing either way
Picking games is not rocket science, there's so many times here people talk themselves out of a great play because "it seems too easy". Many of the best handicappers on the site win because they bet with common sense and objective analysis. That guy "homosayswhat" always wins because he bets on good and smart plays that he came up with, not because "vegas did this, line moved here, trap bet, blah blah blah". He's my favorite poster here because he doesn't buy this sharp/square crap and just has the confidence to believe in his picks
The reason most people are bad at betting is cause they bet with their heart and not their mind. They bet on msu to win tonight even if all prior history indicates a solid victory for lsu because they WANT msu to win. These are the people who bet against justin verlander even when doing that has shown to be bankroll suicide all season long because they want to go against the grain
Bruce Lee - "the key to brilliance is simplicity"