A close call for Clemson at North Carolina gave us some drama in an otherwise uneventful CFB weekend but we should learn a little more this coming week as conference schedules pick up some steam, with Iowa-Michigan and Auburn-Florida standing out as matchups of interest.
In the NFL there was plenty of intrigue, and as is often the case with a 15-game slate, there were also some misleading final scores that we can look to use to our advantage moving forward.
It's difficult to label any win by New England as misleading, given the Patriots' perennial propensity to outperform their stats, but you tell me who would normally win a game when Team A beats Team B 23-11 in first downs at 5.3-3.6 in yards per play. As New England demonstrated in typical Patriots fashion today, a +3 turnover differential and a special teams touchdown will make up for a sizable YPP shortcoming. With regard to Buffalo, i.e. Team A in the above scenario, turnovers come with the territory when Josh Allen is your quarterback (keep an eye on his progression through concussion protocol). But that level of statistical domination over a team of New England's caliber warrants our attention. To hold Tom Brady to a sub-50% completion mark and less than 4 yards per attempt, without a touchdown and with an interception, validates the Bills' defense as being the real deal. And it makes them a team to at least consider looking toward on the betting board moving forward. If not ATS, Buffalo game totals and opponent team totals to the Under will be going under the microscope shall the market leave any room for opportunity.
In another outcome that doesn't tell the whole story, Jacksonville escaped with the win in Denver in a game that was eerily similar down the stretch to Chicago's Week 2 win at Mile High. Today the Broncos won by almost a full yard per play, with their 0.9 YPP edge generally indicative of a 4.5-point scoreboard advantage, but they lost the turnover battle and ultimately the game. After the Chargers' injury report got even longer today - and it was longer than a CVS receipt before Melvin Ingram, Denzel Perryman, Dontrelle Inman and Sean Culkin went down in Miami - Denver may well be worth a look at the Chargers in Week 5 should the Bolts' MASH unit not show significant progress in the coming days.
While the outcomes in Buffalo and Denver weren't too surprising but arguably were misleading, in Baltimore and Indianapolis we saw outcomes that were surprising but not as misleading as one might imagine without digging into the box score.
The Browns benefited from a +2 turnover differential against the Ravens but didn't even need that advantage to win going away in Baltimore, with Cleveland walloping the heavily favored Ravens 8.7-5.9 in yards per play.
The Raiders were another road underdog to win outright with the benefit of the turnover edge yet not the need for it, riding an edge of almost a full yard per play to knock off the Colts.
These numbers make the case that Cleveland and Oakland could be better than we'd given them credit for prior to today, whereas the Ravens might not be as invincible as they looked after a 2-0 start and a Week 3 back door cover in Kansas City, and the Colts might not be a lock to win the division without Luck after all.
Lastly, from the "how much would you have bet if..." files in honor of Dave and his aptitude for impeccable bankroll management, let's look at Minnesota-Chicago. How much would you have bet on the Vikings to cover their leg of a 6-point teaser, which had Vikings +8.5 available earlier in the week, if you knew that:
- Roquan Smith would be a surprise game day inactive for the Bears;
- Mitch Trubisky would go down on Chicago's opening drive and not return, giving way to Chase Daniel; and
- Only 22 points would be scored in the game?
Minnesota ultimately made it interesting, coming up a failed 2-point conversion short of covering the +8.5, but the Vikings' failure to cover their leg was no fluke. When you can't muster 4 yards per play on offense, a 16-0 deficit can be too much to overcome.
Football is full of vagaries, as well noted by forum contributor SportsHec8 in last week's thread following a wild Thursday Night game in Green Bay and as demonstrated again today in Chicago. So as we roll up the sleeves and get to work on Week 5, let's use what we saw in Week 4 as a reminder that anything can and often will happen in the NFL. Success in this endeavor comes via the disciplined accumulation of small edges over time - nothing more and nothing less.