Originally Posted by
aznbluff
People underrate the impact of a defenseman in hockey, since all the headlines and all the commercials go to "star" point producing forwards. Nick Lidstrom was the best player of his generation. The success of his team is a testament to that. I believe Detroit missed the playoffs the year before they drafted him, then have not ever been out of them the last 20 years, winning multiple championships along the way.
However, Lidstrom hasn't been dominant (top 5ish) at his position for a few years now. He won the Norris last year (an absolute joke) with the worst year of his career purely on reputation. He was very average at times, while being good at others. His smarts, positioning, and first pass are all still there obviously. That's not something you lose with age. But when push came to shove, he wasn't on the ice for the tough minutes, the quality minutes that he was leaned so heavily on for in seasons past. He was surpassed by both Kronwall, Stuart, (even) Ericsson in a PK role, and had his load reduced at ES as well. He is still great on the PP, as are most older point producers (Selanne, Jagr, Whitney, etc) since you don't need to move around and they are the softest minutes you can give a player.
He's good, but Suter will be an upgrade on him at this point in every facet of the game (I mean this quite literally). I recognize that Nick was the best of his generation, but also that the game is about to pass him by, and has been on that road for more than a few seasons now. The more irreplaceable test for Detroit will come when Datsyuk leaves at the end of his contract (he has stated that he wants to end his career in Russia).