Originally Posted by
Ladle
Appreciate the response.
Offensively crisp? Yes, perhaps. He blew Dolloway out of the water with deliberate speed. But defensively crisp? Not at all. He's still an enormous liability in that department. It's no coincidence that he's been dropped in four of seven of his UFC fights, and in spite of Cordero's influence, he still got tagged with clean, hard shots from Aaron Simpson consistently. You don't go from having a strike-magnetic face to being defensively crisp in the period of one year.
I agree that Maia isn't a dangerous striker. He tends to lift his rear foot off the ground when throwing which is a boxing no-no in the sense that it detracts greatly from your power. That said, he's still decent enough in the stand-up to put some leather on Munoz. There's little evidence to suggest that Munoz isn't as defensively porous as he's always been.
That claim is unsubstantiated right now. The Dolloway fight didn't show us much other than Munoz's ability to throw a nasty hook. We'll see.
Dan Miller's boxing isn't going to win him the Val Barker Trophy, but he's at least competent on the feet, and Maia was a step above him.
I'm speaking purely in terms of pulling guard and working from there.
Actually, MacDonald was much better equipped than Munoz to deal with Maia pulling guard because of his grappling ability. In spite of that, Maia nearly triangle choked him within 20 seconds. Later on, he swept him almost instantly.
You forgot the part where Simpson took his back standing on a couple of occasions. Pretty significant in a discussion of a fight with Demian Maia, no?
He was briefly taken down by Dolloway, was taken down by Okami, was taken down by Simpson, and (as you pointed out) was taken down by Catone (in a fight which he should have lost in my opinion). Grove tried to stand with him and Hamill kicked his head off. Not an awesome record of defensive wrestling.
Or Maia will lateral drop him like a JV wrestling castoff, as he did to Chael Sonnen. Like I said, Maia is very efficient at finishing takedowns once he gets inside. You're overvaluing Munoz's ability to "power out".
Maia will definitely pull guard if he has to. He might even do that before trying to get a takedown.
So, apart from a Kendall Grove d'arce attempt (a submission which isn't at all easy to secure in an MMA fight), where is the other evidence to suggest that he has notably better submission defense than Sonnen? I don't think there is any.
I'm not saying he's worse than Sonnen, or even equally as bad. I'm saying there's no evidence to suggest that he has considerably better sub defense.
Once again, Simpson took his back in one of those scrambles. We also saw barely anything of Munoz's defensive prowess off of his back (which is what's really significant).
Unless Maia gets clobbered early, it will definitely get to that point. Maia will successfully pull guard at the very least.
Not only did he submit MacDonald, but he absolutely dominated him on the ground for two and a half rounds. It was impressive that MacDonald lasted as long as he did.
All I'll say is, don't bet the house on Munoz. There's a reason why the line is close: Maia has a very clear path to victory too.
Best of luck to you as well.