If You Don't Think Tony Romo is a Top 3 NFL QB.......

[SportsPedagogy]

There is something consistent with the cowboys in big games especially in December over the past several years...it's something that always prevents them from winning, making the playoffs, and representing the NFC in the superbowl...I wonder what it is?

Poor coaching??? This can't be it they have made changes???

The don't get good enough talent??? This can't be it either...they have a lot of talent

The refs cheat??? I haven't seen anything that indicates this would be the case either...

The owner doesn't care about winning??? He seems to be in tune with as much as any owner...
Hmmm wonder what it is??? It has to be something

The amount of logical fallacies in that post is ridiculous. Your obviously trying to hint that it's Tony Romo holding Dallas back. Thats jut stupid. 22 TD's and 9 picks ... i can think of alot of teams who would love to have that.

[RHB041000]

Bradys team sucks, Peyton's team obviously has sucked (0-14 without him)... yet they both win.. why cant romo? You really wanna put him in the same tier as those guys??? they win despite their teams... Romo has a much better team then them, yet still loses, and it falls on him when he cant make the throws when they matter

I will give you the Peyton portion, that cannot be refuted. But brady... i disagree with you on that one, but i guess we will agree to disagree on that one.

but regardless, im not arguing he's THE BEST. im saying he's top 5/6... along with those aforementioned and rodgers, breese.... and then him.... i really think he's 5. in no particular order... brady, manning, breese, rodgers, romo IMO.

It would be retarded for me to say it is absolutely 0 percent Romo's fault they keep losing, but to place all the blame on him is just biased hatred.

[Djstucky]

sorry but this is a dumb, vague post. of course there's talent on the team, it is the NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE. they are all talented, but comparatively to other top tier teams, cowboys talent as a whole just doesn't match up. they don't have the "clutchness".

No shit they don't have "clutchness" (not a word) they have tony fukkn romo...that's my fukkn point...you win one point for getting it right...congrats...now run along...

[warriorfan707]

If Romo was truly a top 3 QB in the NFL, he would have dropped that pass in there on 3rd and 5 with just over two minutes left. Austin was wide open and Dallas should have won the game.

Instead, in typical Romo fashion, he launches the ball 30 yards down the field, overthrowing the receiver, and Dallas is forced to punt.

Then Eli showed Homo how to close out a game.

[RHB041000]

No shit they don't have "clutchness" (not a word) they have tony fukkn romo...that's my fukkn point...you win one point for getting it right...congrats...now run along...

hopeless. gnight.

[SportsPedagogy]

No shit they don't have "clutchness" (not a word) they have tony fukkn romo...that's my fukkn point...you win one point for getting it right...congrats...now run along...

Go look up how many comeback wins Romo has this year.

[antifoil]

he played good tonight. the rest of the team played bad down the stretch.

i don't know why you guys let the eagle fan troll you.

[RHB041000]

Go look up how many comeback wins Romo has this year.

as well as his career QB rating stat for his career. he's only above rodgers, brady and the likes sittin at the TOP. but thats irrelevant too i suppose right?

for the 4th quarter i meant to say.

[Djstucky]

[QUOTE=SportsPedagogy;12744217]The amount of logical fallacies in that post is ridiculous. Your obviously trying to hint that it's Tony Romo holding Dallas back. Thats jut stupid. 22 TD's and 9 picks ... i can think of alot of teams who would love to have

It's not all about td's and picks...there are a ton of intangibles one has or doesn't... these don't show up on stat sheets...for example...romo doesn't convert a 3rd down late in the game...gives the giants the ball...that doesn't show up but was one of the biggest reasons they lost the game...

[Gmen30]

Let's blame Romo..Are you fukkin clowns serious????

[19th Hole]

Think the #3 QB for 2011 in the NFL could complete
a pass to run out the clock and beat the G-Men and COVER??
Hell no...Truly a loser.

[Djstucky]

Go look up how many comeback wins Romo has this year.

Having a bunch of come back wins isn't a stat to be proud of...it means they play from behind often which catches up to you...

[RHB041000]

[QUOTE=Djstucky;12744283]

The amount of logical fallacies in that post is ridiculous. Your obviously trying to hint that it's Tony Romo holding Dallas back. Thats jut stupid. 22 TD's and 9 picks ... i can think of alot of teams who would love to have

It's not all about td's and picks...there are a ton of intangibles one has or doesn't... these don't show up on stat sheets...for example...romo doesn't convert a 3rd down late in the game...gives the giants the ball...that doesn't show up but was one of the biggest reasons they lost the game...

then doesn't that also include the intangibles such as the two offsides penalties on ware and the fumble with felix etc etc? those were just as huge...

[freakydave]

Brady missed it vrs the Bills, Brees missed it vs Rams and Bucs ..... I guess Aaron Rodgers is the only good QB in the league.

Yup just keep pretending this is the first time he's had the game in his grasp & choked.Do you know the difference between BLOMO & those other 3 QB's? all 3 of them are going to the playoffs again this year.

[TexansFan]

Romo is not and never has been a top 3 QB. The next big game he wins will be his first.

[SportsPedagogy]

It's not all about td's and picks...there are a ton of intangibles one has or doesn't... these don't show up on stat sheets...for example...romo doesn't convert a 3rd down late in the game...gives the giants the ball...that doesn't show up but was one of the biggest reasons they lost the game...

Romo has the highest 4thQ. QB rating in NFL history. Cowboys up by 12 with 5 mins left... All on the defense. Romo put up 34 points .... all passing TD's. He has made plenty of clutch throws this season.

Terrance Newman is the biggest reason Dallas wont have any big success this season.

[RHB041000]

Yup just keep pretending this is the first time he's had the game in his grasp & choked.Do you know the difference between BLOMO & those other 3 QB's? all 3 of them are going to the playoffs again this year.

this would be a non issue had jason garrett not iced his kicker last week with that timeout hahaha. ohwell, im done w/ this, just silly talk.

[antifoil]

yeah but maybe only one will win. the rest will just be losers like romo. there will be no difference in the end.

[paco]

Romo has the highest 4thQ. QB rating in NFL history. Cowboys up by 12 with 5 mins left... All on the defense. Romo put up 34 points .... all passing TD's. He has made plenty of clutch throws this season.

Terrance Newman is the biggest reason Dallas wont have any big success this season.

Is that u Tony?

[SportsPedagogy]

Romo is not and never has been a top 3 QB. The next big game he wins will be his first.

another idiotic statement that just proves my theory. Its only a big game if the Cowboys lose.

[dwaechte]

Having a bunch of come back wins isn't a stat to be proud of...it means they play from behind often which catches up to you...

The amount of idiocy in this thread is staggering.


So Romo doesn't get credit for comeback wins because it means he doesn't play well enough early... but also doesn't get credit when he plays well early and puts his team in a position to win late. Gotcha.

[RHB041000]

Romo has the highest 4thQ. QB rating in NFL history. Cowboys up by 12 with 5 mins left... All on the defense. Romo put up 34 points .... all passing TD's. He has made plenty of clutch throws this season.

Terrance Newman is the biggest reason Dallas wont have any big success this season.

Newman has plagued the Cowboys for many years now.

[RHB041000]

The amount of idiocy in this thread is staggering.


So Romo doesn't get credit for comeback wins because it means he doesn't play well enough early... but also doesn't get credit when he plays well early and puts his team in a position to win late. Gotcha.

[frostno98]

Terrible defense, terrible kicker. Not much you can do, if your kicker can't kick or your defense can't stop anyone.

[warriorfan707]

Let's blame Romo..Are you fukkin clowns serious????

Are you blind? Did you see that 3rd down play with 2 minutes left?

[Gmen30]

Dallas should trade for Tebow. He is awesome.

[dwaechte]

I love how Romo haters are resorting to using one incomplete pass(and not exactly a simple play either. Sure, the receiver was open, but the defender was still between Romo and the target meaning he had to drop it in... a throw good QB's make more often than not but still a throw that Brady or Brees or anyone misses somewhat regularly) as Romo's latest "Choke". Not an interception(Like Eli has thrown in a lot of big moments this year), or a fumble, or a botched snap, or a poor decision... an incomplete pass in a situation where their win probability went from .82 to .71(Though that's generic WP, not team specific which would probably skew things against my argument a bit)

[bigsmitty]

Tonight's game was not lost because of Romo but neither did he put his team in a strong position to win the game. Yes, he struggled and fought,etc to set up the game-tying FG but that's the point in my opinion. If you scramble and struggle that many times you're bound to make poor decision/rushed throws and so on which Romo does. Eli was absolutely spectacular in this game and the DAL defence was brutal but Romo was not great. Moments of greatness, moments of poorness. I don't hate on Romo but neither do I put him in one of my "feel secure with this guy on the field" lists...Cheers

[jsmithj88]

Brady missed it vrs the Bills, Brees missed it vs Rams and Bucs ..... I guess Aaron Rodgers is the only good QB in the league.

pats are 10-3
saints are 10-3

both have superbowl wins
those players deserve some slack
choking as many games as romo has choked .............
u dont get to referenced along with those qbs

[Djstucky]

Are you blind? Did you see that 3rd down play with 2 minutes left?

Fukk yes...someone else that understands how big certain things are that don't show up on a stat sheet...

[Djstucky]

I love how Romo haters are resorting to using one incomplete pass(and not exactly a simple play either. Sure, the receiver was open, but the defender was still between Romo and the target meaning he had to drop it in... a throw good QB's make more often than not but still a throw that Brady or Brees or anyone misses somewhat regularly) as Romo's latest "Choke". Not an interception(Like
Eli has thrown in a lot of big moments
this year), or a fumble, or a botched
snap, or a poor decision... an
incomplete pass in a situation where
their win probability went from .82 to
.71(Though that's generic WP, not team
specific which would probably skew
things against my argument a bit)

It wasnt an easy play??? How many chances do you get to throw the ball to a guy that has 2 steps on the defender??? Granted a blitz was on but it's the NFL...you make these plays to win games...or in romo's case you don't and lose them...

[TexansFan]

another idiotic statement that just proves my theory. Its only a big game if the Cowboys lose.

The only idiots in this thread are those that think he belongs in the top 3. This wasn't a big game?

How about this, since Romo has been in the league how has he done in the playoffs? Romo is a nice player when there's no pressure, but chokes under the pressure.

It's ok if you're a Romo homo, but please remove your head from your ass. Thanks.

[warriorfan707]

Fukk yes...someone else that understands how big certain things are that don't show up on a stat sheet...

The idiocy of some of these morons is unreal. The whole point is all the top 3 QB's in the league find a way to drop that pass in there.

Romo finds a way to fuk things up.

[warriorfan707]

Top 3 QB my fukkin foot

[TexansFan]

It's simple really, very few elite QB's in the NFL. Romo isn't one of them.