If You Don't Think Tony Romo is a Top 3 NFL QB.......

[PAULYPOKER]

Who ever thinks Romo is in the top 5 even,is also buried in sports betting because they see what is not there,delusional so to speak........

[opie1988]

they also have the niners at #3 in their power rankings
where is peyton on their list? Im assuming not on there? espn's rankings have always been god awful

Uhhhh.......Peyton hasn't played all year.

Sorry, chief.....but I have to defer to the worldwide leader on this issue.

Again, I'm man enough to admit I was wrong.....

Romo is #4.

[opie1988]

Who ever thinks Romo is in the top 5 even,is also buried in sports betting because they see what is not there,delusional so to speak........

Well then, I have to ask.....

Based off of your countless "lock thread" losses.....what exactly is it that you see?

[dlunc3]

so bc he hasnt played for 10 months, he isnt better then romo?

[PAULYPOKER]

Well then, I have to ask..... Based off of your countless "lock thread" losses.....what exactly is it that you see?

they see what is not there.........

[opie1988]

so bc he hasnt played for 10 months, he isnt better then romo?

No, because he hasn't played.....

He's not better than Tony THIS YEAR.

[cant call it]

opie, tony romo is like the nelson cruz of football.

[dlunc3]

willis mcgahee has been better then cj this year... does that mean he is better?

victor cruz is having a better year then larry fitz... does that mean he is better?

you cannot base rankings off one one year

Real Rankings:

Easily top 5 with no debate-
1.Rodgers
2.Brady
3.Peyton
4.Brees
5.Roth

6. Rivers
7-9. Romo/Vick/Eli all can be tossed around based on personal preference

[lovetobet]

willis mcgahee has been better then cj this year... does that mean he is better? victor cruz is having a better year then larry fitz... does that mean he is better? you cannot base rankings off one one year Real Rankings: Easily top 5 with no debate- 1.Rodgers 2.Brady 3.Peyton 4.Brees 5.Roth 6. Rivers 7-9. Romo/Vick/Eli all can be tossed around based on personal preference

Somebody got it right!!! Ding, ding, ding!!

I don't know if I totally agree with the order of 1-5 but you have all the right players in there and you certainly have the #1 guy correct. There is NO WAY that ROMO is a top 3 QB. You can maybe start to make some arguments for the 4th spot if you leave P. Manning out of the argument but you don't watch enough football if you honestly are making the assertion that Romo is better than Rogers, Brees or Brady. Seriously? What are you smoking, it's obviously good, because it's clouding your judgement.

[psufan]

Romo lovvves to self destruct once in a while. Then he tries to bs his way out of it with the "America's team, cowboys swag" that is tangential to the NFC east mentality. Don't get me wrong, their team has talent and he can play once in a while. But all in all him, his Cowboys squad and their coverage manifests what being spoiled is about.

[PAULYPOKER]

Here is what a top 3 QB looks like>

Ben Roethlisberger #7 of the Pittsburgh Steelers throws a 79 yard touchdown pass to teammate Antonio Brown #84 against the Cleveland Browns during the game on December 8, 2011 at Heinz Field










Ben Roethlisberger limps down the steps to the locker room after the Steelers' 14-3 win over the Cleveland Browns in an NFL football game in Pittsburgh, Thursday, Dec. 8, 2011.

[Goat Milk]

i think Romo has won 1 playoff game in his whole career.

and every year he has one of the most talented teams in the nfl.

romo will never win a ring

[SportsPedagogy]

Big Ben threw a pick that almost cost them the game .....
Romo came back from a punctured lung to beat the 49ers defense ...

i love the talk that Dallas is so stacked ....
what has T.O. , Terry Glenn, Julius Jones, or Patrick Crayton done without Romo ?

We all know what happened vs the Seahawks. Everybody forgets that Romo drove them down there... she shouldnt have dropped the snap ... but a lil bit of football knowledge suggest the kicker should have done something. a half second block and Romo scores a TD, even if he grabs him and holds him, the TD would be negated but they still kick a FG 10 yards back. Regardless, there was alot of time left and Josh Brown was kicking like a mad man, he probably would have kicked a 48 yarder to win it ...
The game vs the giants, Romo threw a pass to Crayton that would have been the 1st down and probably a TD to put them up by 2 scores, he dropped it ... the defense gave up go ahead touchdown, Romo drove the ball back down the field and had to force it on 4th down. it was picked. He didnt throw a game losing pick. There were no open receivers and no downs left. Go back and watch the play.
The Game vs the vikings was complete domination. The cowboys were destroyed off the ball. Romo was hit in the backfield almost everytime he got the ball.

[PAULYPOKER]

[dlunc3]

Big Ben threw a pick that almost cost them the game .....
Romo came back from a punctured lung to beat the 49ers defense ...

i love the talk that Dallas is so stacked ....
what has T.O. , Terry Glenn, Julius Jones, or Patrick Crayton done without Romo ?

We all know what happened vs the Seahawks. Everybody forgets that Romo drove them down there... she shouldnt have dropped the snap ... but a lil bit of football knowledge suggest the kicker should have done something. a half second block and Romo scores a TD, even if he grabs him and holds him, the TD would be negated but they still kick a FG 10 yards back. Regardless, there was alot of time left and Josh Brown was kicking like a mad man, he probably would have kicked a 48 yarder to win it ...
The game vs the giants, Romo threw a pass to Crayton that would have been the 1st down and probably a TD to put them up by 2 scores, he dropped it ... the defense gave up go ahead touchdown, Romo drove the ball back down the field and had to force it on 4th down. it was picked. He didnt throw a game losing pick. There were no open receivers and no downs left. Go back and watch the play.
The Game vs the vikings was complete domination. The cowboys were destroyed off the ball. Romo was hit in the backfield almost everytime he got the ball.

I must not have read this right... There is no way you just said, "what has TO done without Romo?"??????? Are you kidding me???

[Goat Milk]

Big Ben threw a pick that almost cost them the game ..... Romo came back from a punctured lung to beat the 49ers defense ... i love the talk that Dallas is so stacked .... what has T.O. , Terry Glenn, Julius Jones, or Patrick Crayton done without Romo ? We all know what happened vs the Seahawks. Everybody forgets that Romo drove them down there... she shouldnt have dropped the snap ... but a lil bit of football knowledge suggest the kicker should have done something. a half second block and Romo scores a TD, even if he grabs him and holds him, the TD would be negated but they still kick a FG 10 yards back. Regardless, there was alot of time left and Josh Brown was kicking like a mad man, he probably would have kicked a 48 yarder to win it ... The game vs the giants, Romo threw a pass to Crayton that would have been the 1st down and probably a TD to put them up by 2 scores, he dropped it ... the defense gave up go ahead touchdown, Romo drove the ball back down the field and had to force it on 4th down. it was picked. He didnt throw a game losing pick. There were no open receivers and no downs left. Go back and watch the play. The Game vs the vikings was complete domination. The cowboys were destroyed off the ball. Romo was hit in the backfield almost everytime he got the ball.

DId you just put the 2nd greatest reciever in NFL history in the same sentence as Patrick Crayton? Owens has done a lot without Romo chief. Thanks.

[Goat Milk]

What did Dion Branch do in seattle when he went there? Nothing.

How about all those other recievers brady had in NE? What did they do when they left? Nothing.

Brady makes Hall of Famers out of scrubs.

[lovetobet]

Here is what a top 3 QB looks like>






Ben Roethlisberger #7 of the Pittsburgh Steelers throws a 79 yard touchdown pass to teammate Antonio Brown #84 against the Cleveland Browns during the game on December 8, 2011 at Heinz Field










Ben Roethlisberger limps down the steps to the locker room after the Steelers' 14-3 win over the Cleveland Browns in an NFL football game in Pittsburgh, Thursday, Dec. 8, 2011.

Seriously, now you with the top 3? Seriously??? I like Big Ben but over Brady, Brees or Rodgers?? Not a chance you're as high as the Dallas lover if you think he's top 3 over them and I left Peyton out to. Come on this isn't that hard, you can argue about order, blah, blah, blah but Brady, Brees and Rodgers are hands down the top 3, not necessarily in that order

[SportsPedagogy]

I was being rushed at the end. I had to go Christmas shopping with the woman. Two things, first, I was saying, what did T.O. Do after Romo. Owens was past his prime when he was in Dallas. He had two less then average seasons and now he can't find a team.

My second point, it looks like I am making excuses for Romo, but I am not. I agree that GREAT QBs find a way to win. I agree that Tom Brady has a weak supporting cast and he fit it done. My point is, football is such a team sport that you can not judge a QB by team results. What if they ruled The first tuck rule play a fumble, or if Vinitari wasn't so clutch ? Then you have People saying Brady can't close out the big ones.

Everybody bashes Romo cause he "makes mistakes at inopertune times" .... Is there really a good time to make mistakes ? Every QB makes mistakes. How many times has Peyton manning blew it ? That pick six cost his team the Super Bowl and won it for Brees. Eli Manning threw a horrible pass that should have been picked to ice the game, instead it was dropped and he is the Superbowl MVP. Brees and the Saints lost to the Seahawks last year in the playoffs.

My point is, no QB is perfect. They all have their strengths and weaknesses. It is ludacris to judge a QB off of simply playoff records because there will be one QB who wins the superbowl, and 31 who do not. It takes a complete team effort, and a little bit of luck to win one.

[SteveRyan]

This thread is ridiculous.

The OP was referring to Romo's performance this year.

The difference between top 5 and top 3 is totally insignificant.

Look at the stats for yourself.

[rwd201]

Roethlisberger is in the Top 5 for sure
They should print him on the 100 dollar bill

[Big Bear]

Top 3 are 1. Rodgers 2. Brady 3. Brees don't know who the 4th is the top 3 are so much better than all the others.

[smoke a bowl]

Top 3 are 1. Rodgers 2. Brady 3. Brees don't know who the 4th is the top 3 are so much better than all the others.

4) Tebow?

[SportsPedagogy]

4) Tebow?

No ! Since we only go by records here, Tim Tebow is number 2!!!!

[p19101]

It depends on if you base it upon this season or whole career, what's the criteria?

This season then Eli is def top5, if career then yeah maybe not so much...

[k13]

I want all these top 5 QB's to play on the Browns for a year then we'll see who's really the best.

[KKoz9]

i think Romo has won 1 playoff game in his whole career.

and every year he has one of the most talented teams in the nfl.

romo will never win a ring

complete and utter bullshIt ^^^^

[SportsPedagogy]

complete and utter bullshIt ^^^^

He has mistaken Romo for Phillip Rivers.

[dlunc3]

I want all these top 5 QB's to play on the Browns for a year then we'll see who's really the best.

peyton has played for a team worse then a browns, as we can see by their record this yr... that argument is not vaild

[PAULYPOKER]

Put Roethlisberger in a Dallas uniform and they go to the Superbowl 1st year.......

Understand now Dallas fans?,the most blind bias there is..............

[k13]

peyton has played for a team worse then a browns, as we can see by their record this yr... that argument is not vaild

Playing with great WR's and TE's while being in a dome/turf for most of your games is the same as playing for the Browns.

Drew Brees would shit his pants if he played for the Browns. He'd do nothing.

Don't forget you play Bal/Pit 4 times a year.

[dlunc3]

Playing with great WR's and TE's while being in a dome/turf for most of your games is the same as playing for the Browns.

Drew Brees would shit his pants if he played for the Browns. He'd do nothing.

Don't forget you play Bal/Pit 4 times a year.

How is dallas clark and his 28 catches doing this year? the colts win 11 games with peyton... 0 without.... you cant even make an argument that the browns have a worse surrounding cast

[SportsPedagogy]

Put Roethlisberger in a Dallas uniform and they go to the Superbowl 1st year.......

Understand now Dallas fans?,the most blind bias there is..............

BS. Ben is cradled by the greatness of his defense. You are so bias.

[p19101]

BS. Ben is cradled by the greatness of his defense. You are so bias.

^this

[SportsPedagogy]

How is dallas clark and his 28 catches doing this year? the colts win 11 games with peyton... 0 without.... you cant even make an argument that the browns have a worse surrounding cast

werent they 10-6 with him last year ? Didnt he blow the game vs Dallas last year by throwing 4 picks ?