Is he really going to Liverpool for £35m?!?!?!?!?!?!?!????!?!!??!??!!???
More than Luis Suarez and David villa!!!!!!!!
irlandais_noir
SBR Wise Guy
12-02-10
812
#2
Sources now saying deal "in excess of 35M with add-ons", it's a ****** up world we live in these days
Comment
EaglesPhan36
SBR Aristocracy
12-06-06
71662
#3
If they're shipping Torres out, they'll get that money back + some and it won't matter. Yeah they overpaid ridiculously, but in the big scheme of things, I don't think they'll lose money.
Comment
phenomenon
SBR MVP
03-11-10
3227
#4
HE really DESERVE this money ?
Comment
swiss88
SBR Wise Guy
02-07-10
906
#5
BBC.co.uk:
1704: Yep, the BBC has just had confirmation that Newcastle did reject Liverpool's second bid of £35m for Andy Carroll. BUT we understand that will not be the end of the matter... If and when a third bid is made, we will let you know. Carroll is apparently keen on the move, remember.
wow!
Comment
Hall2Collie
SBR Sharp
01-03-11
462
#6
Even as a Newcastle fan who loves Carroll as a player
I'd so take this deal and run
Do it Ashley
Comment
Mr.Kitty
SBR MVP
11-10-09
1880
#7
Yeah hopefully they accept the deal since I have a bet on Carroll to leave. Spurs wont give up on him either, its said that their bid is money + Crouch.
Comment
TurkzZ
SBR MVP
01-07-09
4095
#8
this is a joke, they should hold the money till end of season and plan out some good transfers, 35 mil, really!
Forward points to Karayilan, i am unable to receive SBR points
Comment
Hall2Collie
SBR Sharp
01-03-11
462
#9
Newcastle rejected the bid but now Carroll has handed a transfer request in
Comment
Hall2Collie
SBR Sharp
01-03-11
462
#10
He's heading there for a medical now
Deal looks to be done
Comment
Mr.Kitty
SBR MVP
11-10-09
1880
#11
Liverpool confirmed that Newcastle has accepted the £35m bid on Carroll. Very nice transfers by Pool IMO, Carroll + Suarez will score lots of goals. I think Suarez will be a hit in PL, he has already showed that he can perform on a high level at the world cup.
Comment
Hall2Collie
SBR Sharp
01-03-11
462
#12
35mil is way too much for Carroll but he should still be a decent player for them
Comment
Supamanu
SBR Sharp
02-22-10
425
#13
I think he and suarez will make a nice pair but thats a lot of money, i guess this means that torres is gone now?
Comment
Mr.Kitty
SBR MVP
11-10-09
1880
#14
Yes, Torres is most likely history, think he passed his medical at Chelsea. And Adam is close to signing for Liverpool, they are stayin busy. United is also keen on signing him but looks like Pool are in pole position right now. I think Pool feel pressured to act, especially if/when Torres leaves, hence the big price on Carroll. They arent where they want to, and with a new manager that want to get players he want.
Comment
shinobi90
SBR Rookie
01-30-11
23
#15
such inflated fee would definitely put pressure on carroll to perform . Thou he is an quality player
Comment
decado
SBR MVP
08-23-10
2392
#16
I love the upcoming financial fair play.
I see bad years coming for mainly English and Spanish teams when UEFA starts banning football clubs in 2015 that are sunk in debt.
Better stop that money-wasting bs now. Andy Carroll ain't even 20mio worth.
Comment
The Special One
Restricted User
01-08-11
3972
#17
Originally posted by decado
I see bad years coming for mainly English and Spanish teams when UEFA starts banning football clubs in 2015 that are sunk in debt. Better stop that money-wasting bs now. Andy Carroll ain't even 20mio worth.
very true, I hate seeing players go for so much money early in their careers because it leaves no room for inflation when they reach their peaks... clubs like Liverpool and Newcastle seem to want to SPEED UP their value inflation in order to gain advantage over other clubs - but if a player like Carroll goes for 35 mil now, what will be his value in 3-5 years? he should be valued at around 15-20 mil now and maybe later, at around 30-35... truly a joke...
Comment
Hall2Collie
SBR Sharp
01-03-11
462
#18
Originally posted by decado
I love the upcoming financial fair play.
I see bad years coming for mainly English and Spanish teams when UEFA starts banning football clubs in 2015 that are sunk in debt.
Better stop that money-wasting bs now. Andy Carroll ain't even 20mio worth.
Liverpool is just spending the Torres money that they are recieving
There was no official confirmation from Stamford Bridge but Telegraph Sport understands that Torres is travelling down to London where he will be checked over by Chelsea's doctors. Personal terms are still to be agreed, although these are not expected to be a problematic
Chelsea's lavish spending comes on a day when they reported an annual operating loss of £68.6m. The club's results for the financial year to end June 2010 show a small increase in turnover from £203.3m to £205.8 million, but with operating loss reducing from £72.3 to £68.6m.
Liverpool, meanwhile, have confimed the signing Newcastle United striker Andy Carroll, who will replace the Spaniard at Anfield. Liverpool will pay £35 million for the England forward, with various add-ons included in the deal.
Comment
Hall2Collie
SBR Sharp
01-03-11
462
#20
Originally posted by The Special One
very true, I hate seeing players go for so much money early in their careers because it leaves no room for inflation when they reach their peaks... clubs like Liverpool and Newcastle seem to want to SPEED UP their value inflation in order to gain advantage over other clubs - but if a player like Carroll goes for 35 mil now, what will be his value in 3-5 years? he should be valued at around 15-20 mil now and maybe later, at around 30-35... truly a joke...
What is Newcastle doing to speed it up? They didn't come in with an offer 10+mil over his value
They simply accepted the crazy offer
Comment
The Special One
Restricted User
01-08-11
3972
#21
Originally posted by Hall2Collie
What is Newcastle doing to speed it up? They didn't come in with an offer 10+mil over his value They simply accepted the crazy offer
let me rephrase, I rushed with the comment... (clubs like Liverpool - in the Newcastle situation) AND NOT INCLUDING NEWCASTLE...
but nevertheless, what Liverpool is doing is bullshit...
Comment
pouroupoupou
SBR Wise Guy
03-13-10
971
#22
this is insane
Comment
HCBoone
SBR Wise Guy
01-18-10
596
#23
Every body now english players is ridiculously over valued. Lescott to Man City for £25m, and that's a CB who never plays the important games. The price on Carroll is laugable as is Torres £50m and Bent £24.
Liverpool has been put in a situation were they need to buy as Torres 3 days before the deadline hands in a TR so thats also part in it.
Finally Liverpool pay the big money but they arent doing it without selling for huge money so I don't really see the problem with Liverpool spending huge...
Chelsea are going way out of line spending 50 for a striker who's had all injury problems you can have and has lost a lot of pace.
Comment
irishbettor92
Restricted User
01-31-11
63
#24
andy carroll good all round player but not worth 35mil to be honest
Comment
RedDevil11
SBR Sharp
01-18-10
335
#25
Originally posted by irishbettor92
andy carroll good all round player but not worth 35mil to be honest
totally agree....he's making Berbatov look like a bargain now...lol. Or you could have gotten 4 Van der Vaarts for this price.
Comment
Scottish
SBR Wise Guy
12-21-10
588
#26
Carroll is the best aerial threat in the Premier League bar none, the price is a bit inflated but hes young, him and Suarez will be a good partnership if given the service.
Comment
Karayilan9
Restricted User
01-10-09
3742
#27
Getting rid of Torres was a good move, can't believe Chelsea paid 50 mil for him, ever since his injury he's been a shadow of his former self.
Liverpool needs to stop rushing, Suarez is a great player but 35 mil for Carroll that's an expensive gamble, they could have done alot better for that price.
Comment
JOHON8
SBR Hall of Famer
01-28-10
7712
#28
Originally posted by Karayilan9
Getting rid of Torres was a good move, can't believe Chelsea paid 50 mil for him, ever since his injury he's been a shadow of his former self.
Liverpool needs to stop rushing, Suarez is a great player but 35 mil for Carroll that's an expensive gamble, they could have done alot better for that price.
Yeah Carroll is a great player, but he's overrated. For 35 mil they should go after someone to take Xabi Alonsos position a few years ago. Gerrard is alone in the midfield surrounded by average midfielders.
Comment
The Special One
Restricted User
01-08-11
3972
#29
ok so now Suarez and Carroll up front, but who to give them the ball?
Comment
Karayilan9
Restricted User
01-10-09
3742
#30
Originally posted by The Special One
ok so now Suarez and Carroll up front, but who to give them the ball?
Lucas
Comment
The Special One
Restricted User
01-08-11
3972
#31
Originally posted by Karayilan9
Lucas
ok...
if they had kept Benayoun, it may have worked out better...
currently, I dont like any of their mid-fielders for a serious game (like say vs MNU)...
Comment
Arsenal
SBR MVP
01-30-09
1349
#32
Liverpool are so stupid to pay this much money for Carroll?
Comment
nulldah
SBR MVP
01-27-10
1473
#33
ok, people, keep saying it's stupid move or whatever.
is that expensive move? check.
is he still "rookie" in premier league? check.
is he a player dalglish has known long enough? check.
is torres dalglish's striker or rafa's striker? rafa's striker.
given torres is gone, can suarez be the only major offense liverpool has? NO.
So, considering all that, if I'm asked this question in December:
unhappy torres or suarez+carroll with net spending 10M pounds? I will take the latter as liverpool fans. Crazy? Yes. Risky move? Yes. But I prefer this kind of move than leaving those 25M pounds idle until the end of the season (If Hodgson still here, I believe that is the move).
After all, we never really have 2 pure good strikers for years since Heskey, Fowler and Owen era. (N'gog is still learning and learning)
Comment
Fabu88
SBR Rookie
01-22-11
22
#34
I would rather take the two anytime, but i would definitely not pay as much for carroll as they did. I would rather pay more for suarez than carroll.. imo 20 for carroll max.
Comment
Karayilan9
Restricted User
01-10-09
3742
#35
Originally posted by The Special One
ok...
if they had kept Benayoun, it may have worked out better...
currently, I dont like any of their mid-fielders for a serious game (like say vs MNU)...
I was being sarcastic, Lucas isn't going to get Liverpool anywhere.
Mascherano and Alonso were the backbone of the the team when they were the best in Europe, their current crop of midfield players excluding Gerrard just doesn't cut the mustard.
They should invest in a top quality defensive midfielder and playmaker instead of breaking the bank with a gamble on Carroll. This move was rushed, Carroll hasn't even proved himself yet, he's young and will be under pressure likes he's never faced before.