Best Gangster/Crime Movie Of All Time

[Cougar Bait]

Yeah American Me is a great movie. If people want to vote for others they can...just had to narrow it down some way.

Bread...do you want to change your pick from Heat to American Me then?

[Bread]

No. Heat is the shit.

[jellobiafra]

Sometimes Herman and Sammy get a little too worked up after watching these types of movies.

CALM DOWN BOYS!!!

Cougar, to answer your question in this confusing as fukk proposition.... sure - I'll go with True Romance even though it won't win. Great, great movie. Anything...and I mean ANYTHING with Christopher Walken is golden to begin with but this movie is great from script to screen and it has held up well over time. One of my all-time favorite flicks.


Bread!! Great fukkin synopsis man.

[Cougar Bait]

Updated in contention for the #5 spot is

Carlito's Way with 2 votes. Once Upon A Time In America, Donnie Brasco, American Gangster, Heat, Casino, Pulp Fiction, Gangs of NY, and True Romance all with 1 vote.

[Shark79]

Casino

Carlitos Way

GF I and II

Heat is pretty much for gringos.

[Mudcat]

Is that pick of the boys in their panties from Gomorrah?

[Cougar Bait]

Casino Carlitos Way GF I and II Heat is pretty much for gringos.

OK Shark you have 4 picks. 2 are from the initial 4 GF 1&2 and are already in.

Casino or Carlito's Way? If you had to pick only one?

[Shark79]

Casino.

[neclannec]

Reservoir Dogs
is the best

[PAULYPOKER]

1.goodfellows
2.the departed
3.scarface
4.casino
5.f--k the rest!!

[Killer_Demo]

goodfellas
state property 2
blue hill avenue
killa season
colors

[Cougar Bait]

Pauly pick one from Departed or Casino as your pick for the #5 slot.

[jellobiafra]

Cougar I'm lol'ing at you having to explain this to everybody who posts after the fact.

Way to make things clear in the OP you asshole! I HATE you.

I'm just kidding.

I love you.

[ericc]

Godfather 2 is the best movie, period.

[Cougar Bait]

goodfellas state property 2 blue hill avenue killa season colors

Cougar I'm lol'ing at you having to explain this to everybody who posts after the fact. Way to make things clear in the OP you asshole! I HATE you. I'm just kidding. I love you.

Yeah. I love it.

I love you too Jello. But not in a mature, forgiving way. Mostly in a forceful, unmotivated assault way.

[PAULYPOKER]

pauly pick one from departed or casino as your pick for the #5 slot.

thats my story and i'm sticking to it

[Cougar Bait]

Update is:

Casino and Carlito's Way 2 each
8 other movies 1

I'll let this run until tomorrow, then start the poll to chose the best out of the top 5.

[Brocc]

Scarface
Godfather I
Godfather II
Goodfellas
A Bronx Tale

[Cougar Bait]

In no particular order: Scarface Godfather I Godfather II Goodfellas A Bronx Tale

So is your vote for the #5 slot A Bronx Tale?

[protein]

List is a Joke if Sopranos is not included

[Cougar Bait]

List is a Joke if Sopranos is not included

Sopranos isn't a movie.

[The Seer]

Menace to Society was kinda fuked up.
I didn't see it on the list at first glance but Heat with Pacino and DeNiro was a classic.

[Cougar Bait]

Seer...is that your vote for #5? Heat? A movie you've never seen?

I will allow it...but am thinking people are now just fukking with me for fun, which I completely respect.

[Brocc]

So is your vote for the #5 slot A Bronx Tale?

Correct

[Hilljacademics]

I vote for Heat

[McBa1n]

Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels has to be in the hunt.

[Capybara]

Cougar Bait, I applaud you for doing a movie thread!

But I'm a little thrown because your list seems very liberal with what you call a gangster movie. Very liberal.

So since we're including everything, I guess I'll say here is my Top Five:

1. Pulp Fiction
2. No Country for Old Men
3. Sexy Beast (Ben Kingsley is the scariest gangster in film history in this movie.)
4. The Usual Suspects
5. Snatch

[Cougar Bait]

Capy...Gangster/Crime...so I think all the ones on my list of movies qualify. Every movie you got there is a great selection. Which one would you like counted towards the #5 slot? Pulp Fiction?

[robmpink]

How come Kangaroo Jack didn't make the top 25? Unreal!

[Cougar Bait]

How come Kangaroo Jack didn't make the top 25? Unreal!

[The Seer]

Seer...is that your vote for #5? Heat? A movie you've never seen?

I will allow it...but am thinking people are now just fukking with me for fun, which I completely respect.

I've seen it a ton of times, I meant i didn't see it on the list at first glance.

[The Seer]

Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels has to be in the hunt.

that movie was awesome

[Cougar Bait]

Seer's vote for Heat gives it the current lead for the #5 spot with 3 votes. Casino and Carlito's Way both have 2, and 9 others with 1.

[Mudcat]

As I watch Cougar Bait attempting to manage this thread, there is an expression I am reminded of:

like trying to herd cats

[Capybara]

Sure, Cougar, count Pulp Fiction for me, since it's in my Top Five All-Time overall list anyway!

Ah, movies.

Everyone start thinking about your all-time all-genre Personal Top 25 lists, and I will start a thread soon for that!