Halladay Report Card So Far

[Ace_of_Spades]

B-

Maybe even worse than that.

[TobiasFunke]

Are you serious?? Worse than a B-??

[seaborneq]

I have read some posts that predicted 25-30 wins since leaving the AL East. Too early to call. He was bought in for the playoff run.

[obamaismyuncle]

Cliff Lee..

[stealthyburrito]

i'd say around B+/A-, remember only 27 runs scored by the phils in his last 10 starts.

[seaborneq]

i'd say around B+/A-, remember only 27 runs scored by the phils in his last 10 starts.

This Roy Freakin Halladay we are talking about here. Try to shut them down if the phillies are not scoring. you can't lose if it is 0-0.

[philswin]

No much run support - But this game was on him. Got him a lead into the 8th

[gryfyn1]

dont be stupid -- Halladay is currently the one of the top pitchers in the NL

• 3rd in WAR for pithers
• 4th In ERA
• 3rd in wins
• 8th in WHIP
• 1st in BB/9
• 8th in SO
• 1st in CG
• 1st in SHO
• 1st in IP
• 1st in SO/BB
• 3rd in ERA+

Any way you slice it hes still an A pitcher

[clarkj2]

He's just been unlucky; if you look at his peripherals, he's still top notch.

[keyboarding]

He's just been unlucky; if you look at his peripherals, he's still top notch.

Most people on SBR have no idea what peripherals even means, including the idiot who started the thread.

[Ace_of_Spades]

He's been sucking it up this season. B- for me, fuk you all cock fukers.

[rickbo528]

I wonder if Phillies are starting to think that maybe Cliff Lee would have been the pitcher to keep after all. Who has been more dominant lately? Take away the perfect game (I know you can't) and Halladay is only 8-7. He is giving up a lot of hits lately. 13 to the Reds today. Before the year is out they may wish they had kept Lee. What if the Mets get Lee before the deadline and win the east! Who is a proven money postseason pitcher. Just food for thought.

[Mikail]

I wonder if Phillies are starting to think that maybe Cliff Lee would have been the pitcher to keep after all. Who has been more dominant lately? Take away the perfect game (I know you can't) and Halladay is only 8-7. He is giving up a lot of hits lately. 13 to the Reds today. Before the year is out they may wish they had kept Lee. What if the Mets get Lee before the deadline and win the east! Who is a proven money postseason pitcher. Just food for thought.

I sadi it last year and I will say it now. The Phillies made a huge mistake by letting Cliff Lee go. Picking up Halladay was a great idea, but not if you had to lose Cliff Lee. No disrespect to Roy Halladay. He is an ace. Just not on his game like Cliff Lee is.

[big joe 1212]

He is going through a bad stretch right now, but I'm sure he'll be back to his A game soon!

[ZetaPsi808]

guy can pitch on 3 days rest in the playoffs.

[cala56]

he is the best pircher i ever seen

[keyboarding]

I sadi it last year and I will say it now. The Phillies made a huge mistake by letting Cliff Lee go. Picking up Halladay was a great idea, but not if you had to lose Cliff Lee. No disrespect to Roy Halladay. He is an ace. Just not on his game like Cliff Lee is.

I don't know how anyone could justify keeping Lee over Halladay. Honestly, I can't possibly fathom why. It makes no baseball sense.

[gryfyn1]

He's been sucking it up this season. B- for me, fuk you all cock fukers.

Well stop being a fool and paying ridiculous juice on him

[Ace_of_Spades]

Well stop being a fool and paying ridiculous juice on him

I haven't backed him once this season.

[JEK]

He's got good #'s but the money he's being paid, I would expect better #'s. Roy is very competitive, if you asked him personally, I bet he would tell you that he could have been a little better so far.

[keyboarding]

Roy is very competitive, if you asked him personally, I bet he would tell you that he could have been a little better so far.

I bet you he would also say he made mistakes in the perfect game, too. Dude's a machine.