Kershaw vs. Halladay?

[Rand2359235252]

Clayton Kershaw is unbeaten in his last seven starts, going 5-0 with a 0.63 ERA (3 ER/42.2 IP). The Dodgers are 7-0 in his last seven starts.

Would you trade him for Roy Halladay?

[BobHarvey]

To me that's a no brainer. I'd keep Kershaw. I'd trade Billingsley before I traded Kershaw.

[The HG]

if it's just for the rest of this year, no-brainer, of course I'd trade Kershaw for Halladay

[cap10]

keep kershaw; hally past his prime;

[diogee]

Kersh is young and has looked brilliant at times...when he is locating he is almost unhittable. Definitely worth hanging on to...don't think I'd make the trade from the Dodgers standpoint having a young ace like Kershaw that has great stuff and can dominate.

[rjt721]

No.

[Shortstop]

I'd keep Kershaw.

[LT Profits]

No way, Kershaw may have some Cy Youngs in his future.

Now don't get me wrong, Halladay is still one of the best pitchers in the game and I could certainly understand a team wanting to win this year making a big move for him. But you just can't sacrifice the future in doing so.

[thebestthereis]

The Dodgers know in the post season season they are vulnerable so Halladay is a true #1 which they don't have. To win it all you need at least 1 guy (like Hamels last year) to dominant typically. To win now (maybe) yes, but I wouldn't do it.

[Rio DiNero]

This is non-sense there is no way the LAD give this kid up, we may be looking at the next Sandy Koufax! (YOU HEARD IT HERE FIRST!)

[pavyracer]

I'd trade Kershaw for Halladay. This is a no brainer.

[CashMoney]

Short term - Yes
Long term - No
Realistically - Hell No

[Richkas]

Stupid question because its not going to happen

[lakerboy]

Stupid question because its not going to happen

you tell em rich

[cankid]

I think you have to look at Kershaw and look long term

[element1286]

Probably not.

Dodgers probably don't have enough to get Halladay unless they deal Kershaw.