Advice Appreciated

[BigDeem5]

In a keeper league, can play 2 Qbs I have Rodgers, Lynch, Kap, and Marshall.

Can keep 3 - was going to go kap Rodgers Marshall n I have first pick next year

Dilemma:

Rg3 is draft able because guy is keeping Russel Wilson over him.

Should I keep Lynch and draft Rg3 or keep Kap over Rg3

You play 2 qbs a week.

[BigDeem5]

Crabs torn Achilles is what is making me rethink.

[EASports]

WR's/RB's are the most replaceable players on a football field. I would be more concerned about keeping Kap if there were huge changes made on their offense line.

Of course a guy like Calvin Johnson is irreplaceable, but the majority of those players production can be replicated by another group of players.

[Wrigley]

RG3 coming off the injury might disappoint

[stikymess]

RG3 coming off the injury might disappoint

This is true, I would hope they manage him better and teach him to slide better or throw the ball away.

[xraygord]

Holy crap, someone is planning early.

[Andy117]

If you only keep 2 are you picking 1st?

[BigDeem5]

Everyone keeps 3- I won Toilet Bowl for 1st pick.

[playersonly69]

How do you guys actually make keeper leagues work?


We always end up losing like 2 or 3 owners every season. Maybe it is because the entry fee is $1200, but it makes it impossible for us to usea keeper league

[Wrigley]

This is true, I would hope they manage him better and teach him to slide better or throw the ball away.

Agree alot of that was the coaches fault he should have not stayed in the game when he got injured shannahan fault

[Mitchell88]

I really hope RG is good to go. I think that he might be a little shaky to start just cause he will be worried about hurting it again.

[Andy117]

Everyone keeps 3- I won Toilet Bowl for 1st pick.

Ok, well I'd keep Lynch anyway.

[BigDeem5]

So it is either keep Lynch and draft Rg3 or keep Kap and could still draft Lynch or other top guy.

[dudekid]

I'd keep lynch personally. I completely disagree with whoever said "WR and RB are the most replaceable" if anythig QB is BY FAR the most replaceable...just as an example, think of how late in drafts RG3/Luck went, russell wilson wasnt even drafted in most leagues, now you are talking about taking them 1st or keeping them! Lynch is a workhorse back, I wouldnt give that up. you can keep rodgers because he is elite, keep marshall because he is pretty much the best WR out there, and keep lynch because he is a beastly workhorse goal line back which is all but extinct these days...then you can find a second qb elsewhere, even if you don't take RG3, which i might not even do at the #1 overall depending on who else is on the board when you pick

[Jrod124]

Lynch no doubt I would keep with of course Kap and Rodgers since u can start 2 QBs. Then grab the best RB or WR available with your 1st pick, u should be able to get a nice RB so u have a good QB and RB combo

[Otters27]

Keep Kap he is less likely to get hurt than RG3

[BigDeem5]

QBs always score highest, Kap/Rodgers are probably 2 of top 5.. Figure I keep them and Marshall ( Top 3 WR)

Lynch has back spams/DUI luming, also Percy Harvin/Russell Wilson will steal some of his TDs this year...

That is my thinking.. Now, I could still draft Lynch #1 pick overall


But b/w Kap/RG3, you guys like Kap or RG3

[Jrod124]

QBs always score highest, Kap/Rodgers are probably 2 of top 5.. Figure I keep them and Marshall ( Top 3 WR)

Lynch has back spams/DUI luming, also Percy Harvin/Russell Wilson will steal some of his TDs this year...

That is my thinking.. Now, I could still draft Lynch #1 pick overall


But b/w Kap/RG3, you guys like Kap or RG3

Just not sure how RG3 will return after that injury. I love Kap this year so I would take him over RG3, slightly

[Otters27]

Definitely keep Marshall. RGIII is too much of risk. I also would not draft lynch #1 depending on who the other guys keep

[dudekid]

any chance you could give some of the other options you can get at #1?

[Straight Cash]

So it is either keep Lynch and draft Rg3 or keep Kap and could still draft Lynch or other top guy.

I'd go with Lynch and RG3 with Crabtree going down.

[Andy117]

Definitely keep Marshall. RGIII is too much of risk. I also would not draft lynch #1 depending on who the other guys keep

One thing I've realized with WRs is that if you aren't strong early you're generally not gonna get there. It seems harder to find WRs as the season goes on than RBs. When a starting RB goes down his backup is instantly valuable, that doesn't really apply to WRs.

[Wrigley]

Unless you can get AP , Foster id take a wr first

[BigDeem5]

I mean my keepers Marshall, Rodgers are no brainers.. I think Kap is a great QB, Lynch is solid but there will be other guys to draft at #1 too.

[me-first]

I would definitely keep Kap, Rodgers and Marshall..

[Robber]

Congrats deemer on big toilet win

[dudekid]

either way you cant go wrong i just think its easier to find production for a qb2 than an rb1