Buster

[jayson311]

I can't stand having him on my team... is he worth trading or is he the value everyone claims he is?

[jayson311]

May trade him or atleast try too...

[Grits n' Gravy]

Unless you are getting something great back in return you hold onto Posey.

[ProPicker713]

Trade him for Gantis! Gantis will dominate at turner field this year off the scrubby lefties in the NL.

[dudekid]

dont trade him for gattis, he will lose a lot of playing time once mccann is back. if you have a spot right now pick up a catcher who is hot..use him until posey heats up

[Cross]

MVP last year, relax dude.

[BigSpoon]

Still too early to panic. At least wait until he heats up a bit if you really want to trade him.

[opie1988]

Slow starter. He'll be back to form here soon.

[Wrigley]

dont trade him for gattis, he will lose a lot of playing time once mccann is back. if you have a spot right now pick up a catcher who is hot..use him until posey heats up

I agree with dudekides statement dont trade him

[me-first]

if you had enough confidence in him to waste a high pick, now is not the time to trade him..

[Otters27]

Keep him or try to get Wilin Rosario and another start. If not hold him

[Andy117]

I can't stand having him on my team... is he worth trading or is he the value everyone claims he is?

Why did you draft him?

[jayson311]

blah

He is just so damn frustrating

[Robber]

Posey>>>>>>gattis

Shame he plays in a tough home park

[opie1988]

So many of the Giants are slow starters.

[Mitchell88]

Slow starter. He'll be back to form here soon.

he will come around dont think it is worth doing anything right now. he will heat up

[LT Profits]

Why would anyone "hate" having Posey? He is head and shoulders above all other catchers in MLB and frankly it's not even close. Find another catcher that you can pencil in for 15-20 HR, 100 RBI and .300 BA with a lot of at-bats because Posey plays first base when he is "off".

[LT Profits]

He is just so damn frustrating
[ATTACH]55902[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]55904[/ATTACH]

Are you seriously stressing every single at-bat in April?

[gryfyn1]

srssly, trade him for anything you get; he struck out so he must not be worth having on your team; even if you can't trade him he's batting 231 so you may as well just drop him.

[jayson311]

Are you seriously stressing every single at-bat in April?

Ohhh I am just so stressed.... taking xanax all day. Also if doesn't matter what month if I am dropping games

[jayson311]

great empty slot today

:+whippin

[dudekid]

again it still early...give him a chance

[jayson311]

again it still early...give him a chance

Your right. I am just a micro manager

[BigSpoon]

He will produce numbers soon enough, just need to hang tight.

[ProPicker713]

:+whippin

Well that's the main reason Giants are down 7-1 right now to Gallardo.

[stevenash]

Trade him for Gantis! Gantis will dominate at turner field this year off the scrubby lefties in the NL.

You know once McCann gets back Gattis gets reduced to part timer.
Also, Gattis is 2 for his last 19, he was a flash in the pan for two weeks, .391 down to .261, will continue to nose dive to the .240's or so.
He's got the attention of all MLB pitchers after his flash start, they are getting him out regularly all week, and will continue to do so.
Plus he's a crappy OBA guy, barely over .300 on base percentage.

Posey is a proven .310 hitter in the bigs.
I know he's frustrating owners because he's hitting .217, he's not going to wind up .220, even if he winds up at .280 by the break, which I think he will, that means he'll hit .320 between then and now.

Ridiculous to trade a MVP catcher for a AA catcher who was hot for 2 weeks and will never get that hot this season again. Not even close.

If I owned Gattis, and I was offered Posey for him straight up, I'd pull the trigger on that deal 101 times out of 100

[Otters27]

Buster will start to payoff later. Keep him and ride him out.

[Straight Cash]

Value is too low to trade. Just keep him, he'll come around eventually...

[Robber]

Posey stil the best fantasy catcher

He'll probably wind up batting 300 anyway

[stikymess]

If you are set on trading him I think now would be the worst time, as no one will give you value, you will end up on the wrong side of the trade.

[Cross]

He will be big if you hold now.

[Straight Cash]

I actually think that instead of trading him, people that dont have him should be trying to trade for him. Maybe you can find someone looking to dump him...

[playersonly69]

Just keep him on your team

[MrZ]

Do not trade Posey.

[Andy117]

I actually think that instead of trading him, people that dont have him should be trying to trade for him. Maybe you can find someone looking to dump him...

Buy low, sell high!