If Youve Ever Failed A Drug Test You Should Be Banned From Hall of Fame

[BernardMadoff]

I say yes, what do you guys say.

[Vesuvius]

Saw this on PTI discussion, if you ban one, you have to ban them all...I guess I'm good with either way but if they do get in then YES have an asterisk saying they failed and are dopers

[Kaladarus]

They should test more so they catch everyone and anyone that has failed should be taken out for sure. It's cheating and against the rules. Either take them all out of the hall of fame or make drugs okay and not against the rules.

[Reno Paul]

Dang the players in the 60's and early 70's were doing speed way before drug tests.....The days of Koufax, Mantle, Mays, Gibson, McCovey, Cepeda, Rose, Frank Robinson, Brooks Robinson.........I think Barry Bonds was a Hall of Fame type of player before he really got into roids.

[Optional]

Erase their names from all records.

[Dirty Sanchez]

They should start a "special" Hall for juicers...it would be full...many guys are praying that secret 106 that tested positive a few years ago never comes public. Only ARod was outed...I'm sure there were some big names on that list

[Reno Paul]

Think there will be a few years where no one gets in the Hall.....Except for a few old timers from the Veterans committee.

[BRAVES1985]

"baseball was better with steroids"



charlie sheen

[mmike032]

depends on what drugs

[cornwallace]

totally yes

[Fischnasty]

i am of a different opinion on this one

[JimmysEgo]

go for the glory... whatever it takes.

[doublej95]

yes.

[zam77]

Their should be a section of the hall that is dedicated to the failures who made. If they've been proven failures and they still get in, that's where they end up.

[wonderyears]

depends on the drug test they're failing. HGH, yes. Pot, no.

[ROYAJA8]

I say no if they were drug testing before then it would be fair to ban them. So manny I guess your in.

[iceminers26]

pretty much already the case, I don't think any of those guys in question will ever get in. Me personally I could care less if they juice, they should just base it on their stats.

[Lincoln73]

The hall of fame is overrated anyways, who cares.

[HotStreak]

Your suggested rule would be very hypocritical, seeing that even the old timers were popping amphetamines or snorting lines. Every era of baseball was trying to get an edge. This isn't a bunch of choir boys were dealing with here. Accept it.