Javier Baez needs time in the minors
It's usually not a good thing when a hitter admits to being completely lost. Of course, strikeouts are nothing new for Baez: He fanned 225 times in 154 games between Triple-A and the majors in 2014. His strikeout rate was so prodigious in the majors -- 95 in 229 plate appearances, that give him a season's worth of 650 PAs and you'd have 270 strikeouts, a pace that would shatter Mark Reynolds' major league record of 223 set in 2009.
Baez is only 22 and I guess that Reynolds season is what Cubs' fans can dream on: At age 25, Reynolds hit .260/.349/.543 with 44 home runs. Imagine that production from a second baseman.
The trouble is, that season came in 2009, the last before the strike zone got bigger and offense plummeted. Reynolds never came close to those numbers again. Since 2010, he's hit .212/.316/.430 for five different clubs and signed with the Cardinals this year, where he projects as a platoon first baseman and bench player.
Overall, Reynolds' value has been minimal, in part because he was an error-prone third baseman and now as a first baseman, a .212/.316/.430 line isn't that useful.
Can Baez, who hit .169 in 52 games with the Cubs, turn into a second-base version of Reynolds? Here's a chart comparing Reynolds from 2010-2014 to Baez's initial stint in the majors:
As you can see, he has a long ways to go just to match Reynolds, let alone be better. Even when he did connect, his Isolated Power was lower than Reynolds' mark. (Baez hit nine home runs in 213 at-bats, but just six doubles.) The one thing Reynolds has done, even while hitting .212, is draw walks to at least boost his OBP over .300 despite the terrible averages. Baez's problem isn't just the swing-and-miss issues that Reynolds has but swinging and missing at pitches that aren't strikes. As long as he continues chase balls out of the zone he'll struggle to hit .200.
Again, however, he's young, and he has a history of scuffling at each new level before figuring things out. Still, his walk rates have never been strong:
2013, Class A/Double-A: 6.9 percent
2014, Triple-A: 7.8 percent
Again, however: When Reynolds was 21, he was in the Midwest League and had a walk rate of 7.6 percent; Baez reached the majors at 21.
Considering the hype Baez has generated coming up, Cubs fans may be depressed seeing him compared to Mark Reynolds. Having Maddon around should be a plus -- "As we continue along I think you’re going to start to see him make his adjustments and become more comfortable," he said. "He's applying a little pressure on himself right now. I'm really not worried. I've been around guys like him before. He needs to play and relax."
The Cubs have other options at second base in Tommy La Stella and Arismendy Alcantara. Plus, once Addison Russell is ready to take over at shortstop, Starlin Castro may have to move over to second. Are the Cubs better off sending Baez down so he can have some success and learn to better control the strike zone, or is there an urgency to see what he can do now in the majors before the Kris Bryant/Russell/Castro infield pushes him out of a spot? There's also the chance he grows bored at a level he's already had success at.
It's not an easy decision for the Cubs. We have all spring training to see what kind of adjustments he makes, but right now it's looking like more of the same as last year, which means he's not ready for the majors. I'd start him in the minors and make him prove he can make better contact before giving him another chance.
"He's thinking too much," (Joe) Maddon said. "He's getting a lot of information from all of us and sometimes I think it's our fault. I just want to leave him alone and let him play. I'm not concerned. The guy cares so much."
There's a progression going on with Baez that simply may or may not end well. He struggles, recognizes he needs to make changes and goes about doing so. He drops weight, adjusts his approach and swing but the results don't come right away. Odds are they wouldn't. So now the coaches say they need to back off and just let him play.
"It's a long process," Baez said before Monday's game against the San Diego Padres. "(Yesterday) I was worrying too much about the mechanics so that's why I was completely lost."
There's a progression going on with Baez that simply may or may not end well. He struggles, recognizes he needs to make changes and goes about doing so. He drops weight, adjusts his approach and swing but the results don't come right away. Odds are they wouldn't. So now the coaches say they need to back off and just let him play.
"It's a long process," Baez said before Monday's game against the San Diego Padres. "(Yesterday) I was worrying too much about the mechanics so that's why I was completely lost."
It's usually not a good thing when a hitter admits to being completely lost. Of course, strikeouts are nothing new for Baez: He fanned 225 times in 154 games between Triple-A and the majors in 2014. His strikeout rate was so prodigious in the majors -- 95 in 229 plate appearances, that give him a season's worth of 650 PAs and you'd have 270 strikeouts, a pace that would shatter Mark Reynolds' major league record of 223 set in 2009.
Baez is only 22 and I guess that Reynolds season is what Cubs' fans can dream on: At age 25, Reynolds hit .260/.349/.543 with 44 home runs. Imagine that production from a second baseman.
The trouble is, that season came in 2009, the last before the strike zone got bigger and offense plummeted. Reynolds never came close to those numbers again. Since 2010, he's hit .212/.316/.430 for five different clubs and signed with the Cardinals this year, where he projects as a platoon first baseman and bench player.
Overall, Reynolds' value has been minimal, in part because he was an error-prone third baseman and now as a first baseman, a .212/.316/.430 line isn't that useful.
Can Baez, who hit .169 in 52 games with the Cubs, turn into a second-base version of Reynolds? Here's a chart comparing Reynolds from 2010-2014 to Baez's initial stint in the majors:
Reynolds | 31.30% | 12.20% | 0.218 | 46.00% | 35.90% | 24.60% |
Baez | 41.50% | 6.50% | 0.155 | 46.80% | 43.70% | 38.50% |
As you can see, he has a long ways to go just to match Reynolds, let alone be better. Even when he did connect, his Isolated Power was lower than Reynolds' mark. (Baez hit nine home runs in 213 at-bats, but just six doubles.) The one thing Reynolds has done, even while hitting .212, is draw walks to at least boost his OBP over .300 despite the terrible averages. Baez's problem isn't just the swing-and-miss issues that Reynolds has but swinging and missing at pitches that aren't strikes. As long as he continues chase balls out of the zone he'll struggle to hit .200.
Again, however, he's young, and he has a history of scuffling at each new level before figuring things out. Still, his walk rates have never been strong:
2013, Class A/Double-A: 6.9 percent
2014, Triple-A: 7.8 percent
Again, however: When Reynolds was 21, he was in the Midwest League and had a walk rate of 7.6 percent; Baez reached the majors at 21.
Considering the hype Baez has generated coming up, Cubs fans may be depressed seeing him compared to Mark Reynolds. Having Maddon around should be a plus -- "As we continue along I think you’re going to start to see him make his adjustments and become more comfortable," he said. "He's applying a little pressure on himself right now. I'm really not worried. I've been around guys like him before. He needs to play and relax."
The Cubs have other options at second base in Tommy La Stella and Arismendy Alcantara. Plus, once Addison Russell is ready to take over at shortstop, Starlin Castro may have to move over to second. Are the Cubs better off sending Baez down so he can have some success and learn to better control the strike zone, or is there an urgency to see what he can do now in the majors before the Kris Bryant/Russell/Castro infield pushes him out of a spot? There's also the chance he grows bored at a level he's already had success at.
It's not an easy decision for the Cubs. We have all spring training to see what kind of adjustments he makes, but right now it's looking like more of the same as last year, which means he's not ready for the majors. I'd start him in the minors and make him prove he can make better contact before giving him another chance.