I really want Suh to win just because its so unorthodox even though I doubt he will.
Comment
BigdaddyQH
SBR Posting Legend
07-13-09
19530
#3
Ingram will probably win it because of his teams record. Gerhart should win it because of his on field production. Suh is probably the best player of the three. McCoy and Tebow do not even belong in the conversation.
Comment
tblues2005
SBR Hall of Famer
07-30-06
9235
#4
I like Ingram but it is going to be close though.
Comment
darrell74
SBR Posting Legend
04-16-07
14648
#5
I think Ingram wins it, but I don't believe he deserves it.
My thoughts:
Harrel got snubbed, last year. Heisman is for the pompous schools
Lefevour deserves a shot, but pompous writers snubbed him because its only Central Michigan.
I like Pike for a while, but he got injured.
Colt McCoy deserves it, imho. (that's if I had to take someone from the aforementioned list)
Except for Nebraska title game, McCoy crushed everybody.
Remember, nobody talked about Suh, until he got a national game with Texas- my point is that the Heisman is a crap trophy. To me, best player in college football, does not get Heisman.
OBTW, Carson Palmer was the last non-bust in the NFL to win the heisman since 2000. (I also say Reggie Bush is a bust)
Comment
kalamity85
SBR High Roller
10-28-09
233
#6
i want gerhart
Comment
roasthawg
SBR MVP
11-09-07
2990
#7
Hopefully Suh... probably McCoy.
Comment
yisman
SBR Aristocracy
09-01-08
75682
#8
Hopefully Suh, but I think Ingram gets it, to become the first Alabama player to win it.
[quote=jjgold;5683305]I win again like usual
[/quote]
[quote=Whippit;7921056]miami won't lose a single eastern conference game through end of season[/quote]
Comment
ezmoney
SBR MVP
09-26-09
1564
#9
handsdown Suh,...
he beat Texas, except for last second field goal??? McCoy not that sharp, Neb got robbed!!! Defense STOPPED Texas completley.
Take them to pound Az, one of my top plays, Holiday Bowl, Dec 30th.
Fred
Comment
wookieehumper
SBR Sharp
11-09-09
355
#10
If Ingram doesn't win it, I'll be shocked. Gerhart has the stats, but he's on a mediocre team and hasn't played on a prime time stage. McCoy would have been a lock to win it, but his dud of a game during the final week of the season really hurt him. Suh is the best player out of all the finalists, but defensive players on a mediocre team have zero chance of winning the Heisman no matter how dominant he is. And Tebow... please... he shouldn't have even been invited.
Comment
moodyt2
SBR Sharp
11-04-09
448
#11
I would like for Ingram to win ,but if he doesn't it would give Alabama even more of a edge heading into the title game. It would give the Tide more to prove and give extra motivation, especially if McCoy wins. Yes it would be nice for Alabama to win their first Heisman. But I would rather win the National Championship and lose the Heisman. or win both would be awesome!! My prediction is 1. Ingram 2. Gerhart 3. Suh 4. McCoy 5. Tebow
Comment
moodyt2
SBR Sharp
11-04-09
448
#12
last day to vote
Comment
boba
SBR High Roller
12-12-07
147
#13
i hope ingram wins it and the jinx happens so Texas can win the title and i get my dog bet cover.