Ok....good news (error found in totals) but bad news (wasn't found earlier)
The LOGIC that went into totals: was correct and IS VERY PROFITABLE, double checked verified/all good
The calculation that went into a sheet that told me what to pick for totals each day - was missing a portion of the equation. What I mean here is I have equations on a sheet with all the games from all years till 2007 - shows a great profit. When I import "today's games", the calculations go into a separate sheet in Excel that has only today's games, and not all 15,000. When I placed the calculations on this page, one part of the equation was not factored in