Login Search

1st base Umpire made a bet on the Angels to Win.

Last Post
#10

Default

Quote Originally Posted by Marigold HD View Post
Umpires are always out of position and just guess the outcome of plays. Let the players determine the outcome, and not the umps
I doubt they 'just guess' the outcomes of plays. I am really not sure what you mean by they are out of position either. I mean I have seen it before, but it was once in a season type of thing, of course they will make errors sometimes. But 95 percent of the time they make the right call. Might be more then that. If you look at all the first base play, where if you look at it from 'above', meaning you are not a fan. IMO they get it right 9.9/10 times. Sure there is not unique case where they get it wrong, but there is no need for replay for on the bases.

I think the way they have it now with home runs being the only replay option is fine. Really what else could you use it for, not strikes. Fair Foul balls on the line? Its pretty easy to tell if its fair or foul by looking at the mark of impact.