Who's The Greater Yankee: Mariano Rivera Or Derek Jeter?
Begin.
Dead even
I think most Yankees fans feel that way.Originally Posted by konck
Dead even
We have to wait to see Jeter until the end of his career though because Mo is already the greatest ever at his position.
Paul O'Neill. =P
Can't deny that O'Neill was a great Yankee.Paul O'Neill. =P
well philli to be honest .. u cant really compare .. same amount of rings ... moe greatest closer ever .... jeter top 3-4 ss ever ... as a yankee fan u just accept them both ...if u had to choose which one was more important i guess u can have a little argument there but me as a yankee fan i was glad to have both!
well philli to be honest .. u cant really compare .. same amount of rings ... moe greatest closer ever .... jeter top 3-4 ss ever ... as a yankee fan u just accept them both ...if u had to choose which one was more important i guess u can have a little argument there but me as a yankee fan i was glad to have both!
Jeter could make a case as greatest SS ever if he finishes his career with 3600+ hits.
But you're right, just accept them both.
However............who's the greater Yankee? LOL
Jeter!!!!
ding ding ding! That's one vote for The Captain.Jeter!!!!
One of my favourite. Great player and likeable guy, he didn't begin his career with NY though.
Can't deny that O'Neill was a great Yankee.
Lou,One of my favourite. Great player and likeable guy, he didn't begin his career with NY though.
how did you feel about Scott Brosius? I loved that guy.
Hands down Rivera
Its not even close
98 team probably only one good enough to win without mo
Jeter not a difference maker. Even in his prime. Mo irreplacable
Only difference making play jeter made during the run was the flip in oakland. They are done that year without that play
Last edited by Br0nxer; 05-16-12 at 03:29 PM.
Mariano Rivera easily.....Yankees fan my whole life
i agree with moe being important but u have to love both of them for what they have done for us....
and greatest SS ever was honus wagner .... lol jeter isnt on his level
OK so we got 2 votes for Mo and 1 for Jete.i agree with moe being important but u have to love both of them for what they have done for us....
and greatest SS ever was honus wagner .... lol jeter isnt on his level
What a great argument. It's never-ending.
As for Honus Wagner, yes, right now he's the greatest, but we have to wait until Jeter is actually finished.
What if Jeter gets 4000 hits?
What if he gets to be the all-time hits leader?
