Stevie, I'd try and work it out with the Judge, as Peep suggested, before making it public here. Things looked a little shakey when their owner got arrested in the spring, but to the best of my knowledge they've never stiffed anyone. IMO their (poor) reputation on here is a little undeserved given what some of the higher rated books get away with, eg. BetEd and BetUS.
Judge is usually pretty quick in responding, contact him first, then post.
As mentioned, other larger shops like BetUS deserve the low grade for their tricks. BFC has always paid, but gets a low grade more so based on prior ownerships legal issues. When there have been payout complaints, they have been quickly resolved.