Whos the most overrated player in the NFL

**SportsPedagogy** · 10-13-11, 09:41 PM

Originally posted by jsmithj88

i dont remember people calling steve young a choker

They kept saying he could win the superbowl, when he finally did he did the big "Somebody please get this monkey off my back" thing in front of the camera. Not the same as Romo, but it shows how quickly people are to judge someone.

**roundcake** · 10-13-11, 09:53 PM

tiki barber and dwight freeney

**SportsPedagogy** · 10-13-11, 09:54 PM

Originally posted by roundcake

tiki barber and dwight freeney

Tiki isnt in the NFL

**jsmithj88** · 10-13-11, 10:08 PM

Originally posted by SportsPedagogy

They kept saying he could win the superbowl, when he finally did he did the big "Somebody please get this monkey off my back" thing in front of the camera. Not the same as Romo, but it shows how quickly people are to judge someone.

then thats clearly different than being called a choker

**zsr** · 10-13-11, 11:10 PM

Originally posted by DwightShrute

hurts me to say it but REGGIE BUSH should be considered

He used to be, but now i think everyone knows he's just not good. Texans made a great decision in that draft.

**PAULYPOKER** · 10-14-11, 05:55 AM

Easy choice..

**kickenchicken** · 10-14-11, 09:12 AM

chaz ohchostinko me hombre chew elstinko... lol

**Scully** · 10-14-11, 06:41 PM

Very good question but too bad the answer isn't so difficult.
The most overrated player in the NFL, barnone, is none other than Michael Vick hands down.

**Full Time Hobo** · 10-14-11, 06:47 PM

Eli Manning
Polamalu

**thejrichshow85** · 10-14-11, 07:12 PM

tony romo

**Trampas** · 10-17-11, 11:18 AM

jamarcus russell

**kickenchicken** · 10-17-11, 11:49 AM

cam newton... dont get me wrong hes a great player but too many turnovers for everyone to say he is such a great player right now...he will be great but over-rated right now for all the hype

**bb_skoots** · 10-17-11, 12:11 PM

Originally posted by Full Time Hobo

Eli Manning Polamalu

fail.

**uup115** · 11-14-11, 01:37 PM

Eagles are 3-8 in last 11 games Vick has played. 19 turnovers and only 13 tds...how many in the red zone? Countless bad decisions. Never looks over defensive sets after a bad series. Limited audible options because of limited "ability". Has to call too many time outs because of limited control of system. Same problems as in Atlanta but now with better coach and better surrounding talent...the common denominator for his suck, is Vick himself. WINNER BY A LANDSLIDE!

**FindTheLock** · 11-14-11, 01:45 PM

Originally posted by thezbar

P. Manning, a non factor this season.
Phillip Rivers, his best days are in the past.
D. Mcnabb, see the above comment.

I can understand your points for rivers or mcnabb, but how can you call Peyton manning over rated? The colts win 12 games every season when he is the starter, and right now without him they have yet to win a single game...

**KingJD31** · 11-14-11, 01:51 PM

mike vick hands down gotta atleast be top 5.......revis is a beast he doesnt have the skills deon had but common who the **** does

**will2survive** · 11-14-11, 02:01 PM

Dez Bryant--- Such a talented player but it's all about results. Somehow, I don't think that he'll ever have a consistent career with results

**face** · 11-14-11, 02:03 PM

aaron rodgers. what's so great about throwing completions making big plays sometimes. oh, he won a super-bowl, big deal.

**Glitch** · 11-14-11, 03:51 PM

Originally posted by face

aaron rodgers. what's so great about throwing completions making big plays sometimes. oh, he won a super-bowl, big deal.

hes great man. can run, throw, make good decisions, throw long or short bullets, manages the clock, sells the fakes, accurate with a good arm and good field vision.

tony romo = overrated

**face** · 11-14-11, 04:00 PM

i'll bet you thought jerry rice and walter payton were good too. playmaking is overrated.

**Monte** · 11-14-11, 04:44 PM

Originally posted by Monte

Rivers

It's rare enuf, but i had this one right

**Dkid** · 11-14-11, 05:13 PM

tony romo ..

coming from a cowboys fan.

**riffraff24** · 11-14-11, 05:17 PM

Romo rivers flacco

**antifoil** · 11-14-11, 05:25 PM

when there is a consensus on if a player is overrated. they can't be overrated, because most people don't think they any good.

**Goat Milk** · 11-14-11, 07:51 PM

Originally posted by KingJD31

mike vick hands down gotta atleast be top 5.......revis is a beast he doesnt have the skills deon had but common who the **** does

as a pure cornerback, Charles woodson is much better. the best ever in my opinion. he's a better tackler than deon. deon was more versatile and could do more on the field overall

**Full Time Hobo** · 11-14-11, 07:57 PM

Originally posted by Full Time Hobo

Eli Manning Polamalu

Originally posted by bb_skoots

fail.

Must be a steeler fan
Hes a good player but over the past few weeks I've watched this guy blow it multiple times.
Eli has his ups and downs but dont think hes anything great either

**neverstoppers23** · 11-14-11, 07:59 PM

people are still debating this. come on people it is not that hard. it is tebow.

**Glitch** · 11-14-11, 08:00 PM

polamalu and rodgers were very incorrect answers. not a steelers or packers fan.

**DJ Dana** · 11-14-11, 08:03 PM

Sanchez is an easy choice for me. He chokes nearly every time it matters and was somewhat annointed before he really played a single game.

**beerman2619** · 12-21-11, 01:55 PM

Mike Vick is proving again this season just how overrated he is. Now 22nd in the league with a qb rating of 80.6. Ha down there with guys like Tavaris Jackson and Joe Flacco. Good god Kevin Kolb is higher then Vick in qb rating this season. Vick has 13 tds with 13 ints that sucks. 9 fumbles 3 loss another season where this guy is a turnover machine. 59.9 pct on his pass completions ranks near the bottom also. Again getting hurt which he does every season. Its easy to see just how overrated this guy is Eagles paid way to much money for this guy. Like i've said he has been a pretty good running back in this league at the qb position. But he has never been that good of a qb 2010-11 had one good season thats it. If you look at his number in Atlanta not that great at all.

**Br0nxer** · 12-21-11, 02:24 PM

Hands down and its not even close

Matt Ryan

**uup115** · 12-21-11, 04:33 PM

Originally posted by Br0nxer

Hands down and its not even close

Matt Ryan

sure, the guy is going to pass for over 4000 yds and throw 30 tds first 4 seasons all winning, and probably will break the first 4 year wining record....how is he overrated? he is not top 5 but we all know who they are...how is he overrated when he is the best of the rest?

**thechaoz** · 12-21-11, 04:37 PM

Vick and it's not even close... Eli Manning up there too

**p19101** · 12-21-11, 04:53 PM

Cutler is UNDER rated...

**p19101** · 12-21-11, 04:54 PM

Tebow is the definite answer to the question asked...