[Fishhead]

Very average QB, ESPECIALLY at this stage of his career.


Another f ucking blunder by the Redskins organization, which has been a common theme of theirs for the past 15 years or so.

[Chi_archie]

Redskins ownership takes the exact opposite approach that the Steelers have always taken......


not sure why they can't wake up and smell the lack of super bowl rings

[The Seer]

looking good in the division for the Cowboys again

[Fishhead]

redskins ownership takes the exact opposite approach that the steelers have always taken......


Not sure why they can't wake up and smell the lack of super bowl rings

spot on!

[Chi_archie]

disagree with AVG marking though....


guy has a better career QB rating than half the hall of fame

[Fishhead]

disagree with AVG marking though....


guy has a better career QB rating than half the hall of fame

PLLLEEEEZ.........QB RATINGS are but "ONE" halfass meaningless statistic.

McNabb is "average" at this point in career ...........AT BEST!


Eagles fans should be rejoicing that this guy will be playing in their own division........what a great, great trade by the Eagles management team.

[rm18]

McNabb has the lowest INT percentage of all time I think, but still not sure if I like this move.

[Fishhead]

It's a great move for the Eagles, that's who it's a great move for!

[bruceBRUCEbruce]

McNabb has the lowest INT percentage of all time I think, but still not sure if I like this move.

he's third-tied with world beater Neil McDonnell, and just above other world beaters Jeff Garcia and Mark Brunell. Aaron Rogers and David Garrard are 1 and 2.

and this is probably because when McNabb misses, he misses low, and bounces it, rather than missing high with floaters, ala Favre.

he is vastly overrated.

[3PtShooter]

dont think he has the heart to be championship QB,,Reid see's this has benched him and Mcnabb has even taken himself out of games

[Unicorn7]

I think Billy Kilmer will have a decent year if he can get some help from Larry Brown and Charlie Harraway in the back field

[jjgold]

McNaab always give his team a chance to get to superbowl which is a amazing stat, if he has a few more good years and nfc championship games with wash he is a 1st ballot hall of famer.

[Fishhead]

McNaab always give his team a chance to get to superbowl which is a amazing stat, if he has a few more good years and nfc championship games with wash he is a 1st ballot hall of famer.

True

That's asking a LOT though........


The fact is, at this point in his career he is a very average QB..........at best.

[THEGREAT30]

Average QB's consistently get there teams into the playoffs. If he is average Brees is garbage considering he has gotten his team to playoffs 50% or less of the time

[Fishhead]

Average QB's consistently get there teams into the playoffs. If he is average Brees is garbage considering he has gotten his team to playoffs 50% or less of the time

Tell that to a Philly fan and see what they say........an intelligent Philly fan that is.

[bruceBRUCEbruce]

Average QB's consistently get there teams into the playoffs. If he is average Brees is garbage considering he has gotten his team to playoffs 50% or less of the time

your logic: it has flaws

[Fishhead]

your logic: it has flaws

More then a few .........

[jjgold]

Fishhead I know QB's very well and Mcnaab is a winner compared to 90% of NFL Qb's.

[THE PROFIT]

Ranked 4th among active QB's in winning% between Manning & Favre. Very average guy

[2daBank]

Tell that to a Philly fan and see what they say........an intelligent Philly fan that is.

not the easiest thing to find

[hoopster42]

they just gave mcnabb ALL the motivation he needs by trading him w/in the division

[BigdaddyQH]

The mistake you guys are making is trying to compare McNabb of 5 years ago to McNabb of today. Today he is old, past his prime, and injury prone. He has always been a choke artist. His play against Dallas in his last two games of last season was horrid. He was flat terrible. There are at least 10 QB's who are better than McNabb is TODAY, and TODAY is the only thing that counts.

No one will argue that McNabb had a very good NFL career. To do so is foolish. But the bottom line is that he has a losers mentality, can be a cancer in the locker room, and never won a Superbowl. He only got there once. He lost 3 out of 4 NFC CHampionship games. To expect him to get to another NFC Championship game with a very poor team and a coach who'se entire career was based on one player is just asking for way too much.

[Bannit16]

This is a really good move for the eagles and redskins. No matter how you look it at Mcnabb is better then campbell. The eagles have a great backup in Kolb who is more then ready to take over. The eagles and redskins are going to be better teams.

[slacker00]

The mistake you guys are making is trying to compare McNabb of 5 years ago to McNabb of today.

I haven't noticed that much of a dropoff. If anything, he's coming off one of his best seasons as a QB.

Sure, he had a couple clunkers against the Cowboys who were finally coming together as a team after years of underachieving. If anything, give some credit to the Cowboys defense.

[preplus]

11 seasons in, he has better numbers than Elway.

[Fishhead]

AVERAGE QB at this time........................AT BEST.

[BigdaddyQH]

AVERAGE QB at this time........................AT BEST.

I totally agree. Washington has a washed up QB and a washed up HC. They think they can turn the clock back 5-10 years and have a major rebirth of these two. Will they improve on their 4-12 record of last year? More than likely, but how much worse could it get? Have they thrown away the future of the team? Absolutely.

[GELATINOUS CUBE]

He's hot and cold. But when he's on, he dumps on points like... no QB I can think of besides Brees.

[GELATINOUS CUBE]

The Redskins are similar with real good WRs who are kinda fickle. So I say it's a good match. Watch for some OVERs.

[PAULYPOKER]

Very average QB, ESPECIALLY at this stage of his career. Another f ucking blunder by the Redskins organization, which has been a common theme of theirs for the past 15 years or so.

1.He is by far the best QB in the Eagles franchise history by a landslide!!!!!

2.He is by far the best QB ever signed by the Skins in their history!!!!

3. Are you feeling OK??????

[GELATINOUS CUBE]

What.. Sounds like you're a mcnabb fan. I think he's pretty good too, just watch the eagles games and you'll see he plays terrible sometimes, same with santana and randle-el.
They'll have some real good games, and other times play bad..

[Rig]

He's still probably above average
he's fundamentally sound and should still do a good job running mikes offense

[OmgUrMom]

what do you mean by "us people" ?? HUH HUH!!??

[PAULYPOKER]

What.. Sounds like you're a mcnabb fan. I think he's pretty good too, just watch the eagles games and you'll see he plays terrible sometimes, same with santana and randle-el. They'll have some real good games, and other times play bad..

I'm not really a fan but I give credit where credit is due this poor guy has been taking it in the ass from day one from all sides of the spectrum including non sports media Hmmmmmmm..... I wonder if his skin color has anything to do with it I guess I'll never know

[bruceBRUCEbruce]

1.He is by far the best QB in the Eagles franchise history by a landslide!!!!!

so he's the tallest midget? great.

every W the eagles had last season was against non-playoff teams.

every L the eagles had last season was against playoff teams.