Originally Posted by
Snowball
This version of the Celtics is not mature enough to win a title like the others were. As a Celtics fan, it was not easy for me to bet on Golden State to win this, but I had to because I'm a handicapper. We all encounter this tension. I encountered it in the previous series where very uncharacteristically, I shuffled back and forth between the Celtics and Milwaukee and Miami. That never would have happened with the Celtics teams of past years. But there's a number of factors concerning this team that are just not ready to win a title. Al Horford has been the biggest reason they got this far. Horford and Smart. But the Celtics don't have a pure point guard. That's a problem. One that really manages the plays and changes the way his forwards and guards play offense. Rondo did that.
Another issue is Tatum and Brown really have not matured as position basketball players. They are all over the place. Because both can score from deep, especially Tatum, there is confusion. Tatum doesn't know what to do with the ball, shoot, pass or penetrate. He decides at the last minute.. right at the last second. That's a mark of an unformed offense. Improvisation cannot be the default style of a championship team unless you are packed with all-star veterans. They need a point guard to direct them. I doubt Marcus Smart could even be that guy because Smart is more a natural shooting guard and disruptor on defense.
I never really felt comfortable in the Stevens coaching years. They spent too much time trying to form an identity that still has not fully been realised. When Danny Ainge stepped down and Stevens became chief of basketball operations I was like, okay, I can see why you're doing this, but who will be the coach? They took a risk with Udoka. The team because of its athleticism and talent was able to overcome Udoka's coaching shortcomings. To an extent. The extent witnessed this playoffs. Inconsistency. Losing leads and relying too much on improvisational play and hot shotmaking. This is why they run so hot and cold. It is why they turn the ball over. Because they honestly have no freaking idea what the play is. It's all improv. That is only going to get you so far because when the players are evenly matched, it is the X's and O's that win games.
What is the solution? Tatum or Brown / or Smart has to go. Pick one and replace him with either a true point guard or a true big man that knows his role. If it were up to me, I'd keep Smart, sign a point guard, trade Tatum or Brown. But if it were me, Stevens wouldn't be in charge, and Udoka wouldn't be coach. Stevens is not a true NBA manager or coach. He took the Butler philosophy and NCAA style into Boston. It is only going to get you so far. This is big man basketball. You have to know exactly what you are doing and do it without hesitation. That's why Golden State is coming through in the crunch.