Originally Posted by Mr. Teaser
You just made the point I have been making for years.....Very few have done less with more talent in the playoffs than Bill Cowher. Somehow Tomlin gets roasted and Cowher has always been given a free pass.
Largely true, but consider the QBs Cowher had until Ben came near the end of his career: Neil O'Donnell, Mike Tomczak, Kordell Stewart, Kent Graham, Tommy Maddox. You think that has something to do with not bringing home a championship?
When you lose conference championship games at home to a mediocre Chargers team you were favored by 9 and the qb was Stan Humphrey
when you lose another conference championship team to Denver you hosted at home
and the only home conference championship game game you won was to a Colts team you were favored by double digits over and it wasnt until the last play of the game that it was decided. The qb for the Colts was Jim Harbaugh
Also Cowher's lone super bowl was won with Big Ben as a rookie? and not playing that well. it was also given to them by the officials as the head official pretty much admitted to years later.
Back then you had a better chance of getting by without a star qb. Much more so than today anyway.
But your point is a valid one. It's easier to win with a good qb.