[Goat Milk]

A committee of of posters/mods/Walker.

Selection must be based on a combination of stats (wins, views), iFolds quality per post rating, career length, and many other things. It has to be very selective and cannot be biased (for example Nicky Santoro still hasn't done nearly enough to be selected, while Shari who joined two years later is already close to the HofF).

It must be a very prestigious award and not turn into a joke like Gold's poster of the year awards. This would be part of SBR history and not many names would be selected.

[Chi_archie]

you are dead wrong about nicky though

[ProfitBettingSov]

Nicky is a HoFer. First ballot.

[cleaveland]

I think the only way to make this fair is if the entire forum gets to vote where everyone can see everyone else's vote.

BTW, Nicky Santoro deserves to be a hall of famer for his performance in the team contest several years ago alone. He singly handedly won the contest for his team and demolished everyone else, it was incredible.

[Deuce]

Nicky is first ballot. Here are a few first balloters...

jjgold
Nicky
Cougar
Archie
Venditto
Zeta
Deuce
Bobby
Brock
Richkas

[Goat Milk]

you are dead wrong about nicky though

Archie he's had 1 solid posting year at SBR which was a great year. I'll compare him to Penny Hardaway.

[Goat Milk]

Nicky is first ballot. Here are a few first balloters...

jjgold
Nicky
Cougar
Archie
Venditto
Zeta
Deuce
Bobby
Brock
Richkas

This is the crew right here. Most of these guys are not hall of fame worthy. Venditto is already disqualified because of ghosts. Bobby has no shot at the hall of fame as of now. Richkas is not.

The rest of the names there are potential Hall of Famers.

If you start adding guys like Brock Landers then the award simply becomes a joke. This is why JJ Gold probably will not be allowed on the panel because he is biased towards that list.

[lakerboy]

Lol Deuce puts himself on the list.

[cleaveland]

This is the crew right here. Most of these guys are not hall of fame worthy. Venditto is already disqualified because of ghosts. Bobby has no shot at the hall of fame as of now. Richkas is not.

The rest of the names there are potential Hall of Famers.

If you start adding guys like Brock Landers then the award simply becomes a joke. This is why JJ Gold probably will not be allowed on the panel because he is biased towards that list.

Once you make a "panel" then it becomes political. I say the only fair way to do this is where you let the whole forum vote but selectively.

Management could make it so that only people with over say 1,000 posts and at least 5 years experience are allowed to vote for example. That would cut out 99% of ghosts and cheating right there.

The "panel" idea wll make it all political, we don't want that. Let the people decide!

[jjgold]

Deuce deserves to be on it

[Dad]

SBR needs a HoF. It's been brought up multiple times but has yet to be done.

Give the HoF'ers a badge maybe.

[Sunde91]

Impact on forum culture is paramount to being HOF. Nicky is tops in that regard. Nicky could have never posted again but his legacy would live on. Doesn't have to post consistently or give so many winners, just influence

[Nicky Santoro]

thanks guys. as for you goaters.. what the hell you trying to do destroy my confidence? why do you think i came back for? so i can try to be in the hall here at sbr.

goater, this is all i got. at least let me be in the hall. it's not like i am a winner in life with many accomplishments and awards. i'm probably in the top 3 sbr losers of all time. by taking this away from me and saying i don't deserve it would shatter my life.

Goater, i have 16,000 posts.. the breakdown is i have 15,850 posts from 2008 till 2010.. and 150 posts from 2011 and 2012 combined. so i slowed down a lot, big deal. i still had 2 amazing yrs here. you can't take those stats away from me. if an MLB player has great seasons, then has 2 bad seasons in a row, and then got injured or missed the next 2 seasons, won't he still go to the hall? those past #'s don't disappear.

Goater, i have a feeling i am still in the top 20 on the all time list here at sbr in total # posts.

Does anyone have access to these stats? i'd love to see em. i'd pay to see em. i wonder who is 2nd on the all time list in # of posts after JJ?

someone pls post it. i want to see it. i've gotta still be at #20 or better on the all time list at sbr, even though i missed the last 2 yrs.

[ProfitBettingSov]

This is the crew right here. Most of these guys are not hall of fame worthy. Venditto is already disqualified because of ghosts. Bobby has no shot at the hall of fame as of now. Richkas is not.

The rest of the names there are potential Hall of Famers.

If you start adding guys like Brock Landers then the award simply becomes a joke. This is why JJ Gold probably will not be allowed on the panel because he is biased towards that list.

Brock Landers is another HoFer.

[lakerboy]

Nicky is a first ballot hof'er at sbr. Goat you should know that. The problem with this whole idea is that most of these guys only think players talk is the only forum here while there have been some great contributors in the subforums.

[Goat Milk]

Santoro you might just have to stay another year or so to get inducted. If you retired today, it would be close. Maybe you are already worthy, that wouldn't be for me to decide. I'm not sure if you're top 20 in terms of posts. A lot of power posters now a days. There's a guy named No Coincidences that has 35,000 posts in the last 2.5 years but he's only got a 5% chance at the Hall.

[InTheDrink]

why is daddy not on deuce's list?

perversion is a HUGE part of sbr and daddy is like the michael jordan of perversion

over 25k post and at least 10k had to include broads in them

he should have his own wing as far as im concerned

[Goat Milk]

Nicky is a first ballot hof'er at sbr. Goat you should know that. The problem with this whole idea is that most of these guys only think players talk is the only forum here while there have been some great contributors in the subforums.

yeah you are right. You are a lock for the hall of fame and there are 2 others I can think of that only go into the subforums that should get in. The list has to be selective. It loses clout if there are too many posters inducted.

[wal66]

If there was a Posting Hall of Fame and Nicky Santoro (as Nicky Santoro not any of the other ghost) wasn't side by side with JJ then it would be a joke of a Hall of Fame.

If that roster shrinking oyster Shari was a first ballot Hall of Famer again it would be a joke.

[cleaveland]

If there was a Posting Hall of Fame and Nicky Santoro (as Nicky Santoro not any of the other ghost) wasn't side by side with JJ then it would be a joke of a Hall of Fame.

If that roster shrinking oyster Shari was a first ballot Hall of Famer again it would be a joke.

This is primarily a handicapping forum and I've only seen shari do a small bit of anything even resembling handicapping or anything like it. I agree with you.

[greenhippo]

Dudley liking a post, but haven't seen him post in weeks? The fukk is the dealio here?

[Nicky Santoro]

yeah, daddy does deserve to be inducted into the hall in the sex dept.. also, i remember once reading him going on 17-0 run betting. and most important, he has been part of at least 84 wack offs i had with those pics.. so right there, he should be in. those asian pics, those maids, those butts, those bozongos.... i say first ballot hall of famer..

somone pls post the all time #'s.. i am curious where i am. i was 3rd on the all time list when i left in late 2010.. but i know alot of new guys came in who have huge #'s, so if i am still top 25, i will throw a party tonight. who knows, i might be #59 on the all time list..

[Chi_archie]

put 3-5 guys in first ballot and sort the rest of this group over the next 6-12 months. maybe one per month

jjgold
nicky santoro
bigboydan
lt profits
sbr john
willie bee
buddy bear
pavyracer
onlooker
samodom
raiders
flying illini
tacomaxx

[Goat Milk]

Give the HoF'ers a button maybe.

Lot of support for Santoro. Maybe he's a lock. I think a nice button and an awards display case. It would be pretty easy to do. The hard part would be the voting.

[Cougar Bait]

Good idea, should be accompanied by a lifetime badge, similar to the founder badge

I also like the idea of posters with over a certain amount of posts maybe as (1) dozer/walker as (2) and select panel as (3) and give them all equal voting, highest average gets in. I think it would be cool to induct say 3 a year from a list of 20 or so. Who makes up the list though is a whole other deal.

[Cougar Bait]

thanks guys. as for you goaters.. what the hell you trying to do destroy my confidence? why do you think i came back for? so i can try to be in the hall here at sbr.

goater, this is all i got. at least let me be in the hall. it's not like i am a winner in life with many accomplishments and awards. i'm probably in the top 3 sbr losers of all time. by taking this away from me and saying i don't deserve it would shatter my life.

Goater, i have 16,000 posts.. the breakdown is i have 15,850 posts from 2008 till 2010.. and 150 posts from 2011 and 2012 combined. so i slowed down a lot, big deal. i still had 2 amazing yrs here. you can't take those stats away from me. if an MLB player has great seasons, then has 2 bad seasons in a row, and then got injured or missed the next 2 seasons, won't he still go to the hall? those past #'s don't disappear.

Goater, i have a feeling i am still in the top 20 on the all time list here at sbr in total # posts.

Does anyone have access to these stats? i'd love to see em. i'd pay to see em. i wonder who is 2nd on the all time list in # of posts after JJ?

someone pls post it. i want to see it. i've gotta still be at #20 or better on the all time list at sbr, even though i missed the last 2 yrs.

Pretty sure Pavy is second all time, something like 40K posts sounds about right

[Chi_archie]

adding
Illusion
ganchcrow
the hg (w/loshak)

[InTheDrink]

put 3-5 guys in first ballot and sort the rest of this group over the next 6-12 months. maybe one per month

jjgold
nicky santoro
bigboydan
lt profits
sbr john
willie bee
buddy bear
pavyracer
onlooker
samodom
raiders
flying illini
tacomaxx

kiss ass

bbd shouldnt be sniffing this list...embarrassing performance on the return as a mod...worst. mod. eva.

[JMobile]

Are betpoints involved when you make it into the HOF?
If not, no care.

[Chi_archie]

i'm mostly going for the first year with guys that started in 05 or 06

i've read back in those days.

it was mostly industry tyalk and you better believe walker and bbd contributed alot, as did others on the list. before it was a circus here

BBD has over 5ok posts

[flyingillini]

1ST Ballot for sure

[Chi_archie]

adding
Baus
pags11
LVherbie
RM18
Happyboy

[Sunde91]

sorry archie you're shitting up the place guys like pags haven't been relevant/active in any form in over 3 years if I'm not mistaken. Baus has like 1000 posts. Lvherbie?

[SportsPedagogy]

Lol Players Talk =/= All of SBR. Vaughny has one of the best and most profitable threads in all of SBR

[Matt Rain]

Vaughny has one of the best and most profitable threads in all of SBR

Who the fok cares about sports picks.